Reviews for Only The Best Pizza Restaurant

09/24/2021 - MenuPix User
Excellent food Bad attitude of owner. MAX!!!!!!!!!!!!

04/01/2021 - MenuPix User
BEST PIZZA AND ALL AROUND MENU.EVERYTHING I EVER BOUGHT THERE IS PREFECTION.I HAVE BEEN GOING THERE SINCE THEY OPENED.ALL THERE FOODS ARE THE BEST.FIVE STAR RATING.

03/12/2021 - MenuPix User
mmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm

03/12/2021 - MenuPix User
mmmmmmmmm very good. I especially loved the experience with the waiter after dinner i took her back to my place and the rest is on pornhub.com winkie face

02/24/2021 - Linda
Never Had Anything I didn’t Like Here! Always Great!!!

12/29/2020 - Montanari Family
NEVER had ANYTHING We didn’t Like ! (A Lot)! Trying to decide what to order for New Years Eve??So Much to Chose From! We don’t know what to Get? And I’ve Been looking at Menu for A while & just can’t Decide??

12/15/2020 - Linda Montanari
ALWAYS had GREAT Food there! NEVER had any food I didn’t Like! If there were 10 Stars He DESERVES it!!👍😂

11/02/2020 - JTM
Always awesome!

08/26/2020 - Cathy1112ct
Thanks to my sister for letting me know about this amazing pizza restaurant. Not only do they have the best pizza but their fully loaded stuffed breads & delicious sides are to die for! The pizza is consistently made the same omg delicious way each time I ordered. The crew are courteous & super friendly. I’m actually calling in another catering order, I love Only The Best!!

06/12/2020 - dapierp@att.net
Best of Everything! From stuffed breads to steak & cheese subs to everything in between Only the Best is truly the best!

02/29/2020 - Mary
Great trays and phenomenal stuffed breads. Always great. Friendly people. Give them a try.

01/10/2020 - Joe
Everything is always great and customer service has terrific.

12/15/2019 - g mitchell
good luck finding a better stuffed bread. these things are huge!

11/24/2019 - Chris.b
Always good good prices good people what else do you need

11/17/2019 - Bill
Ordered a large half pepperoni/mushroom well done and a meatball parm stuffed bread. The pizza was less than cooked let alone well done. The stuffed bread was still cold, the cheese was not even remotely melted. We called and the response I got was oh sorry you never ordered well done. That is the only way I order pizza. First/last time here. Heading to zuppardis now.

04/27/2019 - Al Lo
Great stuffed breads and pizza.
Never under or overcooked.
Generous stuffings and toppings.
Better than any other pizzeria or restaurant
in New Haven or Milford.

12/13/2018 - MenuPix User
BEST STUFFED BREADS AROUND!!!!!!!

07/30/2018 - Jada G.
There are lots of great pizza joints in West Haven and New Haven....This is one of them.

09/30/2016 - Mariel Albee
Best stuffed breads ! ! ! I bring them to work in Bridgeport and parties in Wallingford so everyone can enjoy what we Westies have!!

05/14/2016 - Leighann
Awesome breads

04/02/2014 - Linda
There are no words to describe the quality and deliciousness of the food from Only the Best. Their pizza is great, their catered food fantastic. But the best thing about Only the Best are their stuffed breads. I have been ordering their stuffed breads for years and I have never been disappointed. It's like heaven eating any one of the various combinations. Give yourself a real treat and try one.

07/20/2013 - Mama B
Ordered a spinach, sausage pie the toppings are good the crust needs some help...it tasted like it was frozen too long and the cheese was ok. Not a lot of flavor. Sorry...

09/22/2012 - Vee
I have never been disappointed with the quality and taste of their food. My favorite is their eggplant subs...the best....almost better than my Italian mom's eggplant!!! I travel through half of Connecticut several times a year just to have their food. I like to go on a sunny day and eat it down at the West Haven Boardwalk. Then end up with Italian ice at a little ice cream shop near the beach. Pizza is great too!