Italian Restaurants in Middletown

• Cosimo's Brick Oven Ristorante ($$)
  

  Italian, Pizza • Menu Available
  620 Route 211 E, Middletown, NY
  (845) 692-3242 (845) 692-3242
  Write a Review!
• Frank's Pizza Italian Restaurant ($)
  

  Italian, Pizza • Menu Available
  470 Rte 211 E, Middletown, NY
  (845) 342-6541 (845) 342-6541
  Write a Review!
• Frank's Pizza and Restaurant ($$)
  

  Italian, Pizza, Seafood • Menu Available
  470 Route 211 E, Middletown, NY
  (845) 342-6506 (845) 342-6506
  Write a Review!
• Franco Di Roma ($$)
  

  Pizza, Italian • Menu Available
  357 Rt 211 E, Middletown, NY
  (845) 342-3552 (845) 342-3552
  Write a Review!
• Tony Boffa's Restaurant ($$)
  

  Italian, Pizza • Menu Available
  75 Railroad Ave, Middletown, NY
  (845) 343-8842 (845) 343-8842
  Write a Review!
• John's of Arthur Ave Restaurant & Pizzeria ($$)
  

  Italian, Pizza • Menu Available
  19 West Main St, Middletown, NY
  (845) 467-4712 (845) 467-4712
  Write a Review!
• DeStefano's Olde Erie ($$)
  

  Italian, American, Seafood, Pubs • Menu Available
  7 W Main St, Middletown, NY
  (845) 344-3743 (845) 344-3743
  Write a Review!
• Olive Garden Italian Restaurant ($$)
  

  Italian • Menu Available
  200 N Galleria Dr, Middletown, NY
  (845) 692-8232 (845) 692-8232
  Write a Review!
• Marco's Pizza ($)
  

  Pizza, Subs, Italian, Catering • Menu Available
  670 Route 211 E, Middletown, NY
  (845) 695-8700 (845) 695-8700
  Write a Review!
• BadaBing Pizzeria ($)
  

  Pizza, Italian • Menu Available
  28-32 County Highway 78, Middletown, NY
  (845) 341-0000 (845) 341-0000
  Write a Review!
• Fausto's bagel station ($)
  

  Bagels, American, Italian, Deli • Menu Available
  West Main St, Middletown, NY
  (845) 858-8400 (845) 858-8400
  Write a Review!
• Carlo's Pizzeria & Bar ($$)
  

  Pizza, Italian • Menu Available
  295 Wawayanda Ave, Middletown, NY
  (845) 775-4662 (845) 775-4662
  Write a Review!
• Yanis Pizzeria and Restaurant ($$)
  

  Pizza, Italian • Menu Available
  202 North St, Middletown, NY
  (845) 239-4746 (845) 239-4746
  Write a Review!
• Pecorinos Pizzeria & Restaurant ($$)
  

  Pizza, Italian, Sandwiches • Menu Available
  253 Tower Dr, Middletown, NY
  (845) 673-5703 (845) 673-5703
  Write a Review!
• Alondra's Cuisine ($$)
  

  Italian, Mexican • Menu Available
  14 North St, Middletown, NY
  (845) 343-3354 (845) 343-3354
  Write a Review!
• Caborcas Pizzeria ($$)
  

  Mexican, Italian
  90 N St, Middletown, NY
  (845) 342-0023 (845) 342-0023
  Write a Review!
• Pizza Star ($$)
  

  Pizza, Italian • Menu Available
  400 NY-211, Middletown, NY
  (845) 381-5134 (845) 381-5134
  Write a Review!
• Piccolo Due ($$$$)
  

  Italian • Menu Available
  731 Rte 211, Middletown, NY
  (845) 695-6860 (845) 695-6860
  Write a Review!
• Bella Notte Ristaurante ($$)
  

  Italian • Menu Available
  731 Route 211 E, Middletown, NY
  (845) 692-7400 (845) 692-7400
  Write a Review!
• Mario's Restaurant ($$)
  

  Italian • Menu Available
  37 Ogden St, Middletown, NY
  (845) 344-0213 (845) 344-0213
  Write a Review!
• Mezza Luna Pizzeria ($) - Closed
  

  Italian, Pizza, Subs, Sandwiches • Menu Available
  741 Route 211 E, Middletown, NY
  (845) 695-2222 (845) 695-2222
  Write a Review!
• Nico's Italian Bar and Grill ($$) - Closed
  

  Italian, Bar • Menu Available
  42 Ingrassia Rd, Middletown, NY
  (845) 343-6426 (845) 343-6426
  Write a Review!
• Orrio's Restaurant ($$) - Closed
  

  Pizza, Italian, Sandwiches
  42 Ingrassia Rd, Middletown, NY
  (845) 343-9447 (845) 343-9447
  Write a Review!
• La Pizza Mia ($) - Closed
  

  Italian, Pizza
  741 RT 211 E, Middletown, NY
  (845) 695-2222 (845) 695-2222
  Write a Review!
• Zuto's Pizza Plus ($) - Closed
  

  American, Italian, Spanish • Menu Available
  128 Dolson Ave, Middletown, NY
  (845) 342-9357 (845) 342-9357
  Write a Review!
• Levato's Pizza ($) - Closed
  

  Italian, Pizza
  148 Wickham Ave, Middletown, NY
  (845) 343-2121 (845) 343-2121
  Write a Review!
• Pasta Shop ($$) - Closed
  

  Pasta, Sandwiches, Subs, Italian, Pizza
  257 E Main St, Middletown, NY
  (845) 342-0050 (845) 342-0050
  Write a Review!
• Mama Pina Pizza Restaurant ($$) - Closed
  

  Pizza, Italian
  156 Dolson Ave, Middletown, NY
  (845) 344-6262 (845) 344-6262
  Write a Review!
• Olde Erie BrewPub & Grille ($$$) - Closed
  

  American, Italian, Seafood
  711 E Main St, Middletown, NY
  (914) 344-3743 (914) 344-3743
  Write a Review!
• The Spot ($) - Closed
  

  Italian, Sandwiches, Subs
  128 Dolson Ave, Middletown, NY
  (845) 342-9357 (845) 342-9357
  Write a Review!