fb_connect
Sign in | 
FIND WHERE
- New York Restaurant Guide - See Menus, Reviews, Maps and Make Reservations for thousands of restaurants in New York. -
67%
Say Yum
15 people voted
Nicolino's ($$) $ - Cheap Eats (Under $10)
$$ - Moderate ($11-$25)
$$$ - Expensive ($25-$50)
$$$$ - Very Pricey (Over $50)
View Menu



4515 State Highway 30
Amsterdam, NY 12010 (Map & Directions)
(518) 842-4907

Cuisine:   Italian
Location: Montgomery County > Amsterdam
Delivery: No Attire: Casual Reservations: Yes
Wifi: No Parking: Yes Alcohol:
Good for Kids: Yes Outdoor Seats: Payment: Credit Cards Accepted
 

User Reviews for Nicolino's
Amanda posted on 12/20/2013
Rating & Review:
review_stars
Love, love, love it here! Always amazing food! While other restaurants are declining Nicolino's gives you authentic, hand made, food you can't get anywhere else. Always come to this restaurant when out in Amsterdam!
andrew dinitto posted on 08/29/2013
Rating & Review:
review_stars
Chria must be representing competing restaurants. The moment he said the portions were small, I knew he was never at Nicolino. If any thing, the portions are enough for at least 2 maybe more. If you going to lie, at least get your facts straight
Notanidiot posted on 07/10/2013
Rating & Review:
review_stars
I was there once. It was all it took. I got small portions. The taste was horrifying. These positive reviews are probably from people working there or the owner herself. The waitress was a total dolt. I waited FOREVER for my food which was abhorringly disappointing. The price was outrageous. And yes, TGI does do Italian better then Douche Nichlino's.
Chris posted on 06/24/2013
Rating & Review:
review_stars
Highly recommend. 1st time visit and will definitely visit again when we are in the area. Best Italian food I have had for the price in years. Service was good, but we were there on a slow night. Great find!
maureen posted on 07/30/2012
Rating & Review:
review_stars
We've been there before and it's always a highlight when we are in the area - gonna be in the area tomorrow for a couple of days and Nicolino's is definitely a destination for us!!<br /> I agree w/last reviewer - folks if your description of fine dining is most of the chain restaurants, i.e. Red L, Apple..., etc., go elsewhere!
Steve & Thea posted on 05/11/2012
Rating & Review:
review_stars
To those complaining about service time, this isn't a big chain restaurant with six cooks. It is virtually run by one lady (the owner) and a couple of servers. And to the dumbass complaining about the hard crusty bread, it's supposed to be like that. It's ITALIAN bread, in an ITALIAN restaurant, retard. People like this probably grew up on processed crap they got from food stamps and wouldn't know good quality food if it punched them in the face.<br /> <br /> My wife and I have been there several times. Ans, yes, it does take some time. But in our experience it was well worth the wait.. The food is authentic Italian made from scratch, not the frozen crap many chain restaurants use. And it was of the highest quality. Those seeking a real quality Italian food experience we highly recommend Nicolino's. Idiots thinking places like TGI Friday's make good Italian probably would not appreciate this fine establishment. They'd be better off doing some "fine dining" at KFC or some other big chain. Nicolino's is truly a diamond in the ruff.
carol benton posted on 06/10/2010
Rating & Review:
review_stars
went there on 'parm night' wed. we waited for almost 1 1/2 hours for our food. the place only had a few other couples so they we not busy. the chicken itself was pretty good..but the sauce tasted sour..the pasta was horrible. the bread they give you was hard and crusty. the best part of the meal was the small salad that comes with the meal..and they even ran out of soup..would not recommend..and will not be going back. we had to chase down the waiter and waitress more then once for refills..the food..lemon..the check..we had a lot of left overs..but didnt even want a box!!


Get Directions - See Larger Map


Photos

Recent Yum Votes
Goodfellas Pizzeria ($)
       Pizza, Subs, Sandwiches
Gwib Coffee House ($)
       Coffee Shop
Nicolino's ($$)
       Italian
Ripepi's Restaurant ($$)
       American
Bottisti's Pizzeria ($)
       Pizza, Subs, Sandwiches
Baia's Two Restaurant ($$)
       American
Goodfellas Pizzeria ($)
       Pizza, Subs, Sandwiches
La Cucina ($$)
       Italian
Bottisti's Pizzeria ($)
       Pizza, Subs, Sandwiches
Red Lantern ($$)
       Chinese

People Who Viewed this also Viewed
Bosco's Restaurant ($$)
       Pizza, Italian
La Cucina ($$)
       Italian
Crystal Bar ($$$)
       Italian, Pizza, Sandwiches, Subs


Have You Eaten Here?   Yes   No