Timmy's Pizza & BBQ

Add Review

Call

Website

Menu

Location and Contact

See Map - Get Directions

105 N Randolph St
Garrett, IN 46738

Phone: (260) 357-6666

Website

Neighborhood: Garrett

Update Listing

Popular Menu Items

• Crazy Dough With Cheese $6.75
• Hand-stretched pizza dough with garlic butter, cheese & Greek seasoning.
• Railroader (14" Large) $23.75
• A vegetarian's worst nightmare! A meat lover's fantasy. "The all meat pizza" loaded with sausage, fresh ground beef, scrumptious bacon finished off with a layer of pepperoni and tender ham. A monster pizza held together by a ton of fresh mozzarella cheese. Great for the serious meat lover!
• Sausage Roll $11.99
• More than one gigantic foot of Italian sausage, juicy onions and a mound of mozzarella cheese, wrapped up in our freshest pizza dough. Served with our own bbq sauce upon request.
• Timmy’s Piggy Back Mac $13.99
• Built like a parfait starting with Mac & Cheese, then Timmy’s famous Baked Beans and topped with a generous amount of pulled pork.
• Pizza Roll $11.99
• Build your own treat with your choice of two of any of our delicious pizza toppings on the same fresh pizza dough, sauce & mozzarella cheese.

Hours

Update Hours

View the Menu

Update Details

Restaurant Description

Add a description here.

Restaurant Photos

View Menu

Write a Review for Timmy's Pizza & BBQ

Share Your
Experience!

Select a Rating Select a Rating!

Reviews for Timmy's Pizza & BBQ

Write a Review

  4.8 stars - Based on 30 reviews

#3 out of 19 restaurants in Garrett

#1 of 3 Pizza in Garrett

5 star				25 reviews	83%
4 star				4 reviews	13%
3 star				0 reviews	0%
2 star				1 review	3%
1 star				0 reviews	0%

Top Reviews of Timmy's Pizza & BBQ

12/05/2024 - Ashley A.
The BBQ chicken sandwich I ordered at this small, family-run eatery had a good flavor, but could have used more meat. The Railroader Chicago style pizza was a standout dish, and the double crust was a delicious touch. The ribs were a hit with my dining companions, boasting a great smoky flavor and a generous portion size.

04/21/2023 - MenuPix User
Great pizza and sandwiches!

01/24/2021 - MenuPix User
Get out of the bbq business!!!!
Ribs tasted boiled😝😝 and tuff

11/08/2015 - Sherian
Today I had my first Timmy's Train Wreck. It was worth the drive from Auburn to Garrett. The pizza was very "loaded" with Bar B Q and "lots" of cheese. Very gooey and tasty. Can't wait to try their ribs!!! :)

12/23/2012 - John Sprague
After growing up with Whistle-Stop Pizza and the GRINDERS, It has been 15 years since I've had a chance to get back and see if they were still in town. I found they are now Timmy's Pizza and BBQ. I went in and Asked if this is the same place and it is!! I ordered the GRINDER and YES YES YES!!! Still the GREATEST after all these years...same great taste I was wanting and loved. KEEP IT GOING GUYS!!!