Pie Pan

Pie Pan > Menu

Prices and menu items are subject to change. Contact the restaurant for the most up to date information.

From the Garden

  • $10.99

    Chicken Pecan Salad

    Grilled chicken on fresh greens with pecans, shredded cheese, carrots, tomatoes and house-made croutons
  • $10.99

    Crispy Chicken Tender Salad

    Fried chicken tenders on fresh greens with shredded cheese, carrots, tomatoes, and house-made croutons
  • $9.29

    Pie Pan Chicken Salad

    Our house-made chicken salad on leaf lettuce served with tomato and a cup of soup or seasonal fruit
  • $10.99

    Chef Salad

    Ham, turkey and bacon on fresh greens with shredded cheese, tomatoes, and house-made croutons
  • $6.49

    Spinach Side Salad

    Fresh spinach topped with sliced egg, onion, crumbled bacon and house-made croutons
  • $5.99

    Side Salad

    Fresh greens with shredded cheese, tomatoes, carrots and house-made croutons

Quiche

  • $8.99

    Spinach Quiche

    Spinach, onion, Swiss and parmesan cheese served with a cup of soup or fresh fruit
  • $9.49

    Quiche Lorraine

    Ham, onion, Swiss and parmesan cheese served with a cup of soup or fresh fruit

Seasonal Soups

  • Vegetable Beef

  • Soup of the Day

  • $8.99

    Soup and Salad

    A cup of our soup served with a side salad and our famous hot roll

Soup & Sandwich

  • $9.69

    1/2 Sandwich and cup of soup

    Choose 1/2 Sandwich: BLT Grilled Cheese Tuna Salad Chicken Salad Turkey Bacon Avocado Grilled Pimento Cheese Choose Cup of Soup: Vegetable Beef Soup of the day

Sandwiches

  • $10.29

    Pie Pan Classic Club

    Smoked ham and turkey, bacon, American cheese, lettuce, tomato and mayonnaise on toasted Artisan wheat bread
  • $9.29

    Chicken Salad

    Our house-made chicken salad, lettuce and tomato on toasted wheat bread
  • $10.29

    Philly Cheesesteak

    Grilled steak topped with sautéed mushrooms, green peppers, onions and melted cheese on a hoagie roll
  • $8.99

    Grilled Pimento Cheese

    Our house-made pimento cheese on grilled Artisan wheat bread
  • $10.29

    Tuna Melt

    Our house-made tuna salad on grilled Artisan wheat bread
  • $11.29

    Turkey Bacon Avocado

    Turkey, bacon, avocado, lettuce, tomato and mayonnaise on Artisan wheat bread
  • $9.69

    French Dip

    Thinly sliced roast beef piled high on a hoagie roll served with au jus
  • $9.29

    B. L. T.

    Thick sliced bacon with lettuce, tomato and mayonnaise on grilled Texas Toast
  • $9.69

    Fish Sandwich

    Breaded and fried cod filet with tartar sauce, dressed on a Kaiser roll
  • $9.69

    Fried Pork Tenderloin

    Deep fried pork tenderloin dressed as you choose on grilled Texas Toast
  • $10.29

    Chicken Wrap

    Fried tenders, cheddar cheese, lettuce and tomatoes wrapped in a flour tortilla served with ranch or honey mustard dressing
  • $10.29

    Grilled Chicken

    Grilled chicken breast dressed as you choose on a Kaiser roll
  • $11.49

    Maple Bacon Chicken

    Grilled chicken breast topped with maple bacon, melted cheese and dressed as you choose on a Kaiser roll

Appetizers

  • $6.29

    Pie Pan Poppers

    Our house-made cheesy casserole and crumbled bacon, rolled in breading and fried until golden served with sour cream 4 large poppers
  • $9.69

    Pick a Pair

    Choose 2: Pie Pan poppers, onion rings breaded mushrooms or corn nuggets served with choice of dipping sauce
  • $10.99

    Appetizer Basket

    A generous basket of Pie Pan poppers, breaded mushrooms, onion rings and corn nuggets served with your choice of dipping sauce

Burgers

  • $9.49

    Pie Pan Burger

    Our hand pattied beef grilled with cheese, dressed as you choose and served on a toasted Kaiser roll
  • $9.99

    Patty Melt

    Our hand pattied beef with melted cheese and sautéed onions served on grilled Texas Toast
  • $10.49

    Bacon Cheese Burger

    Our hand pattied beef topped with crispy thick cut bacon, American cheese, dressed as you choose and served on a toasted Kaiser roll
  • $10.99

    Smokey Burger

    Our hand pattied beef topped with crispy thick cut bacon, American cheese and BBQ sauce topped with onion rings and served on a toasted Kaiser roll

Chicken

  • $11.99

    Chicken Tender Platter

    A generous portion of our hand breaded fried tenders served with two sides, your choice of dipping sauce and a Pie Pan roll
  • $11.49

    Chicken and Waffles

    Our house-made waffle topped with three fried chicken tenders served with warm syrup and mashed potatoes
  • $11.99

    Pie Pan Chicken Breast

    Two grilled chicken breasts grilled with our house seasoning served with two sides and a Pie Pan roll
  • $10.99

    Grilled Chicken Alfredo

    Grilled chicken, penne pasta and creamy alfredo sauce garnished with parmesan cheese and parsley served with garlic bread
  • $11.99

    Chicken Fried Chicken

    Country fried chicken breast served with mashed potatoes, one side and a Pie Pan roll
  • $10.49

    Chicken Livers

    A hearty serving of our hand breaded chicken livers fried to order served with two sides, gravy and a Pie Pan roll

Seafood

  • $11.49

    Shrimp Basket

    A generous portion of breaded shrimp served with cocktail sauce, coleslaw and French fries
  • $13.99

    Grilled Salmon

    Seasoned and grilled salmon served with two sides and a Pie Pan roll

Beef

  • $11.49

    Open Faced Roast Beef

    Roast beef piled high on Texas Toast smothered in brown gravy served with mashed potatoes and one side
  • $10.49

    Old Fashion Meat Loaf

    House-made meat loaf topped with our traditional ketchup sauce or brown gravy served with mashed potatoes, one side and a Pie Pan roll
  • $10.49

    Liver & Onions

    Grilled liver & sautéed onions served with brown gravy, two sides and a Pie Pan roll
  • $11.99

    Pot Roast

    Seasoned and roasted choice beef slow cooked until tender served with two sides and a Pie Pan roll
  • $10.49

    Country Fried Steak

    Our battered, fried steak served with white gravy, mashed potatoes, one side and a Pie Pan roll

Daily Specials

  • Ask your server about today’s specials.

Sides 2.19

  • Southern Green Beans

  • Buttered Corn

  • French Fries

  • Idaho Mashed Potatoes

  • Cheesy Hashbrown Casserole

  • Cole Slaw

  • Fresh Broccoli

  • Hot Cinnamon Apples

  • Macaroni and Cheese

  • Glazed Carrots

Premium Sides

  • Breaded Mushrooms

  • Corn Fritters

  • Fried Okra

  • Onion Rings

Kid’s Menu

  • Chicken Tenders

  • Grilled Cheese

  • Grilled Chicken Breast

  • Junior Burger

Beverages

  • Fresh Coffee

  • Decaf Coffee

  • Fresh Brewed Tea

  • Sweet Tea

  • Milk

  • Lemonade

  • Orange Juice

  • Apple Juice

  • Soft Drinks

  • Iced Coffee*

    Made daily with a custom blend of brewed 100% Arabica beans and fresh whole milk, sweetened with pure cane sugar and served over ice *sorry no refills

Dessert Anyone?

  • $3.99

    Slice of pie

  • $4.99

    Slice of cake or cheesecake

  • Ask your server about taking home a whole cake or pie today!

    CALL US FOR YOUR SPECIAL OCCASSION AND HOLIDAY DESSERTS We cater, take special orders and have a private party room.

Award Winning Breakfasts

  • $10.49

    Big Country

    Batter fried steak, gravy and two eggs served with choice of potato and toast or biscuit & gravy
  • $8.49

    Libby’s Special

    Two eggs, bacon or ham served with toast or biscuit & gravy
  • $9.49

    The Scrambler

    Three scrambled eggs with diced ham and cheese served with choice of potato and toast or biscuit & gravy
  • $9.49

    Mediterranean Scrambler

    Three scrambled eggs with spinach, tomato, sliced olives and feta cheese served with fresh fruit and toast

From the Griddle

  • $11.49

    Chicken and Waffles

    Our house-made waffle topped with three fried chicken tenders served with warm syrup and choice of potato
  • $8.99

    Waffle

    Our Belgian waffle cooked until golden brown served with warm syrup and bacon

Three Egg Omelettes

  • $9.49

    Western

    Diced ham, tomatoes, onions, peppers and cheese
  • $8.99

    Pie Pan Classic

    Cheese and choice of bacon or ham
  • $8.49

    The Veggie

    Diced tomatoes, onions, peppers, mushrooms and cheese

Bakery

  • $5.99

    Biscuits and Gravy

    Two of our house-made, fluffy biscuits served with a bowl of our made from scratch gravy
  • $3.69

    Pastry/Bread of the Day

    Ask your server for today’s selection

Tag-A-Longs

  • $3.99

    Bacon Strips (3)

  • $4.29

    Ham

  • $2.69

    Cheesy Hashbrown Casserole

  • $2.69

    Home Fried Potatoes

  • $1.99

    Toast

  • $3.49

    Biscuits (2)

  • $1.69

    Single egg

  • $1.49

    Avocado

  • $4.99

    Vanilla yogurt served with seasonal fruit and pecans

  • Seasonal Fruit

    Ask your server for today’s selection

Beverages

  • Fresh Coffee

  • Decaf Coffee

  • Milk

  • Fresh Brewed Tea

  • Sweet Tea

  • Apple Juice

  • Orange Juice

  • Lemonade

  • Iced Coffee*

    Made daily with a custom blend of brewed 100% Arabica beans and fresh whole milk, sweetened with pure cane sugar and served over ice *sorry no refills on Iced Coffee
  • Soda

Award Winning Breakfasts

  • $10.49

    Big Country

    Batter fried steak, gravy and two eggs served with choice of potato and toast or biscuit & gravy
  • $9.49

    All-American

    Two eggs, two pancakes or French toast, choice of bacon, sausage or ham
  • $8.49

    Libby’s Special

    Two eggs, bacon, sausage or ham served with toast or biscuit & gravy
  • $9.49

    The Scrambler

    Three scrambled eggs with diced ham and cheese served with choice of potato and toast or biscuit & gravy
  • $9.49

    Mediterranean Scrambler

    Three scrambled eggs with spinach, tomato, sliced olives and feta cheese served with fresh fruit and toast
  • $10.49

    Breakfast Bowl

    Our cheesy hash brown casserole layered with bacon or sausage, cheese, two eggs, gravy and served with a biscuit
  • $10.99

    Chorizo Breakfast Bowl

    Our cheesy hash brown casserole layered with chorizo sausage, cheese, two eggs and served with a warm flour tortilla, salsa and sour cream
  • $9.49

    Breakfast Burrito

    A warm tortilla filled with scrambled eggs, green peppers, onion, cheese, and choice of bacon or sausage served with cheesy hash brown casserole
  • $8.49

    Breakfast Sandwich

    Egg, cheese, choice of bacon, sausage or ham on grilled wheat bread served with cheesy hash brown casserole
  • $10.49

    Corned Beef and Hash

    Lean corned beef hash with cheese and two eggs served with choice of potato and toast or biscuit & gravy
  • $11.49

    Chicken and Waffles

    Our house-made waffle topped with three fried chicken tenders served with warm syrup and choice of potato
  • $10.99

    Ham Steak & Eggs

    Two eggs, a thick cut grilled ham steak, served with choice of potato and toast or biscuit & gravy

Three Egg Omelettes

  • $9.49

    Western

    Diced ham, tomatoes, onions, peppers and cheese
  • $8.99

    Pie Pan Classic

    Cheese and choice of bacon, sausage, or ham
  • $8.49

    The Veggie

    Diced tomatoes, onions, peppers, mushrooms and cheese
  • $9.99

    Tex–Mex

    Diced fajita-style chicken, tomatoes, onions, peppers and cheese served with salsa and sour cream
  • $10.99

    Meat Lovers

    Sausage, ham, bacon and cheese

Fruits and Grains

  • $7.29

    Avocado Toast

    Our thick cut Artisan wheat toast topped with fresh smashed avocado, a squeeze of lemon juice and crumbled feta cheese served with fruit
  • $9.29

    Breakfast Banana Split

    Banana and vanilla yogurt topped with fresh berries, pineapple and granola then drizzled with honey served with an English Muffin
  • Seasonal Fruit

    Ask your server about today’s selection
  • $3.49

    Oatmeal or Grits

    Served warm with butter, brown sugar and milk
  • $4.99

    Yogurt

    Vanilla yogurt served with seasonal fruit and pecans
  • $3.69

    Pastry/Bread of the Day

    Ask your server for today’s selection

From the Griddle

  • $8.99

    Pie Pan Pancakes

    Our giant, fluffy double stacked pancakes served with whipped butter, warm syrup and choice of bacon or sausage
  • $8.99

    French Toast

    Three slices of Texas toast dipped in our own cinnamon batter, lightly toasted and dusted with powdered sugar served with warm syrup and choice of bacon or sausage
  • $8.99

    Waffle

    Our Belgian waffle cooked until golden brown served with warm syrup and choice of bacon or sausage

Tag-A-Longs

  • $5.99

    Biscuits (2) & Gravy

  • $3.49

    Sausage Patties (2)

  • $3.99

    Bacon Strips (3)

  • $4.29

    Ham

  • $2.69

    Cheesy Hashbrown Casserole

  • $2.69

    Home Fried Potatoes

  • $1.99

    Toast

  • $3.49

    Biscuits (2)

  • $1.69

    Single egg

  • $1.49

    Avocado

Kid’s Menu

  • Cheese Omelette

    Made with 1 egg, cheese, served with toast
  • One Egg, Meat, & Toast

    1 egg, 1 bacon strip or sausage patty
  • 3 Silver Dollar Pancakes

    3 small pancakes, 1 bacon strip or sausage patty
  • French Toast

    French toast slice, 1 bacon strip or sausage patty

Beverages

  • Fresh Coffee

  • Decaf Coffee

  • Fresh Brewed Tea

  • Sweet Tea

  • Milk

  • Orange Juice

  • Apple Juice

  • Lemonade

  • Iced Coffee*

    Made daily with a custom blend of brewed 100% Arabica beans and fresh whole milk, sweetened with pure cane sugar and served over ice *sorry no refills
  • Soft Drinks

Summer Specials

  • $9.99

    Strawberry Salad

    Grilled chicken on a bed of fresh greens topped with pecans, strawberries, feta cheese, and tomatoes.
  • $9.99

    Blueberry Spinach Salad

    Grilled chicken on a bed of fresh spinach topped with almonds and blueberries.
  • $8.49

    Stuffed Tomato

    A large, fresh tomato stuffed with our house-made chicken or tuna salad served with our house-made banana nut bread
  • Fruit Plate

    Strawberries, pineapple, grapes, bananas, and cantaloupe served with our house-made creamy fruit dip and our house-made banana nut bread
  • $2.19

    Seasonal Side

    Cucumber and onion salad in a sweet vinegar sauce.
  • Strawberry Salad

  • For Pickup or Third-Party Delivery

Frozen Family Meals

  • $19.99

    Chicken Pot Pie with Rolls

    House-made chicken pot pie loaded with fresh pulled chicken and vegetables. Comes with 4 Pie Pan Dinner rolls and baking instructions.

Hot Family Meals

  • $24.99

    Chicken and Dumplings with Rolls

    A large 64 oz portion of our house-made chicken and dumplings served with 6 Pie Pan dinner rolls.

Hot Meals with Sides

  • Side Items

    Mashed potatoes, green beans, corn, coleslaw, carrots, baked apples
  • $32.99

    Chicken Tenders with 2 Sides and Rolls

  • $32.99

    Meatloaf with 2 sides and rolls

Voted Best Dessert 2006-2017

  • Available Daily

  • Made to Order

  • Extras

Check out other American Restaurants in Evansville.


Similiar Restaurants Nearby:

Evansville Restaurant Guide: See Menus, Ratings and Reviews for Restaurants in Evansville and Indiana
United States Restaurant Guide:
AK | AL | AR | AZ | CA | CT | CO | DE | FL | GA | HI | ID | IL | IN | IA | KS | KY | LA | MD | ME | MA | MI | MN | MS | MO | MT | NC | ND | NE | NV | NH | NJ | NM | NY | OH | OK | OR | PA | RI | SC | SD | TN | TX | UT | VT | VA | WA | WV | WI | WY
Canadian Major Cities and Provinces:
Alberta | British Columbia | Manitoba | New Brunswick | Newfoundland | Nova Scotia | Ontario | Prince Edward Island | Quebec | Saskatchewan | Yukon | Calgary | Edmonton | Montreal | Ottawa | Regina | Saskatoon | Toronto | Vancouver | Victoria | Winnipeg |
Most Popular US City Guides:
Albuquerque | Amherst | Atlanta | Austin | Baltimore | Boston | Boulder | Brooklyn | Burlington | Cape Cod | Charlotte | Charleston | Chicago | Cincinnati | Cleveland | Columbus | Dallas / Fort Worth | Denver | Detroit | El Paso | Flagstaff | Fort Lauderdale | Fresno | Gulf Coast | Hartford | Hoboken | Honolulu | Houston | Indianapolis | Jackson | Jacksonville | Jersey City | Kansas City | Knoxville | Las Vegas | Long Island | Los Angeles | Louisville | Lowell | Madison | Memphis | Miami | Milwaukee | Minneapolis | Myrtle Beach | Nashua | Nashville | New Orleans | New York City | Oakland | Oklahoma City | Omaha | Orange County | Orlando | Philadelphia | Phoenix | Pittsburgh | Portland | Providence | Raleigh | Reno | Richmond | Riverside | Sacramento | Saint Louis | Salem | Salt Lake City | San Antonio | San Diego | San Francisco | San Jose | Santa Barbara | Santa Fe | Seattle | St. Paul | Tampa | Tucson | Tulsa | Twin Cities | Virginia Beach | Washington, DC | Wilmington | Winston-Salem