Old Time Pizza

Add Review

Call

Website

Menu

Location and Contact

See Map - Get Directions

19152 Market St
New Paris, IN 46553

Phone: (574) 831-4160

Website

Neighborhood: New Paris

Update Listing

Popular Menu Items

• 1-topping Pizza - Large 14" $12.99
• Large 14" pizza with choice of one topping: pepperoni, sausage, bacon, chicken, onions, green pepper, or green olive.
• Cheese Pizza - Large 14" $10.99
• Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza $6.49
• Chicken, bacon, and ranch.
• Works Pizza $6.49
• Pepperoni, sausage bacon, onions, and green pepper.
• 1-topping Pizza - Small 7" $5.99
• Small 7" pizza with choice of one topping: pepperoni, sausage, bacon, chicken, onions, green pepper, or green olive.

Hours

Update Hours

View the Menu

Update Details

Restaurant Description

Add a description here.

Restaurant Photos

View Menu

Write a Review for Old Time Pizza

Share Your
Experience!

Select a Rating Select a Rating!

Reviews for Old Time Pizza

Write a Review

  4.5 stars - Based on 21 reviews

#2 out of 5 restaurants in New Paris

#1 of 1 Pizza in New Paris

5 star				11 reviews	52%
4 star				10 reviews	48%
3 star				0 reviews	0%
2 star				0 reviews	0%
1 star				0 reviews	0%

Top Reviews of Old Time Pizza

03/03/2025 - Danita E.
The Broasted Chicken was incredibly moist, even the white meat, making it a standout choice for carryout. I was pleasantly surprised by the thin crust pizza loaded with toppings, cheese, and a delicious sauce; it quickly became my new favorite in Elkhart County. With a friendly atmosphere and a great variety on the menu, I look forward to returning for more of their amazing offerings.

07/06/2024 - Quinn C.
good