Ice Cream Cottage

Add Review

Call

Website

Menu

Location and Contact

See Map - Get Directions

1590 Montauk Hwy
Mastic, NY 11950

Phone: (631) 395-3580

Website

Neighborhood: Mastic

Update Listing

Popular Menu Items

• Medium Cup (3 Scoops) $7.57
• Medium Cup: Choice of 3 flavors from a variety including nut blends, fruit ices, classic and exotic chocolates, creamy delights, coffee variations, and special mixes like "Mom's Cake Batter".
• Large Cup (4 Scoops) $9.22
• Large Cup (4 Scoops) Ice Cream: Choose from over 50 flavors including classics and unique options like "Mom's Cake Batter," "Sicilian Pistachio," or "Cookie Dough Chunk."
• Small Cup (2 Scoops) $5.65
• Choose any 2 flavors for a delightful ice cream experience: from fruity to nutty, classic to unique, including banana nut crunch, black forest, cookie dough chunk, and more.
• Sundae (5 Scoops) $12.37
• Choose any 5 flavors for your sundae from an extensive selection, including classics and unique options like "Cookie Monster," "Sicilian Pistachio," and "Mom's Cake Batter."
• Super Sundae $14.73
• 5 scoops. choice of 3 flavors and 3 toppings.

Hours

Update Hours

View the Menu

Update Details

Restaurant Description

Add a description here.

Restaurant Photos

View Menu

Write a Review for Ice Cream Cottage

Share Your
Experience!

Select a Rating Select a Rating!

Reviews for Ice Cream Cottage

Write a Review

  4.7 stars - Based on 23 reviews

#3 out of 17 restaurants in Mastic

#1 of 3 Ice Cream in Mastic

5 star				16 reviews	70%
4 star				7 reviews	30%
3 star				0 reviews	0%
2 star				0 reviews	0%
1 star				0 reviews	0%

Top Reviews of Ice Cream Cottage

06/09/2025 - April H.
Ice Cream Cottage offers an amazing variety of creamy, homemade flavors that are both unique and delicious, with friendly staff and excellent service making every visit enjoyable. Their cakes are fantastic, and despite often being busy, the quality and taste make waiting worthwhile for a truly memorable treat.

02/10/2025 - Matthew S.
The ice cream at Ice Cream Cottage is absolutely fantastic, with a wide array of unique flavors that never disappoint. The friendly staff and cozy atmosphere make every visit enjoyable, and I always look forward to bringing my family for a sweet treat!