Reviews for Five Pillars Supper Club

05/02/2024 - Baylee B.
Great service

04/09/2017 - Debby and Val
We were in for dinner on sunday evening, 4/9/17- always go back, it feels like an old fashion supper club, not to many around yet, nice place to relax , have dinner, few drinks, catch up , very nice, Food is always great, Val always has her Prime Rib sandwich, and I always have the Broiled Cod, Almondine- oh so good, never dryed out, thank you again, asked the owner a question, and she went the extra 9 yes, to accomodate me, with menus- thank you again so we'll go back for sure and take my friend along next time, Happy Easter

10/13/2014 - Becky
I recently got married in May 2014 and had the privalage to have it at the Five Pillars. From the moment I booked the venue to the end of my wedding night I had a smooth and relaxing experience. They customized the menu to give my very demanding (and lovable) husband the pig roast he wanted. The food was fantastic and everyone loved it! They created a beautiful atmosphere for not only the reception held in their large hall but all the ceremony held outside in their gazebo. I could not have imagined having a better experience for my special day!

11/05/2011 - KelticRN
We've been to 5 Pillars many times over years. More often over the past year. Never had any problems or bad encounters with staff/ family. Everyone is always genuinely friendly, never rude. Quiet and shy? Maybe, but not rude. And, not like some places where Perky Patty is so obnoxious she'd be better off as a Dallas Cowboy Cheerleader.

Food is delish! We've ordered many different things off the menu. Never a bad plate of food! The little salad bar is perfect for a 'house' salad and cup of soup with a few extras. Want more? Order a full salad off the menu. Who needs BIG salad plate with a full plated meal to follow?

Now the best part. DESSERT! They have THE BEST tortes EVER! My ultimate favorite is the poppyseed, but I have taken the heath torte adventure as well. YUM!

Very reasonably priced. Great selection to meet everyone's tastebuds.

Never been to a banquet or wedding here, but reading other posts, the "requirements" are no different at any non-hotel type facility based on numerous family wedding experiences. We've had to set up or pay to have things set up (right down to the place settings). When the free stuff runs out, then ya gotta pay for it.

We will always recommend 5 Pillars to our friends and family. Thanks for good food, great service and the poppyseed torte!

Ms. Poppyseed Torte :)

08/01/2011 - chris huebner
Brides & Grooms BEWARE! My daughter & son-in-law had their wedding reception there in July 2011. The hall was booked in Nov. 2010. They were given a price list at that time. When they asked about signing a contract, they were told that all contracts were verbal. At the end of the reception, we were presented a bill with charges that were not on the original price list ($5 each to rent the tables, $25 to plug in the white lights behind the head table). Also, we paid for free beer & soda for our guests, only to be told that guests were being charged for these drinks. Some said they asked if there was free beer, and they were told "No". The owner was rude and nasty during and after the reception.

03/09/2010 - Thomasn @Marilee Diillenburg
Tom @ I often go north @ west we eat out often @ feel that we have an excellent concept of what is good@vice-versa! Much to our very pleasant surprise we found Five Pillars fantaastic owners Mary @ Jim Eischen friendly but unobtrusive The food was unparrelled in our yrs. of ;sampling; Prime rib trimmed great @ delectable! Sauteed scallops with the special touch of flamed drawn butter etc. etc.Soup with ancream base but no detectable floury taste! Wow! Not far from Sheboygan well worth your minor trip I am very particular my mother was a waitress at Smith Bros. in Port Wash. for 45 yrs. we have a culinary expert son @ a nephew inPort Newport Shores Port.but we will be back to



















five



Tom @ I went south rather than north @ found a treasure Five Pillars!!! Owners Jim @ Mary Eischen friendly but unobtrusive
















Tom @ I went south rather than north @ found a treasure Five Pillars!!!@ Owners friendly but unobtrusive Food unparalled in our many forays out for that perfect meal we found it Prime rib perfectallt trimmed and the sauteed scallops with that special touch of flamed drawn butter thesoup creamed but no detectable taste of flour what a great culinary event!!!! Thank you Mary @ Jim!!!!!