The Pizza Heist

Add Review

Call

Website

Menu

Location and Contact

See Map - Get Directions

231 Aurora St
Lancaster, NY 14086

Phone: (716) 681-1111

Website

Neighborhood: Lancaster

Update Listing

Popular Menu Items

• Small Pizza For 2 Special $18.99
• With cheese and one item pizza and 10 wings, or 5 chicken fingers.
• French Fries $3.99
• Crispy french fries, available in small or large sizes.
• Cheese (large) $16.99
• Large pizza with a choice of regular or thin crust, topped with mozzarella.
• Cheese (small) $9.99
• Small pizza with cheese topping. Choose between regular or thin crust.
• Chicken Wings (10 Pieces) $15.99
• 10-piece chicken wings. Choice of sauce: plain, hot, medium, mild, BBQ variations, garlic parm, honey mustard.

Hours

Update Hours

View the Menu

Update Details

Restaurant Description

Add a description here.

Restaurant Photos

View Menu

Write a Review for The Pizza Heist

Share Your
Experience!

Select a Rating Select a Rating!

Reviews for The Pizza Heist

Write a Review

  4.1 stars - Based on 15 reviews

#7 out of 52 restaurants in Lancaster

#2 of 9 Pizza in Lancaster

5 star				2 reviews	13%
4 star				13 reviews	87%
3 star				0 reviews	0%
2 star				0 reviews	0%
1 star				0 reviews	0%

Top Reviews of The Pizza Heist

07/05/2025 - Allie S.
The rich, oregano-heavy sauce and the slight biscuity crunch of the dough bring back warm childhood memories with every bite. The chicken finger pizza, layered with just the right amount of cheese and blue cheese base, stands out as an unforgettable flavor experience. Despite the busy atmosphere, orders arrive hot and fresh with friendly service that makes every visit feel welcoming and satisfying.

02/02/2025 - Jolene S.
This pizza place offers the best in Lancaster, consistently delivering fantastic flavors that keep me coming back. The chicken finger pizza is a standout with its generous toppings and perfect cheese blend, while the wings are crispy and flavorful. With quick service and friendly staff, it's a local favorite that never disappoints.

07/12/2024 - Nikita A.
Good food and great service.