Reviews for Stillwaters Restaurant

08/31/2011 - Lisa From Carle Place
I gave the old Stillwaters a 5 star rating their food was out of this world my now husband took me there on our 1st date Nov 20th 2002 and then a year later he asked me to married him there!!!! We loved this place but haven't had the chance to go back there as of yet of their opening again

07/13/2011 - Abigail Desena
Stillwaters' Executive Chef, Tom fired one of their cooks for calling in sick due to bronchitis. I don't know if I would trust any food that comes out of a kitchen whose management team would prefer their food handlers to cough on the meals being served. Perhaps a visit from the Health Department and the Labor Department is in order. I hear they owe ALL of their employees money because they claim not to have made enough. Great job, Stillwaters. I hope karma does a number on you for firing someone who had the decency not to contaminate the area and get everyone sick.

06/17/2011 - Frank Hoerauf
By far the WORST restaurant I have ever eaten at. The place was clean and neat, had a great location on the weater, this actually could be a goldmine. However the food was nothing short of horrible. Couldnt even finish my meal , the seafood bisque was going bad, they ran out of steak, then the seafood I ordered wasnt even cooked. I am easy going , but this was just beyond terrible. Stay away from this dive, unless you want food poisoning.

05/31/2010 - Ken
I passed it on Memorial Day. This place looks closed. All outside furniture is gone. It certainly looked more than closed for the holiday.
Shame, it was very good