Reviews for Old Hickory Steakhouse
Google Places ReviewsRating: 5 | 10/09/2017 - Mark Davis
Review: Best pork chop I have ever had! The combination of sauce, grits, and perfectly cooked chop was amazing. I just ate at the Library Bar next to the steakhouse. It has the same menu, with the added benefit of bartenders watching you for your every need. My server, Erik had obviously been well trained and had experience in the industry. I never would have known it was his first day if he hadn't told me. He was extremely professional and knew his stuff. I will definitely be bringing my friends back here.
Rating: 1 | 10/11/2017 - Susan Nunnamaker
Review: Would advise anyone looking for a good steak NOT to go here. I ordered the filet medium. Steak itself not impressive and came out well done. If the restaurant wasn't so pricey I probably would have just eaten it, but sent it back. A half hour later after my sister had since finished her well done (she also ordered medium) dinner, I received my new steak. It was raw in the middle. Not rare, RAW. Sent it back again asking them to just nuke it so that I could have my dinner. Finally, came back with a steak cooked medium. I agree with other posts - I've had better at Outback. Also, the Caesar salad consisted of about 3 leaves of lettuce. Was very good, but think they could have parted with a few more leaves for $12.
Rating: 2 | 11/01/2017 - Donna Blum
Review: Atmosphere was great, waitress was phenomenal, appetizers (cheese assortment and shrimp cocktail) were worth the money, tasty. Had Ribeye, NY Strip and pork chop. Pork chop was well seasoned and cooked to perfection. However, both streaks were slightly over cooked (we ordered med rare) and had zero season. As in no salt, pepper, no nothing. Incredibly bland. In fact my husband said this morning that he took his leftovers, added salt/pepper and eggs and it wasn’t too bad. I figure if I spend $400 on dinner, the description should NEVER be “its not too bad”
Rating: 5 | 09/01/2017 - LaWanda Aucoin
Review: By far the best steak I've ever eaten (I ordered the filet, medium and typically eat medium well). These steaks are dry aged and I was told the top 5% beef in the US. I believe it!! Also, splurge on the chocolate cake!!! The most amazing thing ever! You cannot possibly be disappointed by your meal, the ambiance, or the staff. Worth it!
Rating: 5 | 07/13/2017 - Alicia Milanese
Review: We just celebrated our wedding anniversary at The Old Hickory. We were a little hesitant after seeing that it had a rating of below four stars on Google reviews. I am so glad that we didn't listen to that. We had an absolute perfect evening. Romantic setting with live piano music, delicious food, and an attentive wait staff! Top knotch place and deserving of five stars!
Write a Review