Bagels Your Way

Add Review

Call

Website

Menu

Location and Contact

See Map - Get Directions

331 Rte 25A
Mount Sinai, NY 11766

Phone: (631) 473-8266

Website

Neighborhood: Mount Sinai

Update Listing

Popular Menu Items

• Bagel With Cream Cheese/spread/butter $4.75
• Bagel served with choice of butter, jelly, or plain cream cheese. Select from over 20 bread types including whole wheat, sesame, poppy, onion, garlic, everything, and cinnamon raisin options.
• Egg Sandwich $7.00
• Soon-To-Be; Almost World-Famous. Fresh Made To Order Egg Sandwiches. Always Made With Farm Fresh Eggs.
• 1 Dozen Assorted Bagels & 1 Half-pound Spread $20.00
• 12 bagels of your choice & 1/2 LB of cream cheese. Choose from: Bialy, Cinnamon Raisin Bagel, Egg Bagel, Egg Everything Bagel, Egg Onion Roll, Everything Bagel, Everything Flagel, Everything Twist, Garlic Bagel, HERO, Onion Bagel, Pain Roll, Plain Bagel, Plain Twist, Plain Wrap, Poppy Bagel, Poppy Roll, Pumpernickel Bagel, Rye Bagel, Rye Bread, Salt Bagel, Sesame Bagel, Sesame Flagel, Sesame Twist, Sunflower Bagel, Sunflower Flagel, White Bread, Whole Wheat Bagel, Whole Wheat Bread, Whole Wheat Roll, Whole Wheat Sunflower Bagel or Whole Wheat Wrap
• Side Of Home Fries $5.00
• Our Soon-To-Be Famous Home Fries "CRISPY POTATO CUBES".
• Hot Coffee $3.00
• Drip coffee with size options: large, medium, small.

Hours

Sorry, we don't have hours for this restaurant yet. We'll be updating the hours for this restaurant soon.

Monday: Add Hours
Tuesday:
Wednesday:
Thursday:
Friday:
Saturday:
Sunday:

Update Hours

View the Menu

Update Details

Restaurant Description

Add a description here.

Restaurant Photos

View Menu

Write a Review for Bagels Your Way

Share Your
Experience!

Select a Rating Select a Rating!

Reviews for Bagels Your Way

Write a Review

  3.5 stars - Based on 13 reviews

#19 out of 40 restaurants in Mount Sinai

#1 of 2 Bagels in Mount Sinai

5 star				2 reviews	15%
4 star				4 reviews	31%
3 star				6 reviews	46%
2 star				1 review	8%
1 star				0 reviews	0%

Top Reviews of Bagels Your Way

07/27/2025 - Irving P.
The bagels here are consistently fresh and delicious, especially the egg sandwiches which are truly satisfying. The staff and owners are incredibly friendly, providing quick and attentive service that makes each visit enjoyable. I've found this deli to be reliable for both everyday orders and special events, always impressing with quality and exceptional customer care.