Reviews for Mystic Island Pizza

12/07/2023 - MenuPix User

06/12/2020 - Local Resident
Used to order from them regularly. Was tailgated by one of their delivery drivers on my way to their restaurant. I brought to the cashiers attention but the manager wouldn’t speak to me, was told they was too busy. I cancelled my order and left. Half hour later I get a call that my order is waiting to be picked up. I told them what happened and once again was given the opportunity to speak to manager. Was told manager would call me back, never did. Never again.

10/12/2010 - Scott
Hands down best pizza in town. Super fast delivery.
Go yanks

08/15/2010 - Not Happy
WORSE place EVER. I just ordered diner there and found a
COCKROACH in my food. After calling them, they offered to make me a new Stromboli. ARE you kidding me? I demanded my money back and called the board of health. After puking several times, I wanted to warn everyone else about this place. THEY ARE DIRTY n NASTY. DO NOT order there. They should be shut down, I feel so violated, I hope they go out of business!!!!!!

10/25/2008 - Trish
I think Mystic Pizza's food is the best in town! I think their secret is....most of it is cooked by Italian women....and the women add that extra touch...of LOVE!