Mill Creek Tavern

4.1

35 reviews

#6 out of 24 restaurants in Bayville

($$), American, Seafood, Steakhouse
Hours today: 4:30pm-9:00pm

Add Review

Call

Website

Location and Contact

See Map - Get Directions

275 Bayville Ave
Bayville, NY 11709

Phone: (516) 628-2000

Website

Neighborhood: Bayville

Update Listing

Bookmark Update Menus Edit Info Read Reviews Write Review

Hours

Open Today:

4:30pm-9:00pm
MondayClosed
Tuesday4:30pm-9:00pm
Wednesday4:30pm-9:00pm
Thursday4:30pm-9:00pm
Friday4:30pm-10:00pm
Saturday4:30pm-10:00pm
Sunday4:00pm-9:00pm

Update Hours

View the Menu

View Menus

Restaurant Details

Delivery
No

Payment
Credit Cards Accepted

Parking
Street

Good for Kids
Yes

Attire
Casual

Alcohol
Yes - Full Bar

Reservations
Yes

Cuisines:
American, Seafood, Steakhouse

Price Point
$$

WiFi
Yes

Outdoor Seats
No

Update Details

Restaurant Description

Add a description here.

Restaurant Photos

View Menu

See Menus

Write a Review for Mill Creek Tavern

Reviews for Mill Creek Tavern

Write a Review

4.1 stars - Based on 35 reviews

#6 out of 24 restaurants in Bayville

#2 of 6 American in Bayville

5 star	11 reviews	31%
4 star	19 reviews	54%
3 star	4 reviews	11%
2 star	1 review	3%
1 star	0 reviews	0%

Top Reviews of Mill Creek Tavern

06/11/2025 - Jaime Z.
The food at Mill Creek Tavern always hits the spot, especially the double pork chop that's so good I ordered it twice without hesitation. The cozy ambiance, friendly staff-shoutout to our witty server Kyle-and that fireplace (wish it had been lit!) make every visit feel like a mini celebration. Whether it's a casual happy hour with killer kung pao cauliflower or a German night feast with hearty schnitzel and perfectly seasoned dishes, this place never disappoints and keeps me coming back for more.

05/21/2024 - Adrian W.
Yum

Best Menus of Bayville Best Menus of Long Island

American Restaurants in Bayville Seafood Restaurants in Bayville Steakhouses in Bayville

Scoop & Coffee ($)
Bakery, Gelato, Coffee Shop
Distance: 0.03 miles

Brigitte's Bayville Luncheon ($)
American, Sandwiches, Burgers
Distance: 0.04 miles

Schultzy's Restaurant ($)
Seafood, Catering
Distance: 0.04 miles

Bayville Deli ($)
Deli, Sandwiches, American
Distance: 0.07 miles

Old Tappan Brewing Company ($$)
Breweries
Distance: 0.11 miles

Wall's Wharf ($$$)
Seafood, American

Ocean ($$$)
Seafood, American

Ship Wreck Tavern ($$)
Bar Food, American, Burgers, Seafood

Wall's Wharf ($$$)
Seafood, American

Porto Bello (Greenport, NY)

The outdoor setup by the marina features cozy couches and fire pits, while the main dining area offers a simple, umbrella-shaded ambiance with stunnin... see review

Aperitif (Rockville Centre, NY)

A surprise party for 15 on a Saturday night was flawlessly managed with ample space and attentive service from Alejandra and the entire team, making t... see review

Burrito Loco (Commack, NY)

The food here is consistently flavorful and fresh, with generous portions of burritos, bowls, and tasty options like birria tacos and shrimp nachos th... see review

Cookoo Rico (Bellmore, NY)

The food here always hits the mark with fresh ingredients and bold flavors that remind me of home. The atmosphere is cozy and welcoming, making it a p... see review

Tacos Mi Poblanita (Freeport, NY)

This restaurant has some of the best food I've had in a while, and the atmosphere is super chill. The staff are friendly and the menu has a great vari... see review

View Menus

Mill Creek Tavern
Home
Long Island
Long Island
Bayville

Long Island Restaurant Guide: See Menus, Ratings and Reviews for Restaurants in Long Island and New York

United States Restaurant Guide:

AK | AL | AR | AZ | CA | CT | CO | DE | FL | GA | HI | ID | IL | IN | IA | KS | KY | LA | MD | ME | MA | MI | MN | MS | MO | MT | NC | ND | NE | NV | NH | NJ | NM | NY | OH | OK | OR | PA | RI | SC | SD | TN | TX | UT | VT | VA | WA | WV | WI | WY

Canadian Major Cities and Provinces:

Mill Creek Tavern

Location and Contact

Hours

View the Menu

Restaurant Details

Restaurant Description

Restaurant Photos

View Menu

Write a Review for Mill Creek Tavern

Reviews for Mill Creek Tavern

Top Reviews of Mill Creek Tavern

Best Restaurants Nearby

Nearby Restaurants

Menus People Viewed Nearby

Recent Restaurant Reviews

Mill Creek Tavern

Location and Contact

Hours

View the Menu

Restaurant Details

Restaurant Description

Restaurant Photos

View Menu

Write a Review for Mill Creek Tavern

Reviews for Mill Creek Tavern

Top Reviews of Mill Creek Tavern

Best Restaurants Nearby

Nearby Restaurants

Menus People Viewed Nearby

Recent Restaurant Reviews

Oops, we can't find your location