fb_connect
Sign in | 
FIND WHERE
- Amherst Restaurant Guide - See Menus, Reviews, Maps and Make Reservations for thousands of restaurants in Amherst and Massachusetts. -
78%
Say Yum
18 people voted
Carmelina's At The Commons ($$) $ - Cheap Eats (Under $10)
$$ - Moderate ($11-$25)
$$$ - Expensive ($25-$50)
$$$$ - Very Pricey (Over $50)
View Menu



96 Russell St
Hadley, MA 01035 (Map & Directions)
(413) 584-8000

Cuisine:   Italian
Location: Hadley > Hadley
Website: www.carmelinas.com/
Delivery: No Attire: Smart casual Reservations:
Wifi: No Parking: Alcohol:
Good for Kids: Outdoor Seats: Payment: Accepts Credit Cards
Description: Piano Bar
 

Add Photo of Restaurant
User Reviews for Carmelina's At The Commons
John posted on 11/24/2010
Rating & Review:
review_stars
My wife and I went there for dinner on Saturday night and it was amazing. The carbonara was the best I have ever had, my wife's beef short rib was "succulent" and those were just the appetizers!!!The drinks were top shelf and the the young lady who served us was gracious and professional.
Scott posted on 04/28/2010
Rating & Review:
review_stars
I've gone to Carmelina's for many years but the past year has discouraged me from returning. Recently they lost their chef. I always order linguini with clams and red sauce and it has always been incredible, not anymore. The sauce was heavy, thick and chunky, without much flavor. My waiter suggested that I mention it to the owner, who was patronizing and dismissive. This same owner was abusive and possibly racist toward a very charming hostess who worked there last year. I saw her in tears out in the parking lot and she told me her story, which I believe. No more Carmelina's for me! It's not what it used to be!
posted on 02/01/2009
Rating & Review:
review_stars
After many years of enjoying some of the best dinning experiences of our lives, the change in management at Carmelina's has broken through. Starting with our drinks, 3 out of 4 of us ordered a margaritas from the page in the menu exclusively dedicated to these signature cocktails. One of the glasses had a marble sized chip on the rim of the glass and the drinks tasted like sugar water. We returned all of them and settled for some wine instead. The "favorite selection of house specialties" Chicken Catalina reminded me of what baby food tastes like prior to being pureed. No WOW factor here anymore. We noticed the manager having to make at least two trips to diners to correct or apologize for unsatisfactory meals. This restaurant is no longer on my list of favorite restaurants. We won't be back.
posted on 09/01/2007
Rating & Review:
review_stars
If you love authentic Italian food, stop at Carmelitas at the Common for absolutely delicious food in a relaxing atmosphere. You won't regret it. And especially try one of the desserts-decedent and delicious.


See Larger Map


Recent Yum Votes
Stables Sandwich Shoppe ($)
       Breakfast, American, Sandwiches
Mi Tierra ($)
       Mexican
Mi Tierra ($)
       Mexican
Carmelina's At The Commons ($$)
       Italian
McDonald's ($)
       Burgers
Young Mens Club of Hadley Incorporated ($$)
       Bar Food
Stables Sandwich Shoppe ($)
       Breakfast, American, Sandwiches
Stables Sandwich Shoppe ($)
       Breakfast, American, Sandwiches
Primo Pizzeria ($$)
       Pizza
Stables Sandwich Shoppe ($)
       Breakfast, American, Sandwiches

People Who Viewed this also Viewed
Arizona Pizza Company ($)
       Pizza, American, Italian
Route 9 Diner ($$)
       Breakfast, Sandwiches, Burgers
Pizza Hut ($)
       Pizza


Have You Eaten Here?   Yes   No