Reviews for Joeys Pizza Depew

04/17/2024 - MenuPix User

03/05/2024 - MenuPix User

12/21/2023 - MenuPix User

12/09/2023 - MenuPix User

11/24/2023 - MenuPix User

11/14/2023 - MenuPix User

12/16/2022 - MenuPix User
Not sure where their quality has disappeared to but....out of the last 6 orders with them, 5 had something wrong. Not sure if it's miscommunication with DoorDash or what. Their pizza has been pretty good (once they get the toppings right). Their subs are delicious (when made correctly). Here's hoping the new management will get things back to normal...SOON.

06/21/2021 - Dianne
Joey’s is the BEST. New owner fantastic. Even when moved out of state Joey’s was always on the have to stop at place whenever we came home.
Wishing the new owner all the BEST

06/10/2021 - Joey's Pizza Depew
Hi Donna! We are unable to reply directly to your review through MenuPix, so we hope you will see this! We are very sorry to hear that this happened. Please know that we also feel this is unacceptable and we would like the chance to apologize and talk to you about this further. Please contact us directly at joeyspizzadepew@gmail.com with your phone number so we can reach out to you and make this right.

06/08/2021 - Donna
Normally I would give 5 stars. My son has special needs and normally they make him feel so special. He called and requested 15 wings. Whoever answered phone and said you must be looking for somewhere else and hung up on him. I am truly disappointed. I have been to Joey's from the beginning. Try to think before you respond negatively. My son doesn't always understand why he can't have items made a certain way.

04/18/2021 - Bob
I will be brief,Joey’s blows La nova and Imperial right out of the water!

03/25/2021 - Jayne
Great food!

06/14/2020 - Ken
Ordered a large cheese and pepperoni pizza with extra sauce and not only was it not extra sauce but was dry and overcooked. Total waste of money. I have been going there for years and lately store bought frozen pizza is way better than they put out. Never again.

02/24/2020 - MenuPix User
Luv all the food is amazing

02/02/2020 - Kathy
Ordered a cheese and pepperoni pizza. Also wanted peppers on half and mushrooms & olives on other half. Got home, live across town, and no pepperoni at all. I specifically asked that there be pepperoni on entire pie. Very disappointed! Too far to go back and have "fixed". Awful pizza without meat.

08/11/2018 - Stephanie H.
Joey's deluxe sub is so good. My girls love the chicken fingers. What a nice way to spend a little time in the afternoon

08/25/2017 - TONY
I grew up down the street from you ,now I live in Iowa. Every time I'm home I take your Pizza and Wings back with me. GREAT

06/13/2017 - C
I order a lg pizza cheese and ham, to be delivered
It costed me over $20, because they charge $3.00
for delivery. Is that money go to the delivery guy, plus people may give him a tip. WOW he's making a lot of money

01/07/2015 - faith
All of their food is awesome! ! The only pizza I will eat. Never had a bad meal from Joeys!