Sign in | 
- Sheboygan Restaurant Guide - See Menus, Reviews, Maps and Make Reservations for thousands of restaurants in Sheboygan and Wisconsin. -
Say Yum
12 people voted
Nicky's Pizza ($) $ - Cheap Eats (Under $10)
$$ - Moderate ($11-$25)
$$$ - Expensive ($25-$50)
$$$$ - Very Pricey (Over $50)
View Menu

1735 Calumet Dr
Sheboygan, WI 53081 (Map & Directions)
(920) 457-6425

Cuisine:   Sandwiches, Subs, Pizza
Location: Sheboygan > Sheboygan
Website: www.nickyspizza.com/
Delivery: Yes - call for delivery info. Attire: Casual Reservations: Yes
Wifi: No Parking: Alcohol:
Good for Kids: Yes Outdoor Seats: Payment: Credit Cards Accepted
Hours: Mon-Thu: 11am-10pm, Sun: 11am-10pm

User Reviews for Nicky's Pizza
kerryn posted on 12/15/2010
Rating & Review:
We ordered a pie last weekend for delivery. We ordered a "The Sheboygan" which should have had Italian sausage, pepperoni and double cheese. I also ordered mushrooms and onions on half of the pie. We waited for 45 minutes which was ok but, when we opened the wrapper after the driver had left, we found NO PEPPERONI and MANY mushrooms and onions all over the pie. My wife hates both and ate very little. This was too late and we weren't about to wait another 45 min for another pie as we were starving. So, check your pie BEFORE the driver leaves!
Michelle posted on 11/18/2010
Rating & Review:
Love this pizza! Never had a problem with them, pizza is always loaded with many toppings and hot. Friendly people and always smiling faces when I am in there!
workinprogress posted on 10/10/2010
Rating & Review:
They use to be the best and have gone to worse. Service What service they messed up every order i had. There pizza is either over done or small amounts of fixings and lots of over done crust.<br /> I don't know what happened to them but it doesn't get fixed there wont be a Nicky's pizza for long I'm a Faye's pizza person now

Get Directions - See Larger Map


Recent Yum Votes
Bummys Haus ($$)
City Club ($)
       Bar Food
Lynn's Creekside Bar & Grill ($$)
       American, Bar Food, Burgers, Grill
Theo's Pizza ($)
       Pizza, Subs, Sandwiches
Chester's Drive-In ($)
       Burgers, Sandwiches, American
Theo's Pizza ($)
       Pizza, Subs, Sandwiches
China Star ($)
Golden Chopsticks ($$)
Kiku Of Tokyo ($)
Smolic's Tavern ($$)
       Bar Food

People Who Viewed this also Viewed
Theo's Pizza ($)
       Pizza, Subs, Sandwiches
Geno Nottolini's Pizza ($)
       Pizza, Subs, Sandwiches
Harry's Diner ($)
       Diner, American, Breakfast, Sandwiches

Have You Eaten Here?   Yes   No