fb_connect
Sign in | 
FIND WHERE
- New Jersey Restaurant Guide - See Menus, Reviews, Maps and Make Reservations for thousands of restaurants in New Jersey. -
69%
Say Yum
83 people voted
Boat House On Swartswood Lake ($$$) $ - Cheap Eats (Under $10)
$$ - Moderate ($11-$25)
$$$ - Expensive ($25-$50)
$$$$ - Very Pricey (Over $50)
Menu



Newton, NJ Map
Newton, NJ 07860 (Map & Directions)
(973) 300-0016

Cuisine:   American, Seafood
Location: Sussex County > Newton
Delivery: No Attire: Dressy casual Reservations:
Wifi: No Parking: Yes Alcohol:
Good for Kids: Outdoor Seats: Payment: Accepts Credit Cards
 

User Reviews for Boat House On Swartswood Lake
dissappointed posted on 09/10/2013
Rating & Review:
review_stars
Was there for the first tine on Sautrday night 8/24/13 and to be honest with you I would never go back. You don't mind paying the price of food if it is good. The service was absolutely horrible and it showed in her tip. I am wondering if they changed chefs because the food was not as good as it use to be. I was there several times prior and was good. Get a new chef and staff.<br /> <br /> Dissappointed
aresea posted on 03/11/2011
Rating & Review:
review_stars
Beautiful views, likable ambiance of the Boat House.<br /> <br /> Food and service fair.
Leo Beshada posted on 08/21/2010
Rating & Review:
review_stars
Over two hours and 15 min to be served dinner. When the meal arrived it was not as stated. The Waitress was bad, three times she forgot to bring a drink or appetizer and then would say sorry 15 min or more later then bring the item. Would not go again.
cnnsucks posted on 08/02/2010
Rating & Review:
review_stars
My first visit to the Boat House was last Sunday. Everything we had was amazing! We started with the French Onion soup, the flavor was great, it could have had a little more cheese, but that's just me. Next was the best crab cake that I've ever had, it came with a wonderful sauce. I then had the broiled sea food combination and everything was very good, the scallops were cooked perfectly. Someone else in my group had the Sea Bass, I stole a taste, it was light & flaky. It came with a fresh pico type topping and was also delicious. For desert I had the Lava cake with ice cream. Service was good and prices were average. The setting is wonderful and has a great historic feeling. I will be returning whenever I visit NJ.
Eliz Armenante posted on 07/19/2010
Rating & Review:
review_stars
After an exhausting day looking at real estate in the county,I stopped in for a drink by myself.The young lady who greeted me could see I was in need of refreshment!I was treated like a good friend and was very well taken care of.I never eat alone but felt so comfortable that I ordered a steak and it was delicious. This experience sealed a deal and I now reside in Hampton Township.Hospitality goes a long way!!<br /> <br /> <br /> <br /> <br /> <br /> <br /> <br />
lake lova posted on 07/10/2010
Rating & Review:
review_stars
Food was absolutely great. Service was non existent for us but many wait servers. Still because we're easy going had a really great evening, lovely to eat on the lake, really nice people to deal with. Would definitely go again!
Scott Osborne posted on 06/28/2010
Rating & Review:
review_stars
My wife and I ate here over the weekend. The food was wonderful and the atmosphere was great. I highly recommend the Brie and steak sandwich.
Glen Jankowski posted on 01/06/2010
Rating & Review:
review_stars
We would recommend this restaurant to everyone. The quality of the food and the atmosphere as well as the service was fantastic. We have eaten there on several occassions and have enjoyed it everytime.
larry posted on 11/09/2009
Rating & Review:
review_stars
Worst crab cakes I ever had in my life and they did not accept my criticism well. In fact Cathy (owner)was a little arrogant about it.
Hunting for Good Sussex Co Restaurants posted on 09/25/2009
Rating & Review:
review_stars
Admittedly spoiled by NYC restaurants, we continue to hunt for some eating options near our country home. The Boat House has been the best by far, and has the potential to be a standout by focusing on more fresh ingredients, avoiding pre-made bottled products (shouldn't all blue cheese be fresh in dairy heaven?), using sauces a bit more sparingly and serving at peak doneness. Otherwise, ambiance and staff are lovely, menu is interesting and food is very tasty - we definately will be back!
Fredonia posted on 09/03/2009
Rating & Review:
review_stars
We have eaten here before, more for the atmosphere than the food--it's great eating outside on the lake surrounded by a lovely flower garden. We were pleasantly surprised on our last visit--perhaps they got a new chef--the food was terrific and the menu was much more creative than we remembered from previous visits. Keep up the good work!
John Woodward posted on 07/26/2009
Rating & Review:
review_stars
Excellent time. The food is exquisit and price fairly. Cathy is a consummate professional and her staff is doting without being "hovering". We all enjoyed a great time!
Max Booker posted on 06/16/2009
Rating & Review:
review_stars
Cathy, the manager at the Boathouse is the most rude and inconsiderate person I have ever met. This restaurant, besides being way pricey and disappointing, is a joke. It is very unprofessional, and the food is horrible. We were going to have our wedding here, but after getting the run-around time and time again, and having the rates raised after already having agreed on the date and time, we decided that it was a very bad Idea. Whether you are looking to have a reception of some kind here, or just go for dinner.... I would seriously rethink it... Just look at the other reviews here!
GJDG posted on 03/14/2009
Rating & Review:
review_stars
Soups Very Salty, Foods in general not so flavorable, Had fish which was soggy and not done, Had Steak, which was very Poor Quality and Price was Very High for Sussex County area.<br /> This not NY City.
posted on 02/10/2009
Rating & Review:
review_stars
Good food and Great atomoshere.Loved sitting outside by the water.
Dissappointed posted on 11/07/2008
Rating & Review:
review_stars
Sorry not so good & PRICY...


Get Directions - See Larger Map


Photos

Recent Yum Votes
Wok N Sushi ($$)
       Japanese, Sushi
Bagel Bistro ($)
       Breakfast, Bagels, Coffee Shop, Sandwiches
A Bite Of Heaven ($$)
       American
Wok N Sushi ($$)
       Japanese, Sushi
Parma Johns ($)
       Italian
Tony's Pizza & Pasta Restaurant ($$)
       Pasta, Pizza, Subs
Savannah Restaurant ($$)
       American
Village Pizza ($$)
       Pizza, Subs
A G Pizza & Restaurant ($$)
       Pizza, Subs
A G Pizza & Restaurant ($$)
       Pizza, Subs

People Who Viewed this also Viewed
County Seat ($$)
       American
Max's Station House Inc ($$)
       American
Andre's Restaurant ($$)
       American


Have You Eaten Here?   Yes   No