Sign in | 
- Delaware Restaurant Guide - See Menus, Reviews, Maps and Make Reservations for thousands of restaurants in Delaware. -
Say Yum
5 people voted
Serendipity Restaurant ($) $ - Cheap Eats (Under $10)
$$ - Moderate ($11-$25)
$$$ - Expensive ($25-$50)
$$$$ - Very Pricey (Over $50)

32580 River Rd
Millsboro, DE 19966 (Map & Directions)
(302) 945-3600

Cuisine:   Italian
Location: Sussex County > Millsboro
Delivery: No Attire: Casual Reservations:
Wifi: No Parking: Yes Alcohol:
Good for Kids: Outdoor Seats: Payment: Accepts Credit Cards

User Reviews for Serendipity Restaurant
Cynthia posted on 12/26/2012
Rating & Review:
Serendipity should be closed. The food that is being served is nasty, frozen and not at all fresh. As a patron you are not allowed to complain about the days old spoiled food or else Michael the manager/owner immdediately phones police and creates bogus stories of how you are refusing to pay. No replacement or compensation was offered for our disturbing experience. The wait staff is hostile, unfriendly and just as racist as the owner. <br /> <br /> Following my lackluster experience I have now filed complaints with the BBB and am urging food critics to visit this establisment. Eat here at your own risk!!!
mike posted on 08/12/2010
Rating & Review:
i generally don't write these thing but after reading jeanette scathing rnt about the music at serendipity i must respond. i was one of the other tables ther at the time and the music changed frequently and what jeanette describes as screaming was in fact ella, and bette, and blossom dearie and frank. she was just as miserable as she could be and no amount of graciousness from the staff could appease her. the music there is a eclectic mix of jazz r&b and old standards i never heard the screaming
Jeannette posted on 08/09/2010
Rating & Review:
I have been to Serendipity several times and had a wonderful time. Tonight was different. We were celebrating one of our party's birthday. There were only about four couples in the whole restuarant. The music was so loud and obnoxious, we couldn't hear each other at our table. We asked nicely several times to turn it down or change the tape. It was turned down just a little, but the never-ending singing (and that's stretching it a bit), lasted practically the whole meal. We were told they were not allowed to change the tape unless the owner did it. I can't believe anyone would enjoy that particular CD and that they couldn't have just pushed a button and put on the next CD. I am very disappointed to think that the staff (or the owners/managers) of this nice restaurant does not care if they ruin what could have been a perfectly nice evening. I doubt if any of us will return anytime in the near future.
JoAnn posted on 08/08/2010
Rating & Review:
Having been to this restaurant before, I was excited to take my entire family to Serendipity for a special dinner. Unfortunately, most of us ordered a meal that contained spaghetti sauce. The sauce tasted burnt, it was DARK red/brown, and it covered our meals to the extent you didn't know what was underneath. Respectfully, we pointed this out to the owner who communited our concern to the cook. The cook's response was, if they didn't like it, "Let them go to Bella's." I can promise WE will. Cost me a bundle and we all walked away hungry!!!! Our special night was ruined.
Lisa posted on 08/07/2010
Rating & Review:
It was fantastic! The view from the restaurant,the decor,the friendly staff and the wonderful food is highly recommended!!!I especially enjoyed the conversation at the bar with owners mother while we waited for our table.
Gary B. posted on 09/28/2009
Rating & Review:
Such a shame that there are such MISERABLE people trying to rip this GREAT restaurant apart! It's the BEST restaurant bar none in Sussex County.Clean,Exciting,Ever changing decor,Fresh HOME MADE food,Top quility ingredients,Excellent service,who could ASK for more?NEVER a disappointment in the 6 years that we have dined there.Maybe these nay sayers should stick with the fast food chains moe on their comfort and expectation level!!!!!
Gary Lusby posted on 09/17/2009
Rating & Review:
The food was cold, the vegetables were watery and bland, the baked potatoes were microwaved to death, and they charged for the bread. I would never go there again.
mike le pera posted on 09/10/2009
Rating & Review:
great food and interesting atmosphere! i think this is the cleanest restaurant i've ever seen italian food is best in delaware
Richard Bennett posted on 08/31/2009
Rating & Review:
This place is not where you want to go! The wait staff are so unfriendly and the waiting time for your order is eXceptionally long. Our food was cold when it arrived and no apology from the owner! This is the restaurant you want to recommend to your worst enemy!! NEVER AGAIN!
Sandy Teigler posted on 08/19/2009
Rating & Review:
This is truly the worst restaurant that my family and I have ever gone to! First of all they messed up our order...we only ordered pizza so it does not take a rocket scientist to make this. After almost TWO hours of waiting, we had to leave. The owner is the most rudest and obnoxious person that I have ever met! No apologies, only a very nasty attitude like he was doing the world a favor! Someone else sent back their chicken because it was not cooked all the way! Again, the owner had a bad attitude. So much for "the customer is always right!" Save yourself a lot of grief, don't go here if you want to have a nice evening out without waiting for two hours and then getting uncooked food!
posted on 01/15/2009
Rating & Review:
this place is really neat ! super clean restaurant with the biggest lasagna i've ever seen. highly recommend

Get Directions - See Larger Map


Recent Yum Votes
Sal's Pizza Gallery Three ($)
       Pizza, Subs, Sandwiches
Agave ($$$)
Pizza King ($$)
       Pizza, Subs
Milford Diner ($$)
       Diner, American
Hong Kong Chinese Restaurant ($)
West Side Restaurant ($$)
Hing Wang Chinese Restaurant ($$)
Holiday Chicken ($)
Alfredo's Pizza Gallery ($)
       Pizza, Subs, Sandwiches
China Wok ($)

People Who Viewed this also Viewed
Long Neck Deli ($)
Bona Pizza ($)
       Pizza, Italian, Mediterranean
Pizza Palace ($)
       Pizza, Sandwiches, Italian, Subs

Have You Eaten Here?   Yes   No