Reviews for Cara Mia's

04/20/2024 - Red P.
AWESOME!

02/24/2024 - MenuPix User

02/21/2024 - MenuPix User

01/09/2024 - MenuPix User

12/10/2023 - MenuPix User

08/19/2023 - MenuPix User
Turkey,lettuce,onions,and pickles,..very short on everything...$30.00...NOT WORTH IT

07/07/2021 - MenuPix User
A totally different price/experience when you go to the sub/pizza shop during the day vs. Ordering delivery. I order greek salad with chicken and garlic bread $39.67. ARE YOU F-CK-NG KIDDING ME. TOTAL RIP OFF. GO TO RAMUNTOS, BETTER QUALITY AND PRICE.

12/01/2020 - Anna thompson
Best calzone in rutland! Pizza is great, customer service 2 thumbs up!

11/11/2020 - MenuPix User
excellent salad!!!!

08/04/2020 - Scitt
Absolutely the rudest customer service ever even the manager is rude. Will never and would never recommend

12/11/2014 - bill comstock
I love their Italian salad and also up until tonight their 6 piece order chicken chunks. The salad was was good as usual but the chicken chunks were small pellet like ,over breaded, and over cooked pieces of I think was chicken. I won't order them again.

10/18/2014 - sarah
Way overpriced compared to other local shops. If you are going to charge a customer 1$ for each veggie added to your sub than they should be loaded on. I literally could count, on one hand, how many were put on.
Another experience I had was when I placed an order online for a cheese pizza and a small chef salad. The order totaled $20.20 with the delivery charge and tax added; when the delivery guy showed up with the food my slip said $24.33 and when the charge hit my account it was for $30.63. When I called Roger to discuss, he started yelling at me, was immediately defensive and ended up swearing and calling me names before he hung up on me.
I will never ever go back there and I would never recommend for you to either.

07/12/2013 - vt guy
great service!! awesome pizza never had a bad meal there! owners are very frtiendly

03/27/2013 - Elizabeth
I always have a wonderful experience every time I go to Cara Mia's. They are very pleasant and I love everything that I order!

02/19/2013 - Nicole
Very dissatisfied. Paid 45 dollars for 2 stuffed shells and 12 baby chicken wings. And a large CHEESE pizza that was worse than little Cesar's. don't know what has happened to this place, used to love their food. Must have gotten new owners. I work in a hotel and will no longer be recommending this place!!

02/03/2011 - Josh
Pretty much, they have gave me what I have thrown at them. I can't say anything mean about them since they brought me a pizza during a nasty snow storm when everything was closed down, and still gave me a smiling face! Much love to them, and those who throw hate there way.... You obviously don't know good pizza!

07/21/2010 - Bobby
Terrible service, poor quality of food.

07/06/2010 - Jenn
The pizza is great! The salads are great! The grinders are good.... Its a little pricey if you pick your own toppings for a pizza but if you order off the menu they're about average. And the pizzas on The menu are great! I personally love the veggie and the CaraMia. They also do dinners for take out... I enjoy the eggplant parmesan and the chicken parmesan with pasta and Italian bread. This is by far my favorite pizzeria in Rutland, they have great verities of food to choose from!