I Love New York Pizza

Reported as permanently closed. Find something similiar nearby.

Add Review

Call

Website

Menu

Location and Contact

See Map - Get Directions

2772 Elkcam Blvd
Deltona, FL 32738

Phone: (386) 532-1311

Website

Neighborhood: Deltona

Update Listing

Hours

This restaurant has been reported as permanently closed. Click here if it has reopened.

Monday:Closed
Tuesday:Closed
Wednesday:Closed
Thursday:Closed
Friday:Closed
Saturday:Closed
Sunday:Closed

Update Hours

View the Menu

Update Details

Restaurant Description

*This restaurant has closed. If this restaurant is open or has reopened, just let us know.

Is this your restaurant? Click to add your description here.

Restaurant Photos

View Menu

Write a Review for I Love New York Pizza

Share Your
Experience!

Select a Rating Select a Rating!

Reviews for I Love New York Pizza

Write a Review

  3.4 stars - Based on 15 votes

5 star				5 votes	33%
4 star				2 votes	13%
3 star				5 votes	33%
2 star				0 votes	0%
1 star				3 votes	20%

Top Reviews of I Love New York Pizza

12/19/2019 - Sylvia Vasquez
Best pizza in **TOWN**

01/24/2016 - Josh S.
As a guy from brooklyn myself, so far, i havent found a better pizza place in all of the four towns here, not in orange city, deland, deltona, or debary. By far the best ive found. When i order pizza, its from here.

10/22/2015 - Fr Jude
One star too many. Greasy Frank, a manager, does not care about quality or how cold and late the delivery was. He would not care if the pizza mushrooms had legs and walked. Is is true they are pets in New York? 10 22 15

07/26/2015 - Wendy D
We love this place. I can't comment on Deliver because we normally pick up or eat in. This is our normal Friday night spot when we aren't on a diet. There have been a couple of mix ups but they have always made it right. Love the food and the people.

06/10/2015 - Alice
Like the other review said...it is hit or miss here. Frank, I really don't think you can leave your staff unsupervised, even on a Tuesday. We have been going there for many years and really like the food. It is the service, or lack thereof that needs some attention. We decided to go last night and when we walked in we were greeted nicely by the head server saying glad you are here because we are so slow tonight. All I can say is that it went downhill from there. Another server took over our booth and we ordered a glass of Merlot. 10 mins. later she brought our wine while we were reading the menu. The wine was soured and hot. When she returned to take our order I informed her about the wine. She scooted away without taking our order and disappeared. After about 5 mins. she returned and apologized and said they sent someone to the store to buy wine. That wasn't really necessary we could have taken a substitute...and weren't there to drink...just wanted a glass of vino to accompany the meal. Anyway, she took our order which consisted of a large Greek salad, buffalo wings, 2 meatballs in sauce, (extra sauce please) garlic bread and a veggie calzone. We explained we were sharing the dishes and please bring out the salad first and follow bringing out our dishes in stages. About 10 mins. after that she brought us fresh wine. We had been there about an 1/2 hr. 10 mins. later she brought out 2 small side salads instead of the Greek salad. Upon questioning her she became very flustered and scooted away again. 10 more mins. until the Greek salad arrived and it looked great. She did not ask us about the dressing, so we had none. We waited to catch her eye. She then brought the Italian blend which was tasty. We barely started eating our salad and she shows back up and unloads the wings, meatballs and bread and said the calzone was almost done. Good grief... The head server was having great conversations with people in 2 different booths while the 3rd young gal was manning the phones. We asked her to please put a hold on the calzone, take the meatballs and wings and keep them warm while we eat the huge salad. It was very clear she needs guidance. To make this long story short... we ate half the salad, a few wings, one meatball and really had lost our appetite. She was missing again and I had to go up to the counter and request to-go boxes and to just box up the calzone that was sitting on the counter. The other young server came over and asked if she could do anything for us. I asked her who is in charge right now. She didn't seem to be sure but she did apologize. We just wanted out of there at this point. It appeared she was in the kitchen talking about us because she kept looking over and we made eye contact. We paid the bill and are looking forward to serving ourselves tonight. The wings we did eat were fantastic, the meatball and sauce yummy and the salad fresh... Too bad the service can't match the food. Not sure if we will give it one more shot...just which day might be the hit and not the miss.

04/12/2015 - Deltona residents
I will never order delivery again!! Food not right missing items! Took longer than I was told now still having to wait for the return visit for my salad. My stromboli is now cold! And is so all they call it a large! I have dined in and picked up many time and a large is so much bigger! Called to the manager James, he was rude and slammed the phone down on me ! I called back to be told he didn't have time to talk to me he was cooking..and slammed the phone down again. People skills wow he has NONE!

01/31/2015 - Loretta
I will never order delivery from this place again, delivery showed up thirty minutes later than time quoted and was spilled all over the bag and cold.

12/26/2010 - mr and mrs charles hernandez
with the exception of this waitress/server named neena, we were there eating for about 45 minutes and all we heard out of this young lady mouth was nothing but negative talk about the other customers"oh they only left me $2.00 dollars",also we noticed that she attended the male customers alot better than the females customers by acting flirtatious as to push for a higher tip! Very disturbing being a family eatery.

11/01/2010 - Scott Macedo
One of the most amazing little Italian restaurants in west volusia area.