91% say Yum
332 people voted
91% say Yum
332 people voted
People Who Viewed This Also Viewed
Xtrodinary Pizza ($)
Ed's Pub & Pizza ($$)
Pizza, Subs, Sandwiches
Big Kahuna's ($)
Pizza, Sandwiches, Subs
Aunt Polly's ($$)
Pizza, Barbecue, Sandwiches, Subs
See All 7 Photos
| Add Photo
Is this your restaurant? Click to add your description here.
Mon-Wed: 3pm - 1:30 am, Thu: 3pm - 3am, Fri-Sun: 3pm - 3am
Credit Cards Accepted
$ - Cheap Eats (Under $10)
$$ - Moderate ($11-$25)
$$$ - Expensive ($25-$50)
$$$$ - Very Pricey (Over $50)
Good for Kids
Reviews of Aunt Polly's
10/09/2014 - Nichols b.
If you want awesome pizza,minus the frills and fast delivery you have no reason to not be ordering from Aunt Pollys Pizza. Their new location is hands down the fastest they've ever had and their menu will satisfy even the pickest of pizza orders. The ham and cheese? Fantastic. Philly cheese steak the same. Great pizza,great bread sticks.and a great operation, any negative review's and reviewers should probably review their own life decisions before choosing to deride what is a long standing east side pizza institution. Their new location is the ultimate in pizza choices. Sure you could spend five times more as long as it is before 10 pm . Is their pizza better sure if you absolutely need feta ,spinach or fresh basil as toppings, I guess so. If you want good pizza late night then there is no comparison,and service? Forget it no one beats Aunt Pollys in terms of turn around,efficiency and quality on the east side
05/13/2014 - seth46219
Sausage Pepperoni calzone<br />
"THE ORIGINAL OWNERS ARE BACK AND DOING THINGS RIGHT......<br />
I eat alot of pizza I love it all, from the chicago style, the the thin uptight spinach and tomato kind. I have to say though that i am glad i stopped in and ordered here.. They have a pretty low key place, but dont let it fool you they know about great food and outstanding customer service. I have ordered to go and had delivery both great. A big thing to me is the quality of cheese and the sauce.... both of theres is great.... No matter if I am doing a review or if i am just feeding my hungry family I will go back to them......<br />
CALL THE ORIGINAL AUNT POLLY's...NEw number ....638-FOOD....638-3663<br />
great food guys keep it up" - IndyPizzaReview<br />
03/12/2014 - Darlene w
This place is awesome their pizza is great their ribs are good and real tender.they have the worlds best BBQ sauce.cheese cake omg real good homade taste. I will be back to order again real soon thanks for dinner aunt pollys.
02/08/2014 - Dave B Cleveland,Ohio
If you want awesome pizza,minus frills and with fast delivery,you have no reason to not be ordering from aunt pollys.Teir nrw location is hands down the fastest they've ever had and their menu will satisfy even the pickiest of pizza orders. Ham and cheese sandwich? FANTASTIC.Philly cheese steak? the same great pizza great sticks and a great operation.any negative reviews and reviewers should probably review their own life decicions before choosing to depride what is a long standing eastside pizza institution.Their new location is the ultimate in pizza choices, Sure you could spend five times more. as long as its before 10pm and go to jockomos. its their pizza better? If you absolutely ned Feta,spinsh or fresh basil as topping i guess so if you want good pizza late light then there is no comparison.and service? Forget it. no one beats aunt pollys in terms of turn around ,efficency and quality on the eastside.
12/16/2013 - Eric-W
Late night at its best. These guys have the best subs and pizza, late night or not. The philly is awesome. And they have dessert. Including pumpkin pie.
Wild Card Pizza
(Beech Grove, IN)
Food is great!! Young man that waited on me & the wife was very nice as well!!...
Let's face it. This location is sort of awful in more than one respect. It's not the cleanest place on earth nor are it's employees overly friendly ...
Those fries! Oh my goodness. I love getting the enormous portion which includes all of the dipping sauces. There are so many to love that you can't...
Applebee's Neighborhood Grill
Now this is how an Applebee's should be. I had the beef meatballs, the spinach dip, and the chocolate churros for dessert. The meatballs were large, ...
This is the place to go to eat LOTS of it. It's all-you-can-eat. It's not a buffet, but rather a place where you take a marker and mark what you wan...