Reviews for B & J Coney Island

01/05/2024 - MenuPix User

12/05/2023 - MenuPix User

11/25/2023 - MenuPix User

06/21/2023 - MenuPix User
We have eaten here for years service and food has been great, the last 6 times service has been terrible and the food has been just as bad. This was our last time dining here.

02/11/2021 - MenuPix User
Never had a bad experience, visit most weeks; very good: makes you want to return! Give it a shot ,you can’t go wrong/ hint The burgers are amazingly good.

12/10/2017 - Bruce Miller
I go there for one thing and they do a very good job of it Coneys. Classic Coney- chili, mustard and onion in the New Castle tradition. I graduated from SRSC in 1979 and stop in at B&J C. I. or Bob's Sub when passing through the Rock which is probably 5 to 8 times a year. There sauce, in my opinion is better than the M&P Coney islands in New Castle which we made many a run to during my college days at the Rock. I usually pick up a quart of their chili sauce at the start of every winter to get me through as I probably won't be passing through the Rock again until the start of Trout season in the spring.

04/22/2016 - No name
Kinda a regular there. And screwed up a simple cheeseburger. Forgot bacon n tomato. Called n told me oops sorry? Never again.

03/07/2013 - Pete 1
Bar side is stale smoke. 90% people smoke in there. Loud guy with long hair and beard yelling and swearing blonde bar tender just laughed about it. Then juke box blaring with songs with swear words and ref to women and men private parts. Food sucks fried with cheese. Chili sauce and dogs are flat out terrible, soggy oily fries. Anyone with IQ over 40 wouldn't go there or go back.