Reviews for Alfano's Pizzeria

01/16/2024 - MenuPix User

12/14/2023 - MenuPix User

11/26/2023 - MenuPix User

06/06/2021 - Ric Fortner, Columbus, Ohio
Best I've ever had.

03/21/2021 - MenuPix User
I will be honest... my orders usually range from decent to very good. With the occasional "meh." I would say 4 to 4.5 stars, but the other reviews are crap. So, to try to get a better balance, 5 stars easy.

I am a regular here and love their pizza and their prices. I see a lot of people complaining about delivery and temperature of food... Those two go hand in hand. From their locale in Galesburg, it can take 10 minutes or more to get the food their. (Remember: we live in a train-town with idiot on the road at all times and the dumbest traffic lights.)

If you want fresh food, go pick it up yourself; Arrive a couple mins early, pay, then wait a min or two, and it will be fresh... don't be lazy and then complain when you don't get things exactly how you want. Food delivery is a touchy business, and even the best businesses will deliver cold food sometimes... Escpecially when it's 20 below how and midnight workers are hard to find.

Anyway, thanks Frank (and Pietro) for the great pies and service. Keep up the good work.

09/17/2020 - Nick
Always Great Food at a very fair price!!

04/03/2020 - Mel
Alfano's makes great pizza and pasta meals. I grew up in NYS and this is authentic Italian like I used to get at home.

04/17/2019 - MenuPix User
Can I get soft shell tacos without frying

04/17/2019 - MenuPix User
Can I get soft shell tacos without fryingf

04/20/2016 - Trying to help you out
Everytime we have ordered they say 45 mins which is fine but are food is always cold I have never have gotten hot food from galesburg Alfano's is not like Knoxville's I don't know how they are still in business I order anywhere else that's delivers and its never as cold as theirs they need to fix there problem

03/13/2016 - rachel
This place is always out of stuff. No wings, no bosco stix , no sour cream for my tacos the list goes on. Waited an hour and a half for my food. By the time I got my food it was all cold. I called and spoke to the owner and the best he could do was remake my order but said it would be another hour wait. This place is going down hill!!

11/01/2015 - Kyra
Out of taco meat, out of mushrooms, and out of mozzarella for cheese sticks....learn how to keep your stock full

05/24/2015 - Jami
Yay for delivery at 2 am!

05/30/2013 - RC laidman
Slow service, food still arrived undercooked.