San Giorgio's Italian Bistro
69% say Yum
16 people voted
69% say Yum
16 people voted
People Who Viewed This Also Viewed
Kinnelon Pizza Pasta Caffe ($)
Pasta, Italian, Pizza, Sandwiches, Subs
Cypress Estiatorio ($$)
Mediterranean, Greek, Spanish, Italian
Kit Hong Restaurant Inc ($$)
Lakeside Bagels Deli & Pizza ($)
Breakfast, Bagels, Coffee Shop, Pizza, Deli
| Add Photo
Is this your restaurant? Click to add your description here.
Mon: Closed, Tue-Thu: 5pm - 10pm, Fri-Sat: 5pm - 11pm, Sun: 4pm - 9pm
Credit Cards Accepted
Good for Kids
$ - Cheap Eats (Under $10)
$$ - Moderate ($11-$25)
$$$ - Expensive ($25-$50)
$$$$ - Very Pricey (Over $50)
Reviews of San Giorgio's Italian Bistro
08/17/2016 - Kathleen M.
This is the only Italian food I will eat other than my mom's. My husband and I first stumbled across this place after moving to Kinnelon two years ago and now we come here at least once a month. Truly delicious and authentic. Just be sure to make a reservation on a Friday or Saturday night--this place is tiny!
01/04/2013 - Dave C
The chef/owner of this restaurant claims that in over 40 years in business he has never had a customer complain about his food. Hard to believe, but if you choose to dine at San Giorgio's and you are not happy with the food, don't dare question the waiter if you feel the food you ordered lacks in quantity or quality. I have been to this local restaurant at least half a dozen times over the years and have never had a reason to complain or write a review. The service was always slow but not worth complaining about because it's not a fast food restaurant. I have never timed how long it takes to get drinks or bread. This is a restaurant you go to relax and enjoy a fine dining experience.
Our appetizers and entrees were fine until I noticed that there was very little or no veal in the veal parmigiana dinner I ordered. At first we laughed about how easy it was to push a fork through the veal as if it were a pancake. The cheese, sauce, and breading actually tasted good. But, I was starting to wonder if the kitchen forgot to put the veal in my veal parmigiana. After further investigation, I realized the veal was as thick as a sheet of paper. I cut a small piece of the entree and carefully removed the thick breading leaving the paper thin veal on a separate plate. I asked the waiter if the chef made a mistake preparing this entree. He brought the sheet of veal to the kitchen and immediately returned with a raw, much thicker slice of veal. He explained that the chef told him that he flattens the veal with a mallet and that's why it is thin. I told him that that was not an acceptable explanation as to why the veal in my parmigiana dinner was paper thin. I told him the chef should learn how to make a proper veal parmigiana dinner. No sooner the chef comes roaring out of the kitchen yelling that he has never had a complaint regarding his cooking in over 40 years. I told him the veal was to thin and his answer was that I was crazy and that most restaurant's substitute their veal with pork. He and his staff were also bragging about all the awards he has won over the years. Our waiter soon told us that the chef was also the owner. We watched this chef/owner go over to other tables and loudly complain to the occupants about us. He continued to boast about his rewards and how no one has ever complained about his cooking in over 40 years. A few of the diners actually started giving us a hard time for complaining to this man about his food. When my adult daughter told the chef/owner that he was unprofessional and thin skinned, he told us to get out and never come back. Before we could get up, the waiter presented us with a check that included the parmigiana with the paper thin slice of veal. We paid the bill and left.
I wish I could leave zero stars for this insane dining experience. My only warning is if you choose to dine at San Giorgio's, don't complain about the food no matter how bad you may find it!
Visited January 2013
Lincoln Park Diner
(Lincoln Park, NJ)
We used to order from here at least 3 times a week until they started forgetting parts of our order or putting things in food that we asked to have re...
It's nice to find a local place you can call home. We always feel welcomed at Upstream. It's like seeing your friends every time you are greeted by th...
El Encuentro Centro Americano
Sibora's Pizza and Mediterranean Grill
(Lincoln Park, NJ)
The panini came cold and tasteless. The falafel was made too doughy to have any taste and it was spicy hot :(
The price was too high for a fala...
I will not be returning to Nautilus Diner in Madison. Made a request to skip soup and salad in exchange for dessert. Would not honor my request even...