87% say Yum
254 people voted
87% say Yum
254 people voted
People Who Viewed This Also Viewed
Pizza King Wea Plaza ($)
Pizza, Subs, Sandwiches
Mancino's Pizza & Grinders ($)
Pizza, Subs, Sandwiches
The Pickle ($)
Wraps, Pizza, Salads, Subs
Magnifico Pizza ($)
Pizza, Subs, Sandwiches, Salads
| Add Photo
We here at the Magnifico family thank you for your patronage. We are a family owned buisness. Everything we make is made fresh to order just for you. We welcome everyone to try our famous Chicago style pizza. Mention this and RECIEVE 10% OFF all regular priced orders.
sun-wed 4-10 thurs-sat 12-10
Yes - call for delivery info.
Accepts Credit Cards
$ - Cheap Eats (Under $10)
$$ - Moderate ($11-$25)
$$$ - Expensive ($25-$50)
$$$$ - Very Pricey (Over $50)
Reviews of Magnifico Pizza
02/23/2013 - Steve Treece
I've been able to try this pizzeria from where I work . Unbelievably good !!! Would be a long standing customer , if not for the poor service !! I recently called to place an order for delivery . To my surprise , the person taking the orders not only didn't want accomodate my place of delivery , but was also very rude to me over the phone . I was ready place an order for over $40 & I live one block from where I work ! I know they deliver to my neighborhood , because of its close proximity to my work . Too bad !!! Great pizza , bad business :(
04/23/2012 - Dago T
I like the person who complained about driving all the way across town. IT'S LAFAYETTE FREAGGIN INDIANA!!! I can ride a bike clear across town in 45 minutes. What did you have to stop for gas?
BTW, the pizza here is really good. And I am inclined to make my own at home from scratch, and I mean my own sauce, dough, AND sausage.
04/08/2011 - FoodGal
Oh this place has GREAT food!!! It may not look like much from the outside but don't judge a book by it's cover! Their pizza is awesome!!! I'm not a big Chicago-style-pizza fan but all of my friends & coworkers insisted I try the "Chicago deep dish" at Magnifico's. I did.....& oh was it ever sooooo good!!! I am also a big fan of their stuffed bread sticks! They are huge!!!! I have so many good things to say about this place! I highly recommend you give it a try a.s.a.p.
04/06/2011 - very unsatisfied customer
So check this out, folks. I called last night at 9:30 pm to order a pizza. Some bimbo girl answers the phone and attempts to stumble through the ordering process. I order what she tells me is that night's special: a 14" pizza with unlimited toppings. She tells me that it'll be 35-40 minutes. Since she never even bothered to ask my delivery preference, I asked her if that was for pick-up and she said, "Well, we have delivery, too." I said that I would pick it up (to make it easier for her), and she responded by telling me that it would again be 35-40 minutes. Now, I know the place closes at 10 pm, but I figured that since there would still be people cleaning up after they lock the doors, they would still serve me (since she took my order). My girlfriend and I drive over from the west side to pick up the pizza. We arrive at 10:12, 42 minutes after I hung up the phone. The door was locked, the lights were off, and nobody was there. I drove across town for absolutely nothing. Gas is $4/gallon. Screw you guys. If you quit taking orders at a certain time, just say so. Just because you're "family-run" doesn't mean you need to hire the high school dropouts of your family. It takes time to clean a restaurant at the end of the day. Either the employees shut the kitchen down long before ten, or they don't clean their kitchen. Either way, regardless of how the pizza tastes (not like I would know), these people do not deserve any business. The comments on here saying, "Awe, feel bad for them. They're family-run, and they try really hard," are obviously friends of the family and get much better service than the regular people. If they actually cared about their customers, I wouldn't have gone to bed hungry and livid last night.
04/06/2011 - hungry_dude
Monday night: they don't answer their phone after trying for 30 minutes (around 6:00pm). Wednesday night: their phone doesn't even ring anymore, you get a message saying "this customer is not taking calls at this number". Guess they're outa business. Or they just don't know how to run a business.
04/03/2011 - pizza fanatic
People let me tell you its great. The short and sweet is that its family owned and they put love into there product. Ill be back keep up the good work. Oh and the lady in the front your a sweetie!
03/29/2011 - Wms Family of 6
We visited this pizza place late night while on a small vacation in the Dunes.They were closing and stayed open for my family.They didn't rush us,they just continued their closing and making the pizza fresh right it front of us..And oh wow are we happy they did. They were (new) open just a short time.The pizza is superb the service is excellent, fast, and friendly. We still talk about this pizza and will drive 2hrs to dine again. ITS
THE BEST.....please start shipping.
03/25/2011 - Tony
magnifico's is like a freakin' domino's in Chicago
03/16/2011 - CTro
Really delicious deep dish pizza... great to have them in the neighborhood.
03/14/2011 - Me to Magnificos
The pizza joint is tiny its family owned and they do what they can to make people happy bc it is so small they probably can't afford to have 20 people on there its not pizza hut u have to wait for food but at least its worth it in the end so people quit bitchen they r doing awesome keep up the good work oh and the girl that works there she is the sweetest :)
12/08/2010 - sam
I love the food, but they say on this website mention the add n get 10% off but the man who answered said since I was just above the delivery minimum he wasnt gonna give me the discount..thats false advertising, I am one person..
11/01/2010 - Kala M.
I have tried the chicago style deep dish and it was wonderful! no complains here! thinking about getting some tonight and pigging out:)
09/29/2010 - TheCritic
Horrible service and overpriced. Just because you own a pizza oven doesn't mean you must inflict it upon the populace. Must have gotten family members to leave good reviews.
08/05/2010 - Downtown Resident
This pizza is awesome! No regrets!
08/01/2010 - ljbeagles
Try this pizza. You won't be sorry!
07/02/2010 - Joy Kane
Super great! Very good pizza.
07/02/2010 - ML
Amazing!!!!! does not even come close to describing the taste of this GENUINELY AUTHENTIC Chicago Stuffed Pizza The word "style" was intentionally left out because this pizza is as good as if not better than any pizza I have had when in in Chicago. Before this, for 20 years, GIORDANO'S "World Famous" Chicago pizza was my gold standard, but this pizza is unquestionably equal to if not better than that of GIORDANO'S.
06/16/2010 - Southsider
The Chicago style stuffed pizza was GREAT! The sauce, as well as all of the other ingredients, were very fresh and tasted like homemade. They even were nice enough to deliver it to us on the southside of Lafayette! We will be coming back again and again!
05/30/2010 - PAPA JOHNS PIZZA DELIVERY GUY
THIS IS SOOOO MUCH BETTER THAN WHAT WE MAKE EAT HERE MORE OFTEN!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!POLKA TRANSAACTIONS
05/28/2010 - Laura
This is the best pizza I've had in a long time. It may be $18 for their stuffed pizza but I assure you this thing is a monster and will leave you with plenty of leftovers. Go for it, you will be glad you did!
05/14/2010 - pustudent
This is something this city has been missing for some time. its a small family owned business with a hand full of hard workers. i order from their often and have become familiar with the place and the people. there is sometimes a wait but its definitely worth it.....Its a 7 lbs pizza, how fast can they cook it!!! doing a great job guys, keep up the good work
05/02/2010 - Betty Boop 26
Best Chicago style pizza! Great service and fair prices. Absolutely delicious! Keep it up Magnificos!
03/04/2010 - Tyson from Buckles Feed Depot
a local small business. feel good points for supporting some hard workers. good quality ingredients, and a good selection of menu items. Tuskan Chicken sandwich is a must try. You can tell they like food, because they know how to cook. They are definitely out to please there customers. Close enough to Purdue!
(West Lafayette, IN)
They make you pay for something you don't ask for and chicken isn't fully cooked and in the silver grill they add something in it that isn't in the me...
We have eaten here many times, and we've always had great service and great food. Their prices are much better than a lot of places in the area, too....
O'Bryans Nine Irish Brothers
(West Lafayette, IN)
My husband and I opted to eat here after Lafayette's annual Christmas party. When we arrived, we were just about the only ones eating here.
The food is absolutely amazing. Unfortunately the service was horrible. It took almost 2 hours to get our food. The table next to us had the same issu...
New York Cafe
The service was poor.
My daughter found a hair in her chicken wrap. Her "new" wrap was replaced on same plate, with the extra buffal...