Great American Saloon
85% say Yum
34 people voted
85% say Yum
34 people voted
People Who Viewed This Also Viewed
Lucky Seven ($$)
Cape Horn Family Restaurant ($$)
Lions Pride ($$)
Sal's Little Italy Red Lion ($$$)
Italian, Sandwiches, Subs, Soups
| Add Photo
Is this your restaurant? Click to add your description here.
Hours: Add Hours
Credit Cards Accepted
$ - Cheap Eats (Under $10)
$$ - Moderate ($11-$25)
$$$ - Expensive ($25-$50)
$$$$ - Very Pricey (Over $50)
Good for Kids
Reviews of Great American Saloon
10/25/2015 - Rob
We went there last night to celebrate mine and a friends birthday,HORRIBLE! I ordered a steak med well,a baked potato,and a salad, the salad was so so,when the steak arrived,it was very rare,and there was a sweet potato,garnished with sour cream.I had sent the potato back before I cut into the steak,the waitress was so nice,and apologized,once I cut into the steak and found it to be barely cooked,I sent it back too.When they returned with the steak,it was the steak I had sent back,cooked again.The waitress again apologized,it was the manager that brought the steak back out to me,as soon as I opened the box up and seen it was the same steak,my appetite was gone,and to top it off,as we were getting ready to leave,we got our bill,was waiting on the waitress to return with change,and the baked potato showed up.I am like,WOW.My wife and I ate there a few times before, and it was very good,this was the last time we go there,the wait staff is very friendly,the manager was nice,but the kitchen sucks.I felt like I was in the movie Waiting.I would never re cook a dish to serve to a customer,it should have been done from scratch, the place was busy,and I understand,mistakes happen,but to re serve an already cooked steak was not only a mistake,but cost them a customer as we will never go back.I would not recommend this place to anyone,sorry to be harsh,but all I could think was how many other orders get re cooked after being served to the public environment.yuk
03/07/2014 - Gale Wiens
The food is good but inconsistent and service is disorganized. I ordered chicken strips and got deep fried chicken breasts instead. Far from the expected finger food for dipping. It was also served 2 minutes after receiving my salad, so it was cold by the time I was ready to enjoy it. The only thing worse than a cold chicken strip is a big cold greasy deep fried chicken breast. My husbands appetizer was brought to the table 10 minutes before my salad. Seems the waitress takes your order then the kitchen idiots bring out the food as soon as it is ready. One hand is not talking to the other in this eistablishment. The restaruant is very close to home so we will be going back, but would not recommend anyone travel a long distance for the below average service.
I think if you want to eat at this restaurant you probably should stick to their regular menu. We went today and thought since it was Thanksgiving we...
Janina's Fine Desserts
I had a piece of pumpkin cheesecake from Janina's and was hooked. He have lived in the York area for over 40 years and never had pastry this good. I...
(Glen Rock, PA)
Best pizza and subs and the hardest working guys in the pizza bizz...
Food was very good and at a good price!...
(York New Salem, PA)
Love to get carry out as well as hang here. A friendly fun atmosphere...the food is great...prices are good...and even when they are crowded and get a...