91% say Yum
121 people voted
91% say Yum
121 people voted
People Who Viewed This Also Viewed
Hawkeye Nys Pizza ($)
Pizza, Subs, Sandwiches, Wings, Italian
Crispy's Pizza & Wings ($)
Pizza, Subs, Sandwiches, Wings
Tates Pizza ($)
Pizza, Subs, Salads, Wings
Texas de Brazil ($$$$)
| Add Photo
Is this your restaurant? Click to add your description here.
Hours: Add Hours
Credit Cards Accepted
$ - Cheap Eats (Under $10)
$$ - Moderate ($11-$25)
$$$ - Expensive ($25-$50)
$$$$ - Very Pricey (Over $50)
Reviews of Sam's New York Pizza
Mike posted on 01/16/2015
This was takeout: Calzone was well prepared and generous in size, Ravioli dinner was fine, however we ordered two garden salads for a total price of $28.70 incl a $2 tip for the order taker who was a very sweet young woman. However the salads were a bad joke, consisting of skimpy iceberg lettuce leaves brown at the stem ends with nothing else. the salads are supposed to conatin onions, cucumbers salt, romano cheese dressing and pepperoncino. Our salads had no dressing either on the salad or in containers as we had requested. The salads cost a total of seven dollars that's not right for a few ounces of unprepared iceberg lettuce. I called and spoke with Brian he said I could come by for new salads (5 miles away) or he would credit my next order. He didnt even bother to take my name down. Why does he think I would order again from him? I work hard for my money. Throwing away seven dollars plus a two dollar tip on one ounce of bare iceberg lettuce ends which I can get for a buck fifty a head at WalMart is not my idea of a good meal. The last time I ordered a pizza from Sam's I got something that looked and tasted like it had been cooked two days before and reheated. Tasted like BBQ sauce and looked like it. I'm done with this place.
Eric posted on 07/11/2011
Having grown up in NY I have always sought a Pizza place with the Right Taste and aroma. This is BY FAR, the most delicious Pizza in the entire Tampa area. You just don't understand until you try it, then you realize what the others lack and what you have been missing. Price is fair and certainly a great value considering the outstanding quality. Try SAM'S once, you'll be hooked!
Richie posted on 10/12/2010
I am from Jersey and this pizza takes me back to it. Good experience except for the one taking orders on the phone. Really hard to understand but the food made up for it
Jinjer posted on 11/11/2009
Sam's NY Pizza was our elementary school's Fall Festival's choice for food. They did an amazing job! They delivered 108 pizzas over a three hour time period!! Everyone said that it was awesome pizza!! Tony is the BEST!!!! Thanks so much!! We want to have you do it again next year!!
The Seafood Dive
Just had fish and chip dinners tonight. Absolutely horrible food..overdone overcooked...bad.......
(Sun City Center, FL)
I love this place! The mussel marinara is awesome!...
San Vito Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria
Food is incredible everything made from scratch Just like I'm used to in NJ/ NY . don't be in a hurry cause everything is freshly made . My new favori...
Hook Waterfront Bar and Grill
We have eaten at Hooks about six times: the food has been very good, fresh, and fair priced....
Terrible customer service... If you don't speak great English don't go here, they are rude.<br />
New girl on the register with a terrible att...