Anderson's Frozen Custard

Anderson's Frozen Custard > Menu

Prices and menu items are subject to change. Contact the restaurant for the most up to date information.

Our Famous Signature Frozen Custard

  • $3.94

    Small

  • $4.74

    Medium

  • $5.39

    Large

  • $6.49

    Pint

Handmade ICE CREAM & FROZEN YOGURT

  • $4.59

    1 Scoop

    Cones & Dishes
  • $5.49

    2 Scoops

  • $6.69

    3 Scoops

  • $7.99

    Pint

Non Dairy Plant Based Frozen Desserts

  • $5.54

    1 Scoop

  • $6.44

    2 Scoops

  • $7.64

    3 Scoops

  • $9.08

    Pint

Original Lemon Ice

  • Lemon Ice

Sundaes

  • Create Your Own

    Toppings: Peanut Butter, Hot Fudge, Cold Chocolate Syrup, Butterscotch, Strawberry, Pineapple, Raspberry, Marshmallow, Caramel Extras: Nuts—Chopped, Spanish, Pecans — Add 1.26 Real Whipped Cream — Add 1.26 Candy — Add 1.26
  • Signature Sundaes

    Reese’s Pieces Deluxe Peanut Butter -Hot Fudge & Reese’s® Pieces Mexican- Our Own Chocolate Sauce & Spanish Nuts Turtle- Hot Fudge, Butterscotch & Pecans Made with our own Signature Vanilla Frozen Custard
  • $8.29

    Banana Split

    Vanilla & Chocolate Custard, Chocolate, Strawberry & Pineapple Toppings, Banana, Whipped Cream & Nuts
  • $8.29

    Brownie Overboard

    Rich Fudgy Brownie with Vanilla & Chocolate Frozen Custard, Hot Fudge, Whipped Cream & Chopped Nuts
  • $8.29

    Choco-Peanut Butter Passion

    Chocolate Peanut Butter Ice Cream, Hot Fudge, Peanut Butter, Peanut Butter Cookie, Whipped Cream & Reese’s® Peanut Butter Cups
  • $4.49

    Strawberry Glacier

    Our Lemon Ice topped with strawberries

Arctic Swirls

  • Arctic Swirl

    Smother it with Hot Fudge—Add .52 Double Dose Your Candy —Add 1.16

Handmade Ice cream Cakes

  • $26.49

    Round

    Serves 8-10
  • $43.99

    Small Sheet

    Serves 16-20
  • $32.99

    Decadent Series

    Serves 8-10 Cookies & Cream Dream w/real Oreo, Rainbow Fudge w/real M&M’s, Cookie Dough, plus seasonal favorites
  • $46.99

    Fudgie Turtle

    Serves 12-15
  • $44.99

    Fudge Ganache

    Serves 12-15

Homemade Ice Cream Pies

  • Turtle, Cookies & Cream with real Oreo, Peanut Butter Fudge

Big Wheels

  • Original

  • $9.99

    Large Chocolate Chip

Sundae Kits

  • $25.00

    Classic

  • $29.00

    Customized

CHOCOLATE SODAS

  • Chocolate Sodas

Johnnie Ryan FLOATS

  • Johnnie Ryan Floats

    Cherry, Orange, Birch Beer, Root Beer, Grape, Loganberry, Cream Soda, Cola, Diet

STRAWBERRY SENSATION

  • Original Lemon Ice blended with Lemon Up & Strawberries

BEVERAGES

  • Soft Drinks

  • Coffee

  • $2.49

    Bottled Water

  • $2.99

    Bottled Pop

MILKSHAKES

  • Milkshakes

    Chocolate, Black Raspberry, Vanilla, Pistachio, Strawberry, Cinnamon, Coffee, Loganberry, Root Beer, Mint, Peanut Butter, Hot Fudge , Caramel , Strawberries, Raspberries, Real Bananas - Add .55 each Make it a Malt add 55¢ Any item made with Hard Ice Cream or Yogurt - add $0.95 Any item made with Plant Based Frozen Dessert - add $1.25

Non Dairy Plant Based Shakes

  • $5.74

    Regular

  • $7.14

    Large

ROAST BEEF SANDWICHES

  • $7.99

    ORIGINAL

    3 oz.
  • $8.99

    CARL'S CHOICE

    5 oz.
  • $6.99

    BARBECUE BEEF

TURKEY SANDWICHES

  • $7.99

    ORIGINAL TURKEY SANDWICHES

    3 oz. (Served hot or cold)
  • $8.99

    CARL'S CHOICE TURKEY SANDWICHES

    5 oz. served hot or cold

VEGAN SANDWICH

  • $5.99

    VEGGIE WRAP

    Lettuce, Cucumber, Tomato, Red Onion & Balsamic dressing
  • $7.59

    VEGGIE BURGER

CHICKEN & FISH

  • $7.99

    BUFFALO STYLE CHICKEN TENDER SANDWICH

    with Lettuce, Wing Sauce, Blue Cheese
  • CHICKEN TENDER BASKET

    with Fries. Plain or Buffalo Style
  • $7.79

    GRILLED CHICKEN

  • $10.51

    CAESAR CHICKEN WRAP

    With almonds
  • $7.99

    WILD CAUGHT FISH SANDWICH

Rolls & Breads

  • Kimmelweck

    Rolls
  • Kaiser

    Rolls
  • Ancient Grain

    Rolls
  • $2.00

    Gluten Free

    Rolls
  • Organic Sprouted White

    Breads
  • Wrap

    Breads

Sandwich Extras

  • $1.26

    Thick Beef Gravy

  • $1.26

    Melted Cheddar Sauce

  • Condiments

    Horseradish, Honey Dijon Sauce, Ketchup, Mayonnaise, Mustard, Banana Peppers, Onion, Lettuce, Tomato, Pickles, Relish, Hot Relish, Bold BBQ Sauce

Cheese

  • $1.26

    American-Cheddar

  • $1.26

    Provolone

  • $1.26

    Feta

More Sandwich Extras

  • $2.39

    Nitrate Free Bacon

  • $2.39

    Avocado

GRILL ITEMS

  • HAMBURGER

    All Natural Beef
  • CHEESEBURGER

    All Natural Beef
  • $3.89

    HOT DOG

    Sahlen’s

FRIES & SIDES

  • CURLY QUE FRIES

  • SWEET POTATO FRIES

  • CAJUN FRIES WITH CHEESE

  • ONION RINGS

  • $3.19

    BAKED POTATOES

    Add Ons: 1.26 each Sour Cream, Thick Gravy, Broccoli, Melted Cheddar Sauce Add On Protein: Bacon 2.39 BBQ Beef 5.29
  • MAC 'N CHEESE

  • $2.99

    POTATO SALAD

SALADS

  • $5.79

    CREATE YOUR OWN GARDEN SALAD

    Create Your Own Garden Salad Start with a base of Mixed Greens, then select your toppings: Includes your choice of: Croutons, Banana Peppers, Cucumber, Tomato, Chow Mein Noodles, Red Onion Salad Extras—add $1.26 each Broccoli, Pecans, Almonds, Mandarin Oranges, Feta Cheese Add Protein to your Salad — All Natural Roast Beef—add $5.79 All Natural Turkey—add $5.79 Grilled Chicken—add $5.79 Chicken Tender—add $5.79 Nitrate Free Bacon—add $2.39 Avocado—add $2.39 Dressings— Ranch, Balsamic Vinaigrette, Greek, Raspberry Vinaigrette, Asiago Caesar
  • $14.10

    GRILLED CHICKEN MANDARIN SALAD

    Mixed Greens, Grilled Chicken, Almonds, Chinese Noodles. Mandarin Oranges & Orange Sesame Dressing
  • $9.57

    SPRING SALAD

    Mixed Greens, Feta Cheese, Red Onion, Pecans with Raspberry Vinaigrette Dressing.
  • $3.99

    SIDE SALAD

    with tomato & cucumber

COMBO MEAL

  • CREATE YOUR OWN COMBO MEAL

    Choose any Sandwich, plus any Side Item or Salad, plus any Drink and Save .75! ~ excludes junior size ~

KIDS MEALS

  • $9.49

    CHOOSE ONE MAIN ITEM

    All Natural Roast Beef, BBQ Beef, All Natural Turkey, Hot Dog, Chicken Tender, Grilled Chicken Strips, Mac ’n Cheese, PB & J or *Angus Hamburger add 1.09
  • CHOOSE ONE SIDE DISH

    Curly Fries, Mac ‘n Cheese, Steamed Broccoli, Applesauce, Banana, Pretzels, Chips or *Cajun Fries - add .49
  • CHOOSE ONE BEVERAGE

    Chocolate Milk, Apple Juice Box, Pop, Milk, or * Mini-Shake—add 1.14

CHOCOLATE SODAS

  • CHOCOLATE SODAS

  • Johnnie Ryan FLOATS

    Cherry, Orange, Birch Beer, Root Beer, Loganberry, Cream Soda, Cola, Diet

STRAWBERRY SENSATION

  • STRAWBERRY SENSATION

    No Fat & Non-Dairy Original Lemon Ice blended with Lemon Up & Strawberries

BEVERAGES

  • Soft Drinks

  • Coffee

  • $2.49

    Bottled Water

  • $2.99

    Bottled Pop

MILKSHAKES

  • MILKSHAKES

    Made with Signature Frozen Custard. Chocolate, Black Raspberry, Vanilla, Pistachio, Strawberry, Cinnamon, Coffee, Loganberry, Root Beer, Mint Peanut Butter, Hot Fudge , Caramel , Strawberries, Raspberries, Real Bananas - Add .55 each Make it a Malt — Add .55

PLANT BASED SHAKES

  • PLANT BASED SHAKES

FROZEN CUSTARD

  • FROZEN CUSTARD

    Vanilla, Chocolate, Twist & Daily Special

ICE CREAM & FROZEN YOGURT

  • ICE CREAM & FROZEN YOGURT

PLANT BASED FROZEN DESSERT

  • PLANT BASED FROZEN DESSERT

EXTRAS

  • $1.19

    Waffle Cone / Bowl

  • $2.39

    Dipped Waffle Cone / Bowl

  • $0.35

    Gluten Free Cone

  • $0.49

    Sprinkles

ORIGINAL LEMON ICE

  • ORIGINAL LEMON ICE

    & Flavor of the Day Non Dairy & No Fat

Create Your Own Sundaes

  • Create Your Own Sundaes

    Toppings: Peanut Butter, Hot Fudge, Cold Chocolate Syrup, Butterscotch, Strawberry, Pineapple, Raspberry, Marshmallow, Caramel. Extras: $1.26 each Nuts—Chopped, Spanish Peanuts, Pecans Real Whipped Cream Candy

Signature Sundaes

  • Reese’s Pieces Deluxe

    Peanut Butter, Hot Fudge & Reese’s® Pieces
  • Mexican

    Chocolate Sauce & Spanish Nuts
  • Turtle

    Hot Fudge, Caramel & Pecans

Specialty Sundaes

  • $8.29

    Banana Split

    Vanilla & Chocolate Custard, Chocolate, Strawberry & Pineapple Toppings, Banana, Whipped Cream & Nuts
  • $8.29

    Brownie Overboard

    Rich Fudgy Brownie with Vanilla & Chocolate Frozen Custard, Hot Fudge, Whipped Cream & Chopped Nuts
  • $8.29

    Choco-Peanut Butter Passion

    Chocolate Peanut Butter Ice Cream, Hot Fudge, Peanut Butter, Whipped Cream, Peanut Butter Cookie & Reese’s® Peanut Butter Cups
  • $4.49

    Strawberry Glacier

    Our Lemon Ice topped with strawberries.

ARCTIC SWIRLS

  • ARCTIC SWIRLS

    M&M’s®, Reese’s® Pieces, Cookie Dough, Birthday Cake, Oreo, Heath, Brownie Pieces, Reese’s® Peanut Butter Cup. Smother it with Hot Fudge—Add .55 Candy Double Dosed —Add 1.26

HANDMADE ICE CREAM CAKES

  • $26.49

    Round

    Serves 8-10
  • $40.99

    Small Sheet

    Serves 16-20
  • $31.99

    Decadent Series

    Serves 8-10. Cookies & Cream Dream w/real Oreo, Rainbow Fudge w/real M&M’s, Cookie Dough Plus Seasonal Favorites
  • $44.99

    Fudgie Turtle

    Serves 12-15
  • $40.99

    Fudge Ganache

    Serves 12-15. Peanut Butter or Mint

HANDMADE ICE CREAM PIES

  • HANDMADE ICE CREAM PIES

    Turtle or Peanut Butter Fudge

BIG WHEELS

  • Original

  • $8.99

    Large Chocolate Chip

FRESHLY SLICED BY THE POUND

  • $17.99

    All Natural Roast Beef

  • $15.99

    All Natural Turkey

    Served in a Tin with au jus on side for dipping. For presentation on a platter: add 4.00 per platter.
  • $12.99

    BBQ Beef

    Our All Natural Beef sauteed in our own BBQ Sauce.
  • Condiments

    Horseradish, Ketchup, Mayonnaise, Banana Peppers.

ROLLS

  • Kimmelweck, Kaiser

  • Ancient Grain

  • Gluten Free

CHICKEN TENDERS BY THE POUND

  • Chicken Tenders By The Pound

    6-7 tenders per pound.

CORPORATE SAMPLER PLATTER

  • $54.99

    10 Mini Assorted Sandwiches

  • $99.99

    20 Mini Assorted Sandwiches

SIDES & SALADS

  • GARDEN SALAD

    With mixed greens. Approximately 7-10 servings per lb.
  • POTATO SALAD

    Traditional egg and mustard. Approximately 3-4 servings per lb.
  • HOMESTYLE MAC N CHEESE

  • BROCCOLI BACON & ALMOND SALAD*

  • GREEK PASTA SALAD*

    Includes feta cheese, tomatoes, black olives, banana peppers, tri colored pasta and Greek Dressing. Requires 48 hours notice
  • BACON CHEESY MASHED POTATOES

    Real mashed potatoes w nitrate free bacon & cheddar.
  • MASHED POTATOES WITH GRAVY

  • CURLY QUE FRIES

EQUIPMENT RENTAL

  • $35.00

    Silver Bullet Coolers (Each)

BAGGED LUNCHES

  • Classic

    Sandwich, Condiments, Side Item & Cookie
  • Customized

    Customized Sandwich, Condiments, Side Item & Cookie

SUNDAE KIT

  • $28.99

    Make At Home Sundae Kit

    Includes ~ • 3 pints Signature Frozen Custard (1 each of Vanilla, Twist, Chocolate) • Hot Fudge • M&M’s • Oreo Cookie Pieces • Rainbow Sprinkles Must Be Pre-Ordered Online Serves 6-8

READY TO SERVE SUNDAE BAR

  • $8.00

    Ready To Serve Sundae Bar

    Includes: • Dishes of your favorite Handmade Ice Creams • Your Choice of 2 Sundae Toppings: Strawberry, Caramel, Hot Fudge, Peanut Butter or Cold Chocolate Syrup • Choice of 2: M & M’s, Reese’s Pieces, Spanish Peanuts or Chopped Nuts • Rainbow Sprinkles & Whipped Cream • Spoons & Napkins. (Minimum order of 20)

READY TO SERVE DISHES

  • $3.99

    Handmade Ice Cream Small Dish

  • $4.79

    Non-Dairy Plant Based Small Dish

  • $3.59

    Signature Frozen Custard Small Dish

  • $2.49

    Original Lemon Ice

ICE CREAM ALA CARTE ITEMS

  • $6.49

    Our Famous Signature Frozen Custard

    By the pint.
  • $8.59

    Handmade Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt

    By the pint.
  • $9.89

    Non Dairy Plant Based Frozen Dessert

    By the pint.
  • $7.00

    Hot Fudge

    per pint (15 servings)
  • $7.00

    Caramel

    per pint (15 servings)
  • $7.00

    Peanut Butter

    per pint (15 servings)
  • $7.00

    Strawberries

    per pint (10 servings)
  • $7.00

    Chocolate Syrup

    per pint (30 servings)
  • $5.00

    Sprinkles

    per pint (30 servings)
  • $9.00

    Candies

    per pint (15 servings)
  • $9.00

    Nuts

    per pint (15 servings)
  • $7.00

    Whipped Cream

    per can (40 servings)

PREMIUM HANDMADE ICE CREAM CAKES

  • $26.49

    Round

    (Serves 8-10)
  • $43.99

    Small Sheet

    (Serves 16-20). Personalized Message For Free

OUR SPECIALTY HANDMADE ICE CREAM CAKE SERIES

  • $32.99

    Cookies & Cream Dream with Real Oreo

  • $32.99

    Rainbow Fudge with Real M&Ms

  • $32.99

    Cookie Dough

  • $32.99

    Seasonal Favorites

HANDMADE ICE CREAM FUDGE GANACHE CAKES

  • $44.99

    Peanut Butter

    Rich Chocolate Ganache with our Handmade Ice Cream.
  • $44.99

    Mint Fudge

    Rich Chocolate Ganache with our Handmade Ice Cream.

HANDMADE ICE CREAM PIES

  • $19.99

    Turtle, Peanut Butter Fudge & Seasonal Specialties!

    To make any visit a special one!!

    Check out other Ice Cream & Yogurt Shops in Amherst.


    Similiar Restaurants Nearby:

    Buffalo Restaurant Guide: See Menus, Ratings and Reviews for Restaurants in Buffalo and New York
    United States Restaurant Guide:
    AK | AL | AR | AZ | CA | CT | CO | DE | FL | GA | HI | ID | IL | IN | IA | KS | KY | LA | MD | ME | MA | MI | MN | MS | MO | MT | NC | ND | NE | NV | NH | NJ | NM | NY | OH | OK | OR | PA | RI | SC | SD | TN | TX | UT | VT | VA | WA | WV | WI | WY
    Canadian Major Cities and Provinces:
    Alberta | British Columbia | Manitoba | New Brunswick | Newfoundland | Nova Scotia | Ontario | Prince Edward Island | Quebec | Saskatchewan | Yukon | Calgary | Edmonton | Montreal | Ottawa | Regina | Saskatoon | Toronto | Vancouver | Victoria | Winnipeg |
    Most Popular US City Guides:
    Albuquerque | Amherst | Atlanta | Austin | Baltimore | Boston | Boulder | Brooklyn | Burlington | Cape Cod | Charlotte | Charleston | Chicago | Cincinnati | Cleveland | Columbus | Dallas / Fort Worth | Denver | Detroit | El Paso | Flagstaff | Fort Lauderdale | Fresno | Gulf Coast | Hartford | Hoboken | Honolulu | Houston | Indianapolis | Jackson | Jacksonville | Jersey City | Kansas City | Knoxville | Las Vegas | Long Island | Los Angeles | Louisville | Lowell | Madison | Memphis | Miami | Milwaukee | Minneapolis | Myrtle Beach | Nashua | Nashville | New Orleans | New York City | Oakland | Oklahoma City | Omaha | Orange County | Orlando | Philadelphia | Phoenix | Pittsburgh | Portland | Providence | Raleigh | Reno | Richmond | Riverside | Sacramento | Saint Louis | Salem | Salt Lake City | San Antonio | San Diego | San Francisco | San Jose | Santa Barbara | Santa Fe | Seattle | St. Paul | Tampa | Tucson | Tulsa | Twin Cities | Virginia Beach | Washington, DC | Wilmington | Winston-Salem