Greiner's Submarine Shop

Add Review

Call

Website

Menu

Location and Contact

See Map - Get Directions

2126 Shelby St
Indianapolis, IN 46203

Phone: (317) 783-4136

Website

Neighborhood: Indianapolis

Update Listing

Popular Menu Items

• Owen's Philly Cheese Steak $13.95
• Our Famous Philly Cheese Steak , the same since 1969.
• Ray's 1969 Hoagie $13.95
• Genoa salami, beef salami, ham and provolone cheese. We recommend that you get this fixed up “old school” - lettuce, onion, tomato, pepperoncini, oregano, oil + vinegar, salt, and pepper.Oh, snap.
• The Hot Toddy $13.95
• Momma was hungry when she made this one . Meat,Meat and more Meat. Turkey , Pepperoni, Ham, Cappicola, Cheddar Cheese and Jalapeno Cheese toasted on house made bread.Not for the weak of heartYou're welcome.
• Mr. Turkey $12.95
• Our hand sliced turkey with provolone – not complicated. adding bacon is extra.This lovely ensemble is put on our house made bread. You won't forget this sammie.We promise.
• Baker's Blt $11.95
• This is a BLT that you will remember to get from us and not make at home. GENEROUS amounts of bacon, lettuce and tomato. We suggest mayo, but ... the choice is yours.

Hours

Update Hours

View the Menu

Update Details

Restaurant Description

Add a description here.

Restaurant Photos

View Menu

Write a Review for Greiner's Submarine Shop

Share Your
Experience!

Select a Rating Select a Rating!

Reviews for Greiner's Submarine Shop

Write a Review

  3.8 stars - Based on 17 reviews

#766 out of 3195 restaurants in Indianapolis

#11 of 125 Subs in Indianapolis

5 star				2 reviews	12%
4 star				10 reviews	59%
3 star				5 reviews	29%
2 star				0 reviews	0%
1 star				0 reviews	0%

Top Reviews of Greiner's Submarine Shop

07/25/2025 - Edward U.
The moment I stepped inside, the warmth of the industrial-chic interior and the lively banter behind the counter set the tone for something special. Each bite of the Hot Toddy sub was a symphony of perfectly balanced flavors, with thick cuts of meat and melted cheeses nestled in freshly baked bread that held everything together without faltering. Despite the unpretentious atmosphere, the friendly staff and generous portions made this experience feel like a comforting discovery worth savoring again and again.

01/04/2025 - Jordan N.
Spent a three-day weekend in Indianapolis and decided to try out Greiner's, the oldest sub shop in the city. While the exterior didn't seem fancy, we were pleasantly surprised by the welcoming atmosphere and the friendly staff. Ordered the Hot Toddy and Philly Cheesesteak subs, which turned out to be incredibly delicious and packed with flavorful ingredients. The experience at Greiner's was so impressive that we left excited to return soon and try more of their offerings.