Reviews for Olivias Italian Eatery

01/02/2024 - MenuPix User

12/25/2023 - MenuPix User

01/04/2019 - Carol
We love the pizza. We usually use delivery which is always within the time that we are told at the time the order is placed!

05/05/2017 - lori ackerman
service was poor, pizza not very good, seating is terrible.... with springs showing through the seats....dont know the bill till you go to check out...HOW CAN I LEAVE A TIP IF I DONT KNOW THE TOTOAL BILL?....done with this place..use to be a favorite ....bathrooms dirty

04/22/2014 - Cas
Firstly,the food is subpar compared to the restaurant across the street, and others in the nearby area, but the Tuesday wing night special a great deal for the price you pay. Other nights of week it isn't worth it.
The reason I gave this place 1 star is because a person who seemed to be either owner or manager was rude to my Mom after a misunderstanding. Though our waitress was wonderful, she failed to let us know that wing night special was only for dining in. We didn't even know it was wing night til we sat down because there is little advertising about it. My mother ordered some wings for my father and brother who were at home and ended up being about a $20 more than what she expected. When she asked about it to the owner or manager (whoever it was) he just said a sarky comment back. My mom was just looking for explanation why, not a discount, but he didn't provide one. A simple "I'm sorry for the misunderstanding" would have been enough, as well. My mother felt like they were treating her like she was dispensable.
Also they really need more than 1 sign explaining their wing night dine-in only policy because if you aren't sitting by it you miss the fact. Not going to be a problem for my family because we are never eating here again.

07/24/2013 - Ashley
My family and I usually go every other Tuesday night for family night dinner and we all LOVE it there. The waitress Becky is amazing and never messes our order up. The people there are always so nice and willing to do whatever they can to make it a good dinner. Love the place.

10/19/2012 - John
I love the food but they are very slow if you dine in. Also, they really sock it to you with drinks. A soda in a small glass is $2.50 and each refill is $2.50! My 8 year old had $7.50 worth of cokes and my total drink bill for 4 people was $17.50. Really? This is a glorified sandwich shop. With the slowness and the overcharging for drinks, I will only get take out from now on. I'll visit their neighbor for dining in.

09/11/2012 - Gary
Beware! Monday night's lobster special was a disaster for both my wife and I. The lobster was not fully cooked! The second attempt at presenting us with fully cooked lobster tails also failed miserably. When they brought me the third lobster tail, I decided to throw in the towel and head home!