Coyle's Homemade Ice Cream

Add Review

Call

Website

Menu

Location and Contact

See Map - Get Directions

75 Howells Rd
Bay Shore, NY 11706

Phone: (631) 666-2229

Website

Neighborhood: Bay Shore

Update Listing

Popular Menu Items

• Medium Homemade (8 Oz.) $8.15
• Sticky Finger Sundae $11.50
• Your choice of any 2 flavors of our homemade ice cream, peanut butter sauce, hot fudge, crunch, and Reese’s peanut butter cups.
• Large Homemade (12 Oz.) $9.00
• Waffle Bowl Sundae $11.50
• Includes 3 flavors and 2 toppings.
• Small Homemade (6 Oz.) $7.20

Hours

Update Hours

View the Menu

Update Details

Restaurant Description

Add a description here.

Restaurant Photos

View Menu

Write a Review for Coyle's Homemade Ice Cream

Share Your
Experience!

Select a Rating Select a Rating!

Reviews for Coyle's Homemade Ice Cream

Write a Review

  4.0 stars - Based on 25 reviews

#35 out of 211 restaurants in Bay Shore

#1 of 15 Ice Cream in Bay Shore

5 star				7 reviews	28%
4 star				13 reviews	52%
3 star				4 reviews	16%
2 star				1 review	4%
1 star				0 reviews	0%

Top Reviews of Coyle's Homemade Ice Cream

07/23/2025 - Marco D.
The ice cream here is incredibly creamy and made with evident care, featuring a wide array of unique flavors like pistachio with cherries and peanut butter fudge that never disappoint. The charming 1950s-inspired interior, combined with friendly service and plenty of seating options, creates a nostalgic and inviting atmosphere perfect for savoring every decadent bite.

05/22/2024 - Kisha L.
Tasty Menu