Myrtle Avenue Market

Add Review

Call

Website

Menu

Location and Contact

See Map - Get Directions

2500 Myrtle Ave
Eureka, CA 95501

Phone: (707) 442-7407

Neighborhood: Eureka

Update Listing

Popular Menu Items

• Build Your Own Bagel Sandwiches $2.45
• Choose from closed or open-faced bagels, with options including ham, turkey, and smoked salmon. Customize with avocado, cucumber, lettuce, or opt for all veggies. Spread choices range from butter to cream cheese. Bagel varieties: cinnamon raisin, everything, parmesan, plain.
• Infused Redbull $5.95
• Redbull infused with customizable sweetness levels ranging from 0% to 125%. Choose between single or double, iced or blended. Flavors include amaretto, blackberry, seasonal options, and sugar-free varieties.
• Bagel With Cream Cheese (no Meat Option) $3.95
• Selection of bagels, including plain, everything, parmesan, and cinnamon raisin, paired with a choice of five cheeses, featuring cream cheese as a classic option.
• Biscuits And Gravy $6.25
• Savory biscuits covered in rich gravy. Choose from full or half order.
• Real Fruit Smoothie $6.25
• Real fruit blended into a smoothie with choice of eight alternative milks, adjustable sweetness up to 125%, available in four sizes.

Hours

Update Hours

View the Menu

Update Details

Restaurant Description

Add a description here.

Restaurant Photos

View Menu

Write a Review for Myrtle Avenue Market

Share Your
Experience!

Select a Rating Select a Rating!

Reviews for Myrtle Avenue Market

Write a Review

  4.3 stars - Based on 24 reviews

#103 out of 242 restaurants in Eureka

#1 of 1 Meat Shops in Eureka

5 star				10 reviews	42%
4 star				13 reviews	54%
3 star				0 reviews	0%
2 star				0 reviews	0%
1 star				1 review	4%

Top Reviews of Myrtle Avenue Market

04/24/2025 - Joseph B.
Since moving into the neighborhood in December 2022, I've seen some major changes at the market that reminded me of the quirky corner stores back in the city, where beer was king and produce was an emergency buy. The new owners are putting in the effort to give us what we want, and with friendly faces and a growing selection of delicious offerings, it's starting to feel like the local hub we've all been hoping for-especially those made-to-order sandwiches that are great for my biking adventures!

09/22/2024 - Gil W.
After moving into the neighborhood in December 2022, I found the local market to be reminiscent of city corner stores focused on beer sales. While some products seemed outdated and the sandwiches lacked flavor, I've noticed a positive shift in the store's atmosphere since speaking with the new owner and long-term employee. With improved produce and meat offerings, as well as a growing commitment to customer satisfaction, I believe the market has the potential to become a reliable choice for weekly grocery needs, especially for those in the community who may not have easy access to transportation. Friendly staff, a great selection, and delicious made-to-order sandwiches make it a convenient and enjoyable place to shop for everyday essentials.

06/28/2024 - Tree K.
Avant-garde!

08/25/2020 - MenuPix User
Deli Staff is quite rude

08/11/2019 - Grandma S.
Best small friendly and well stocked market in Eureka. Their meat department is outstanding as well as the deli. Give them a try, I know you will be pleased.

Menu