Reviews for Tony's Pizza Of York

01/14/2024 - MenuPix User

12/18/2023 - MenuPix User

12/01/2023 - MenuPix User

03/26/2023 - Frances
Best Pizza I have ever had.

02/20/2020 - Rich
This restaurant is great . Warm and friendly staff . The food is wonderful. We travel over 900 miles to visit York SC . It’s our restaurant of choice . We arrived at noon today and will be enjoying dinner there tonight !

02/28/2018 - Lee
I had dinner with my family and one of my adult children was fed a raw chicken sub. It had the texture of rubber and when we looked at it it was pink. The waitress was nice and said they would cook him another one. Five minutes later she came back and said they were out of subs. Ok. He ordered a sausage calzone. By the time that came to the table about 25 minutes later the rest of us were finished eating. He cut into it and it looked like pure cheese was so overstuffed the calzone looked like a gigantic snowball. I asked him if he ordered a cheese calzone and he said no. It was supposed to have sausage in it. We could find about 5 small pieces of sausage and they were frozen. Hard to understand how it could have taken them 25 minutes to cook it and it was still frozen. His food was horrific and hopefully he will not get sick. We used to eat here often but you can bet me and my family will never eat here again. I have already told several people I know about my experience . As I said before, we used to enjoy eating at Tony’s.

10/21/2010 - Jennifer
Tony's has the best Italian food in the south its like going to Little Italy in New York. The garlic nuggets are off the chain. Pizza just perfect my grand daughter loves the spaghetti.