Follow Us

Nicky's Pizza

Yum or Yuck?
View Menu
1735 Calumet Dr
Sheboygan, WI 53081 (Map & Directions)
Phone: (920) 457-6425
Yum or Yuck?

People Who Viewed This Also Viewed

Theo's Pizza ($)
Pizza, Subs, Sandwiches

Luigi's Italian Restaurant ($)
Italian, Pizza

Geno Nottolini's Pizza ($)
Pizza, Subs, Sandwiches

Theo's Pizza ($)
Pizza, Subs, Sandwiches

Restaurant Photos

| Add Photo

Restaurant Description

Is this your restaurant? Click to add your description here.


Mon-Thu: 11am - 10pm, Fri-Sat: 11am - 12am, Sun: 11am - 10pm

Additional Info

Yes - call for delivery info.

Credit Cards Accepted

Parking Lot

Good for Kids


Beer and Wine


Price Point
$$ $ - Cheap Eats (Under $10)
$$ - Moderate ($11-$25)
$$$ - Expensive ($25-$50)
$$$$ - Very Pricey (Over $50)


Outdoor Seats

Reviews of Nicky's Pizza

review_stars 01/01/2018 - William R Weidner
About a week or two ago we had a great pizza in purchasing your special December holiday pizza. Yesterday on New Year's Eve in the afternoon we called in to repeat the experience. The girl took the order and said, "Yes, the December pizza was still available. So we drove from where I live near "The Blind Horse" to eat in at your restaurant. When we arrived the girl said they were out of pomegranates and for that reason they did not make the pizza. Wow! She did not bother to call back and tell us this. As you know, New Year's Eve was extremely cold and my girlfriend has asthma that can be easily triggered by such weather. After a little discussion with her and the cook, we decided to eat at The Duke of Devon instead. But in your parking lot we called to see if they could make us a nice offer given the rather poorly handled situation. All she offered was 15% off. That did not nearly good enough under the circumstances. Do you agree? Thank you for your attentions and if you were to want our repeat business you would have to do much better than an offer of 15% off.

review_stars 05/04/2017 - Jeanne Reinert
Horrible service. Ordered chicken at 3:30 to be delivered at 5:30. Called at 5:45 was told out for delivery. We live there blocks away. 6:00 no good called again promise it would be there in ten minutes. 6:15. No good called again said driver would be there in 15 minutes. Told forget chicken would be cold.rude people horrible service. They do not deserve one star I had to put it there to submit.

review_stars 09/27/2015 - Gail Wallace
Great tasting hot delivery pizza every time--we love The Sheboygan. Highly recommend.

review_stars 12/15/2010 - kerryn
We ordered a pie last weekend for delivery. We ordered a "The Sheboygan" which should have had Italian sausage, pepperoni and double cheese. I also ordered mushrooms and onions on half of the pie. We waited for 45 minutes which was ok but, when we opened the wrapper after the driver had left, we found NO PEPPERONI and MANY mushrooms and onions all over the pie. My wife hates both and ate very little. This was too late and we weren't about to wait another 45 min for another pie as we were starving. So, check your pie BEFORE the driver leaves!

review_stars 11/18/2010 - Michelle
Love this pizza! Never had a problem with them, pizza is always loaded with many toppings and hot. Friendly people and always smiling faces when I am in there!

review_stars 10/10/2010 - workinprogress
They use to be the best and have gone to worse. Service What service they messed up every order i had. There pizza is either over done or small amounts of fixings and lots of over done crust.
I don't know what happened to them but it doesn't get fixed there wont be a Nicky's pizza for long I'm a Faye's pizza person now

Write a Review for Nicky's Pizza

Recent Reviews

1. China Star (Sheboygan, WI)

I’ve been eating here for 5 yrs and the food was great but today Jan 13, it was horible! The egg foo young patties were watery and the fried rice... read more

2. Faye's Pizza (Sheboygan, WI)

Excellent quality and taste. So happy to find this place open for delivery on a Monday. Still can't figure out if other restaurants don't know people ... read more

3. Bumps Grill Tavern (Sheboygan, WI)

Great food and the look and feel of what a classic Wisconsin Tavern should have. I am going to try some of their special menu items as they have a un... read more

4. Dino's Pizza Restaurant (Plymouth, WI)

Delishiouse!!!!... read more

5. Schulz's Restaurant (Sheboygan, WI)

This is a great place to stop and grab a bite to eat if you are in the area. Great food, great employees, and friendly customers.... read more

Sheboygan Restaurant Guide: See Menus, Ratings and Reviews for Restaurants in Sheboygan and Wisconsin
United States Restaurant Guide:
AK | AL | AR | AZ | DE | CA | CT | CO | FL | GA | HI | ID | IL | IN | IA | KS | KY | LA | MD | ME | MA | MI | MN | MS | MO | MT | NC | ND | NE | NV | NH | NJ | NM | NY | OH | OK | OR | PA | RI | SC | SD | TN | TX | UT | VT | VA | WA | WV | WI | WY
Canadian Major Cities and Provinces:
Alberta | British Columbia | Manitoba | New Brunswick | Newfoundland | Nova Scotia | Ontario | Prince Edward Island | Quebec | Saskatchewan | Yukon | Calgary | Edmonton | Montreal | Ottawa | Regina | Saskatoon | Toronto | Vancouver | Victoria | Winnipeg |
Most Popular US City Guides:
Albuquerque | Amherst | Atlanta | Austin | Baltimore | Boston | Boulder | Brooklyn | Burlington | Cape Cod | Charlotte | Charleston | Chicago | Cincinnati | Cleveland | Columbus | Dallas / Fort Worth | Denver | Detroit | El Paso | Flagstaff | Fort Lauderdale | Fresno | Gulf Coast | Hartford | Hoboken | Honolulu | Houston | Indianapolis | Jackson | Jacksonville | Jersey City | Kansas City | Knoxville | Las Vegas | Long Island | Los Angeles | Louisville | Lowell | Madison | Memphis | Miami | Milwaukee | Minneapolis | Myrtle Beach | Nashua | Nashville | New Orleans | New York City | Oakland | Oklahoma City | Omaha | Orange County | Orlando | Philadelphia | Phoenix | Pittsburgh | Portland | Providence | Raleigh | Reno | Richmond | Riverside | Sacramento | Saint Louis | Salem | Salt Lake City | San Antonio | San Diego | San Francisco | San Jose | Santa Barbara | Santa Fe | Seattle | St. Paul | Tampa | Tucson | Tulsa | Twin Cities | Virginia Beach | Washington, DC | Wilmington | Winston-Salem