Better On A Bagel

Add Review

Call

Website

Menu

Location and Contact

See Map - Get Directions

4960 Nesconset Hwy
Port Jefferson Station, NY 11776

Phone: (631) 473-5858

Neighborhood: Port Jefferson Station

Update Listing

Popular Menu Items

• Two Eggs $5.75
• Two eggs prepared in your chosen style: over medium, sunny-side up, over hard, over easy, or scrambled.
• Bagel With Cream Cheese $4.50
• A bagel topped with cream cheese. Choose from a selection of bagel types, including garlic, asiago, sunflower, everything, plain, cinnamon raisin, pumpernickel, salt sticks, poppy, egg everything, egg, wheat, bialy's, onion, sesame, or salt.
• Bagel With Butter $3.75
• Enjoy a soft, freshly-baked bagel of your choice, slathered with rich, creamy butter. Choose from options such as garlic, plain, everything, egg, or cinnamon raisin, amongst others.
• Bagels $1.75
• Choose from a variety of bagels like Egg, Poppy, Salt Sticks, Wheat or try the size options.
• Bagel With Flavored Cream Cheese $5.50
• A toasted bagel of your choice served with deliciously spread flavored cream cheese. Opt for unique flavors like Walnut Raisin, Lox Spread or Jalapeno Cheddar.

Hours

Update Hours

View the Menu

Update Details

Restaurant Description

Add a description here.

Restaurant Photos

View Menu

Write a Review for Better On A Bagel

Share Your
Experience!

Select a Rating Select a Rating!

Reviews for Better On A Bagel

Write a Review

  4.3 stars - Based on 17 reviews

#33 out of 58 restaurants in Port Jefferson Station

#4 of 4 Bagels in Port Jefferson Station

5 star				5 reviews	29%
4 star				12 reviews	71%
3 star				0 reviews	0%
2 star				0 reviews	0%
1 star				0 reviews	0%

Top Reviews of Better On A Bagel

06/30/2025 - Jasmine G.
The bagels here are always fresh, fluffy, and generously sized, with perfectly cooked bacon that never disappoints. The staff is friendly and mindful of hygiene, the prices are reasonable for the quality, and the breakfast sandwiches and wraps consistently satisfy my cravings.

12/08/2024 - Erika O.
My absolute favorite spot for bagels in the Port Jeff/Mt Sinai area is this gem of a bagel store. The bacon is always perfectly crispy, and the bagels are consistently full, fresh, and delicious. I can't recommend this place enough for anyone looking for a top-quality bagel experience in the area.