86% say Yum
93 people voted
86% say Yum
93 people voted
People Who Viewed This Also Viewed
Milano's Pizza ($)
Muldoon Pizza ($$)
Pizza, Subs, Sandwiches
Sparta Pizza ($$)
Greek, Pizza, Sandwiches, Subs
Milano's Pizza ($)
| Add Photo
Is this your restaurant? Click to add your description here.
Hours: Add Hours
Credit Cards Accepted
$ - Cheap Eats (Under $10)
$$ - Moderate ($11-$25)
$$$ - Expensive ($25-$50)
$$$$ - Very Pricey (Over $50)
Good for Kids
Reviews of Pizza Plaza
10/15/2014 - Larry E Compton Jr
My wife and I have been eating at pizza plaza since the early 1970's with our parents and then as a couple and even had Christmas dinners there thru the company that my wife used to work for. But recently it seems the food has been going down hill. Last time we ate there my wife's chicken fettuccini wasn't that good and this time it was terrible and my pizza had a 1/2" of raw dough all but the crust which I usually take home and reheat later. This time I told the waitress we didn't want to go boxes she asked if anything was wrong we replied yes the food was awful and explained why. She was very nice and apologetic brought us our check I left a 20% tip and I think our 40 year relationship is over
04/09/2014 - An unsatisfied customer
Just waited almost two hours for the actual manager named Tosta or something like that to deliver the food himself. Upon arrival food was cold and on top of that he didn't want to give me my $5 in change. He said he didn't have any change at first but, when I stuck to my guns he brought out a wad of cash with plenty singles and a couple twenties. My advice, if you order from this establishment make sure they know how to find out where you are and PAY IN EXACT CHANGE.
03/29/2014 - Frank Mennah
I used to love the pizza but that's like 6 years ago! <br />
me and my wife whent today for lunch and I didn't remember why it is such a long time that we where regulars at this place!<br />
Not to late later I can now recall that every time we go I get seek! Today we whent at 1:30 pm got a halibut a la plaza $29 dollars!! And the amount of fish really small and it wasn't even a fillet it look like little scattered pices here and there on top of the pasta!! Ok it is 1:37 am I'm still awake trying to get better I been seek all day and I still have the taste of the food!! Bad!!!!!! I will never go back
04/08/2012 - haffy
I ordered a calzone from them last week and it was a big dissapointment. Not only was it not in fact a calzone (it was a stromboli) but it was very small. Not only was it in fact small, but it was missing the salad that it says comes with it. For 16 bucks I would expect much more than this. Suffice it to say I will not be ordering from here again.
08/26/2010 - S. Mitchell
We absolutely love this place. It's nice to be able to have a full meal delivered to our door, and it's even nicer to dine in. Our favorites are the calzones and the shrimp dishes.
06/07/2010 - Laura Jansen
This place as been around forever and is one of the best restaurants in town. THE SERVICE IS ALWAYS WONDERFUL AND THE FOOD IS FANTASTIC!!!!!!<br />
as far as a bad review goes-I think sometimes when people have bad experiences at places, they usually come in with an attitude. We always are welcomed warmly and treated great. Best pizza in town and their pasta usually feeds me there plus 2 more leftovers at home (IT'S ALOT!). The baklava is to die for-best I've ever eaten. As far as the atmosphere-it's wonderful-you can actually carry on a conversation and hear each other, and what's better than Dean Martin singing in the background!! Pizza Plaza-live on forever!!!!!!
01/30/2010 - Brenda
Best delivery available 4 seafood, reliable, consistent, and fresh i am told (fresh not frozen).... a yummy treat... expensive...
12/21/2009 - Kim
Okay, I admit the service is not always great but don't let anyone fool you the food is fantastic. It is in a funky old strip mall but they remodeled a few years ago and it is nice enough. If you don't like the atmosphere then just get the food to go or delivered. This restaurant has been around for years and the owners are from the old country. They know how to cook authentic Italian and Greek food. It says Pizza Plaza but the menu is so much more. I have never been disappointed.
11/29/2009 - Brandy
Very good spaghetti and meatballs. Stuffed shrimp was good too. Tried their new spinach salad also very good and much lighter. Will definitely eat there again!
10/23/2009 - Jan
This is my favorite restaurant in town; however, my last visit there was rather disappointing, and even unsettling. I ordered the Halibut Olympia, my favorite dish. I had to send the first order back, which I had never done at a restaurant. The second order looked and at first tasted much better than the first attempt, unfortunately, the halibut was raw when I bit into the center. I am worried that a change in chefs has occurred recently because I have heard several other die hard Pizza Plaza fans make similar comments about recent visits. I hope this situation improves, and I hope the ownership reads this and takes it as kink criticism, because I really enjoy eating at this restaurant. Chow.
10/19/2009 - Susan
The best hidden secret in Anchorage!! Love the gyros and stuffed mushrooms! Our favorite italian restaurant!
09/04/2009 - Hungry
Awful place. Strip mall. Mediocre food that took forever to arrive. Waitress had to be reminded about my drink - I changed the drink at that point so she brought both... Called everyone "kiddo". First one person's food arrived. Then later another person's food (a bland pizza) arrived. About 10 minutes later the waitress brought a plate. Had to eat the pizza off the pan... We sat and sat waiting for something to eat - and when it arrived it was pretty plain. Cookie-cutter cheap Italian fare. Nothing special here. Don't bother. Go to Pizza Hut...
Always good food, with a nice atmosphere. A hidden Anchorage jewel.
My friend and I had dinner there last Friday night, the service was great, very friendly and professional, the food was OUTSTANDING! My friend had the...
Fast delivery but the portions were small, my baby kitty could of eaten everything. I ordered steamed rice and received vegetable, when my boyfrien...
Kava's Pancake house
okay went there with my wife, it took 30 minutes to order the food was not what we ordered first time coming here after hearing good things qbout this...
The Bar-B-Q Pit
I can't believe I have lived in Anchorage for 30 years and today is the first time I have eaten here! The baby back ribs were the best I've had anywh...
Great food! Great price! Great service! Don't waste your time and $$$ at Shine's. Jimmy's is located in the old Shine's restaurant and is a thousand t...