fb_connect
Sign in | 
FIND WHERE
- Long Island Restaurant Guide - See Menus, Reviews, Maps and Make Reservations for thousands of restaurants in Long Island and New York. -


Best Shelter Island Restaurants
Sweet Tomato's ($)
       American
Dory ($$)
       American
Cafe 27 ($)
       American, Cafe, Sandwiches
Cannery Row Cafe At Alfreds ($$)
       Cafe
Island Cafe ($)
       Cafe, Sandwiches




town_pic
New Search
Narrow by Cuisine

Shelter Island Restaurant Guide

restaurant listings
Found 15 restaurants (Showing 1 to 15)
Result page: << 1 >>

arrow_img Cafe 27 ($)
American, Cafe, Sandwiches
  27 N Ferry Rd (631) 749-2727
arrow_img Cannery Row Cafe At Alfreds ($$)
Cafe
  63 Menantic Rd (631) 749-2516
arrow_img Dory ($$)
American
2 votes
  185 N Ferry Rd (631) 749-4300
menu available
arrow_img Island Cafe ($)
Cafe, Sandwiches
  63 S Menantic Rd (631) 749-3355
menu available
arrow_img Michael Anthony's At Dering ($$)
American
  65 S Menantic Rd (631) 749-3460
arrow_img Olde Country Inn ($)
American, Southern, Cafe
  11 Stearns Point Rd (631) 749-1633
menu available
arrow_img On Shore ($$)
American
  13 Winthrop Rd (631) 749-2300
arrow_img Pat & Steve's Family Restaurant ($)
American
  63 N Ferry Rd (631) 749-1998
arrow_img Planet Bliss ($$)
American
  23 N Ferry Rd (631) 749-0053
menu available
arrow_img Primo Pizza & Restaurant ($)
Pizza, Subs, Sandwiches
  53 Ferry Rd (631) 749-2732



arrow_img Shelter Island Bake Shop ($$)
American
  27 N Ferry Rd (631) 749-2717
arrow_img Sweet Tomato's ($)
American
6 votes
  15 Grand Ave (631) 749-4114
menu available
arrow_img Tuck Shop ($)
Australian
  75 Menantic Rd (631) 749-1548
menu available
arrow_img Two Eds ($$)
American
  1 N Ferry Rd (631) 749-0261
arrow_img Vine Street Cafe ($)
Cafe, Sandwiches
  41 S Ferry Rd (631) 749-3210
menu available
Result page: << 1 >>