Delivery
Yes
Payment
Credit Cards Accepted
Parking
Parking Lot
Good for Kids
Attire
Casual
Alcohol
Reservations
Add a description here.
| 5 star |
|
|
5 reviews | 13% | |
| 4 star |
|
|
5 reviews | 13% | |
| 3 star |
|
|
12 reviews | 30% | |
| 2 star |
|
|
9 reviews | 23% | |
| 1 star |
|
|
9 reviews | 23% |
02/09/2025 - Angelica P.
The steak subs I ordered were fantastic, and the delivery was impressively fast, thanks to a very friendly driver. After six years of enjoying the mouthwatering offerings from Incredible Pizza, including their delicious baked ziti and generous toppings, I can confidently say their food has transformed into the best in town. If you haven't tried their pizza or subs lately, you're missing out on a culinary experience that truly satisfies!
04/26/2024 - MenuPix User
I ordered like $50 worth of food there. I waited and with the door open and waited and they never showed up. I ended up falling asleep with the door open. We are talking a 2-3 hour wait. I called and asked where my food was and they said they came to the door and no one answered but still wanted me to pay for the food they delivered . Then the owner female manager. She is either the owner or married to the owner. Anyways she gets on the phone gets all snotty with me about wanting paid for food they never delivered . What it is , is the location I'm they don't like driving there. So they made up an excuse to stop delivering to me. Plus they have an issue when you order two liters of soda . I don't know why myself it is a sale and they make money from it. But if you order two liters of soda 90% they will screw up the order and forget items and make 2-3 trips to and from your house just to get everybody in the house their food. So plan on a family meal if you order from there. Then she finally says that if I wanted food from there again that first I would have to make a pick up order and pay the $40-$50 for the previous order and in addition pay for the pick up order. The subs are alright but the in store service is sh-tty . I would not refer them to my worst enemy if I had one to refer too. Much better to go GFS and buy a the large 5lb bag of Jalapeno poppers and make them at home it is tastier and cheaper as well.
07/19/2022 - MenuPix User
Ordered a 16 inch intalion sub, 1550 one thin layer of pepperoni, very thin layer of ham, if not for the bread it would have blew away with the when, there is a lot more.out there for that price. Don't w aste.your money.
01/01/2018 - Nursing home nurse
I ordered a pizza at 11:30pm and was told they could not give me a time on delivery. This was alright since I work the night shift. At 2:30 am still had not received any pizza. Tried calling them for over 35 minutes with no answer. They closed at 2am and I never received my pizza which was a birthday gift from one of my co worker. Thanks Incredible you could have called and let me know you were not going to deliver. Properly will not order from you again.
09/06/2016 - Trey
Food is nasty and expensive! The employees are rude and the customer service sucks. The supervisor does not care what goes on at that business. She closes the business up early after taking your order.
09/06/2016 - Cindy
NASTY NASTY NASTY!
06/10/2015 - Amy
The pizza and bread sticks are horrible and their service sucks!! Will never order from there again and I will warn other people about them.
04/08/2015 - dude
Wow bye 2 sub's and get one free $25 dollars plus your really paying for all 3 its a joke this is the only place to get food for people who work late at night and its the last place to pick from in my book wish other places would stay open for night shifters that had better food and service
03/17/2015 - neb
Their service is horrible their pizza is horrible and they are trying to rip me off for money.
See all restaurants in Newark
