Sign in | 
- Youngstown Restaurant Guide - See Menus, Reviews, Maps and Make Reservations for thousands of restaurants in Youngstown and Ohio. -
Say Yum
61 people voted
Elmton ($$) $ - Cheap Eats (Under $10)
$$ - Moderate ($11-$25)
$$$ - Expensive ($25-$50)
$$$$ - Very Pricey (Over $50)

584 5th St
Struthers, OH 44471 (Map & Directions)
(330) 755-8511

Cuisine:   American
Location: Youngstown > Struthers
Delivery: Yes Attire: Casual Reservations:
Wifi: No Parking: Alcohol:
Good for Kids: Yes Outdoor Seats: No Payment: Credit Cards Accepted

User Reviews for Elmton
Carol Danvir posted on 04/09/2014
Rating & Review:
I have eaten Elmton pizza for over 50 years and enjoyed it. Ordered a 16 inch cheese pizza last Tuesday and was very disappointed in the taste. Something was wrong. It did not taste like the old familiar Elmton pizza. The crust was thinner, darker and it had less sauce and cheese. Not sure if this was because of the Tuesday special but not sure if we will ever order the pizza again. Have heard from several others who also thought something has changed in the taste and texture. Why would you change a tradition?
Mississippi Queen posted on 01/06/2014
Rating & Review:
I'm 53. My parents have been going to the Elmton since I was about 8 years old. The best pizza & broasted chicken dinners around. I've continued the tradition with my own family. Yes, they do get very busy at times, that's the result of serving great food. Their Italian dishes are also excellent. Very pleased. Another satisfied customer. Just goes to show you that you don't need all the "fluff" just great food & good service.
LovinItLocal posted on 06/26/2013
Rating & Review:
I've eaten pizza all over the US and without a doubt, the Elmton serves the best there is. The green peppers and provolone/swiss cheese topping make it a unique find in the boring world of mozzarella topped pies. The Youngstown area boasts an amazing number of great pizza parlors but the Elmton is number one. Don't forget to grab and order of broasted chicken for lunch the next day. It's so tasty, it may not last until later the same day, let alone tomorrow. A1 food and service!
D posted on 05/21/2013
Rating & Review:
The elmton rocks love the food and I think reviews are for people with a problem well I have none u win some and you lose some but this place Is great if u disagree we don't see eye to eye but leave it this way you don't like the elmton please keep it to yourself because you got problems
Donna from Struthers posted on 10/20/2010
Rating & Review:
Those of us from Struthers know that at times you need to wait for the food here, but, the wait is always worth it. It's a bar/restaurant and it's fabulous. They haven't stayed in business all these years because one family of 5 couldn't wait. Additionally you can get carry out, which at times takes an hour to get, they are that busy. Struthers people upon returning to the city first want Elmton pizza, then they go see their family and friends or better yet, they meet them at the Elmton. I've had to next day air their pizza to Texas because relatives there couldn't get good pizza and longed for the Elmton.
Unsatisfied posted on 09/10/2010
Rating & Review:
Unable to review the food due to my family of 5 had to wait over 55 minutes to be seated. Kids became tired and restless. Had to leave on an empty stomache. Needless to say, we won't be going back. Hostess never even offered any compensation for our wait. They had unorganized seating arrangements. There was no room for my family as we waited. At one point I informed the hostess that we would be willing to separate our group. She continued to seat smaller parties and continued to make our party wait. Families of 5 or more had better go elsewhere unless they have an enormous amount of patience.
Jim Neighbors posted on 05/29/2010
Rating & Review:
Great Pizza and good food.Reasonable prices.You get what you pay for.

Get Directions - See Larger Map


Recent Yum Votes
Hunan Express ($$)
Christy's Pastry Shoppe ($)
Sandwich Factory ($)
       Subs, Sandwiches, Wraps
Elys To Go ($)
       Vegetarian, Bakery, Organic
Elmton ($$)
Lariccia's Italian Marketplace ($$)
Lariccia's Italian Marketplace ($$)
Tangier Bar & Pizza ($$)
       Pizza, Subs, Sandwiches
FIesta Tapatia ($)
C's Waffles Family Restaurant ($)
       Breakfast, Brunch

People Who Viewed this also Viewed
Elmton ($)
       American, Pizza
Elm Tree ($$)
Aqua Ohio ($$)

Have You Eaten Here?   Yes   No