Mikey's Pizza Pit Stop
Add Your Vote!
Menus People Viewed Nearby
Gina Marie's ($)
Pizza Hut ($)
Pizza King ($)
Christos Family Dining ($$)
Additional Dining Info
Credit Cards Accepted
Good for Kids
Beer and Wine
$ - Cheap Eats (Under $10)
$$ - Moderate ($11-$25)
$$$ - Expensive ($25-$50)
$$$$ - Very Pricey (Over $50)
tue - thur 11am to 9pm, fri and sat 11am to 10pm, sun 11am to 8pm
Great environment, with big screen tv's and music. Nice open concept you can watch your food being made in the kitchen from your seat in our dining room. Great place for kids and adults the same with our new kids menu and beer and wine liscense. Come in and see the Pit Crew at Mikey's Pizza Pit Stop!
| Add Photo
Top Reviews of Mikey's Pizza Pit Stop
03/11/2018 - Marcia
Last night we had some friends come up so we called in an order for the 1st time. .. We were told that it would be ready in 35 to 40 minutes. .. My husband & friend went in to pick up the order after the 40 minutes. .. they waited for an hour ( not exaggerating any) inside for the pizza & bread sticks... after they were gone for 50 minutes without hearing from them I called to make sure they didn't have car problems. ..only to find out that they were STILL WAITING FOR OUR PIZZA. ...My husband said that people were getting up & walking out because they never got their food. ... I then called Mikey's Pizza to find out why they were STILL WAITING & to find out if they were going to offset the bill for the wait only to be told that my husband would have to ask when he paid for the pizza. .. come to find out my husband had already paid for the pizza (plus the tip) when he walked in so nothing was done to even offset this unreal wait. .... UNBELIEVABLE. ... .
03/13/2017 - estaban
Hey,just tried Mikeys this last Saturday night.The place was nice and clean,seats were comfortable.The waitress was very knowledgable,courteous,and quick for the refills.The food was great.The pizza is perfect.Sandwiches are just the right size,and taste great.Our table had a little of everything on the menu with our orders,so it was easy to get a real "all-around" taste.Prices were competitive.WE WILL BE BACK!!!!!!!!Great job guys,don't change a thing!!
12/03/2016 - Erin
I usually order in, but am always happy with what I get. It's a pizza place that has specialty pizzas, so I like to go there when I'm not feeling traditional. Their chicken, bacon, and ranch subs are quite tasty too. And I always enjoy their hot wings. They have loaded cheese fries, which my kiddos go crazy over. Overall, it's a good place to go in a town full of pizza joints.
03/27/2016 - Tony
Food is absolutely terrible. Had there breadstix they were O.K just ok had a few left and they refused to give me a to go box for them.. I am serious they said if you buy to go you get a box if you buy for dine in then you get no box.. Try it for yourself and you will see NO JOKE.. O.K now about the pizza,, NO NO NO NO thats all i can say I had peperoni and italian Sausage the Sausage was TERRIBLE I am very seriouse it was all BAD.. I only went there because it was a Tuesday and they have dine in,, Gina Marie's Pizza is closed on Tuesday and she has no dine in but man I will wait for Wednesday and just get delivery in order to get some good pizza.. I am not trying to plug Gina Marie's But if your from Starke County then you understand what I am talking about Gina Marie's is no doubt the BEST Pizza in Starke County but besides That I can even go to Pizzahut and dine in and get some edible Pizza this Mikey's is honestly not for me.. If you like there Pizza I am sorry but it is what it is and I'm not even picky but if I'm gonna pay $20 for a pizza i better get some good pizza with at least REAL Sausage,, There Sausage was like par cooked soy or something like that,, I don't know but it was all bad
12/17/2013 - bill thompson
well this place was a breath of fresh air...certainly made me never want to come back. the food was very mediocre and the only reason i even went there was with a group. the drinks, super over price, a jack and coke for 7 bucks, no thanks. the fat manager mikey who looks like he is 15 is an arrogant jerk that seems to have no idea what he is doing, anyone could cook the food they make there at home. i could hear the kitchen staff talking and laughing for probably 30 minutes while i waited for the food, and when it finally came, it was completely wrong, the only thing i found decent about the place were the waitresses, very nice a apologetic, this place is ripping you off, the pizza is super bland and once again the prices are off the wall. ive heard mixed things about this place so i gave it a shot but never again, mikeys pizza pit stop, you are owed by a failed racecar driver that is trying to make ends meet with a pizza place. lose some weight and you might just win some races.
10/11/2013 - Autum
We were there for 20 minutes never even received menus or had anyone say they would be right with us. Some teenagers came in after us and received menus right away. Finally left with 2 crying children because the wanted pizza. Called and spoke with the manager who laughed when I said that we wouldn't be back. Apparently we are not the customers that get service at Mikey's.
12/11/2011 - Evony Anitsirk
GREAT food....love the tuscan and sicilian pizza. Definitely different from all the other same old pizza I've tried. I would go out of my way to get it....It's that good.
10/09/2011 - mrs. kinney
Pizza was great, and not greasy. clean & relaxing environment.staff was very freindly
07/16/2011 - jimbo
I wasnt impressed i still think Gina Marie's pizza is the best in the area. This place has a dine in and gina maries dosent but i will take mine to go if it means better. and in this case it does gina maries is alot better. I wish gina would get dine in though but she makes up with her delivery..
09/30/2009 - bob
This pizza is phenomenal! The buffalo chicken is the best. Would give another star, but it is slightly pricey. I would also recommend the brownie "oil slick" Our family loves it.
Recent Restaurant Reviews
Great food wonderful staff & for $10 extra the waitress will love you long time, great for a family outing...
Waymire's Corner Tap
had so much fun visiting this historical building - enjoying great food - the owner (there for 33 years) did it all! It will be a outing all seven of...
The Downtown Depot
I was just at the downtown depot.I was really disappointed.To start,the tables were pretty gross..I had breakfast,and it was way too salty,and the siz...
(San Pierre, IN)
I recommend this Bar / Restaurant. GREAT FOOD & GREAT CUSTOMERS too visit with.... Monticello IN., patron.... 3/2/16 .... Bull Durham ......
Sporty'z Grill & Bar
We recently moved away from this area. One of our greatest regrets about leaving is no longer eating regularly at this most appealing spot. Really g...