Reviews for Papa's Pizzeria

04/22/2024 - Alexander P.
The pizza at this local pizzeria in Teaneck is absolutely fantastic with its perfect texture and delicious taste, making it a must-try. I highly recommend trying their various menu offerings, especially the pizza and subs, as they never disappoint in quality and flavor.

03/22/2024 - MenuPix User

02/02/2024 - MenuPix User

01/05/2024 - MenuPix User

09/12/2023 - MenuPix User
So disappointed. It used to be one of my favorite pizzerias, but the sauce tasted different and a tv was blasting so loudly that my ears are still ringing. A very sad change for this once great food stop.

12/12/2015 - Lori Williams
I've been going to Papa's for about 10 years now and the pizza is the best around. They make eggplant parm here, as well as an eggplant pizza that is to die for! I also love their chicken caeser salad, they make it fresh and the chicken is warm, yum. I'm sure everything on the menu is delish. I keep going back to my favorites though :-) You won't be disappointed with Papa's!

11/02/2014 - Demetri
Papas pizza is so good there Italian heroes are the best papas pizza is the best

01/05/2014 - Samantha Martinez
The pizza sauce tastes like rotten tomatoes. The staff is very rude and impolite. Every time i have went there the snapple and soda machines are always empty and when it comes to the food i want to order they are always out of something! They run out of chicken and even wings! The pizza literally tastes like cardboard . I would say years ago it was better but as time goes by the food quality worsens. I would recommend Victors Pizzeria in Teaneck to anyone who wants a Real slice of Pizza and a delicious philly cheese steak

10/15/2010 - Lauren
Papas Pizza is one of the best pizzerias around. The food is incredible. My favorite is the Chicken Parm with Penne. 5 out of 5!