Reviews for Mayflower Seafood Grill and Oyster Bar

04/07/2024 - MenuPix User

02/26/2024 - MenuPix User

02/15/2024 - MenuPix User

02/07/2024 - MenuPix User

12/15/2023 - MenuPix User

03/27/2021 - Lynda
Been to the Mayflower many times, each visit is a joy, Myra has a smile each visit & a joy to be around!!

02/19/2021 - MenuPix User
We ate lunch there today and it was absolutely horrible. There was no seasoning and no taste. We will never go again.

02/19/2021 - MenuPix User
We ate lunch there today and it was absolutely horrible. There was no seasoning and no taste. We will never go again.

05/01/2020 - Greg Whitener
Good food with sizable portions and very reasonable prices. Best Seafood Restaurant around.

12/30/2017 - EARL FUTRELL
OUR SUPER AT THE MAYFLOWER IN WINTERVILLE NC WAS GREAT WE GOT JUST IN TIME AND THE FOOD WAS GREAT OUR SERVER WAS GREAT TO THE FOOD WAS GREAT GREAT KEEP UP THE GREAT WORK

10/07/2017 - Ron
Food taste horrible. Fish taste nothing like when i cook it. 1 star for screwing me and my daddy and other people over! 15 or 20 dollars a meal and you dont give a free drink???! They get my daddys order wrong everytime he says. Twice a year and they get it wrong everytime. They disnt even give him sweet tea! The hell with Mayflower we are done! Hate this place im still feeling sick from the food right now ugh

07/26/2017 - John
I have been there many times and the last 2-3 times while paying for the meal with a 100 dollar bill I have received the wrong amount of change. One time $20 short another time $35 short and just today (07/26/2017) $10 short. What is going on at the cash register. Sure hope there is no embezzlement going on.

05/14/2017 - H & C Thompson
We eat here every Friday. Wait staff is very friendly and work as a team. Food is great and always enough to take some home. Check out the occasional "specials" on the lobby whiteboard. Shrimp & Grits, Cajun Chicken & Shrimp Pasta - divine! Gourmet quality dishes, developed by aspiring chefs.

04/22/2017 - Linzy
I eat there several times through out the year because of the distance and it's always delicious. You get so much food on the platters that I always get a take out box. It's my husband favorite place to go. When last there in March for a family BD party we had a blast. The waitresses & waiters are so accommodating. We've even taken our relatives from Delaware and they loved it. They don't have such a place there.

10/11/2016 - Ted Frankie
Eat there today, never even eat halve of
My meal, awful never new cooks could
Mess up seafood like that tasted.
Terrible.

06/11/2016 - Tami Smithers
On our way, haven't been since closed=due to remodeling. .

04/27/2016 - Pete Pelt
the food was good but the coleslaw just can't get my head around brownish coleslaw. The service was great .

11/28/2015 - Fart N. C.
I had the most awful experience!! My waiter couldn't even tell the difference between the seafoods!

09/26/2015 - Dana Jordon
Had a great experience @ Mayflower. The food was delicious and the service was excellent. Ask for the waiter named TY. HE was very professional and took very good care of us!

01/27/2015 - Stephanie
I ordered the grilled salmon and it had such a nice smoky flavor to it. The fried dill pickles were delicious; I probably could have made a meal out of them if I had realized how many come in the appetizer! My companion had fried catfish that practically melted in my mouth when I was able to sample some of it. I enjoyed the atmosphere and our waitress was very friendly and courteous.

12/07/2014 - Keesha
The food is good but it's not as it used to be. Some waitresses keep skipping by your tables and rarely ask if anything needed such as refills on drinks. ..While on the other hand, some waitresses stopping by/asking every 10 minutes..which gets annoying because you feel rushed! I feel that they need more training on greeting and hosting.

02/11/2014 - Diana
I went to eat there last Friday it was ok but I went to pay with my credit card and they charged me for the wrong table and there was more that mine, then for mine, so that was over double for our lunch. that my money not there to take, they said it would n there today, as of today I have not got my money back yet. They say there not a corporate office to complain to. Very upset over it, WATCH OUT WHEN YOU USE YOUR CC THERE.

07/11/2013 - Mike Shugart
This is the best local seafood restaurant and doubly good because of the large quantity servings at a reasonable price. Jessica was a great waitress and the owner is a hard working and personable woman. The shrimp is my favorite and it is always lightly breaded and hot. Clean and cool and love the aquariums.

02/10/2012 - Angie Faith
My aunt and I decided to eat at the Mayflower in Winterville, NC. She and her husband had been there before but I had not. I was pleasantly surprised at the good service and abundance of food. My aunt and I shared the pick three combination platter. It was absolutely Delicious and even had enough to take home to my husband for his supper. The prices are very reasonable for families and would recommend this restaurant to my friends and family. The staff was very friendly and accommodating. I had no problem leaving a 20% plus tip to our server.