Reviews for Atlantic Beach Pizza

10/27/2011 - Ellen
Heard there was new management. Food is GREAT. U gotta try the buffalo chicken pizza. Awesome. The new owner is a great guy & shared some of his plans for the place. Check it out. It'll be worth ur while especially if ur a local like me.......... ....................bring the kids!

06/28/2011 - Kitty
I loooove their pizza it's better than domino and pizza hut.I love hoe they make it fresh cuz in other places they buy the frozen dough(that's already made)and use it to make pizza.the owner is nice and funny.

Best pizza

10/15/2010 - Erika
I Loooooove their barbecue chicken pizza. The carmelized onions are delicious and I don't like onions.

09/28/2010 - From the hood
The food is okay, but nothing to rave about.

The pizza is a bit better than frozen take home from the grocery store.

Subs ... ahhhh ... not great ... not terrible ... but nowhere near they need to be.

The only place these guys excell is with calzones.

Problem is ... they take a hell of a long time to put one out the door.

I've ordered three (on different occasions) and each time I go to pick up at the appointed time ... I need to wait 15 extra minuts or so.

I refuse to go there anymore ... I'll wait for these guys to fold and see what the next owners put in this space.

Does anyone remember when there was a Chinese restaurant where Atlantic Beach Pizza is currently located? Sagamore Beach needs CHINESE!!!

06/10/2010 - houligan
Its better then it was with joe and the gang those people thought they were doing you a favor making you a pizza or a sub, the bread was stale, very little cold cuts and the pizza was all garlic. Moved here from Boston they should go there and learn how to make good gravybefore you even put on a pizza. I have not had the pizza under the new owners but I have had the subs.
The bread is fresh stuffed sandwiches great chicken tenders, the staff they need to work on being friendly. but the food is better the the original that for sure!!!!

12/02/2009 - tommy star
wow boy has this place changed, Joe's gone and so is the great food what happened. new owners and staff rude!!!