Anthony's Coal Fire Pizza

Add Review

Call

Website

Menu

Location and Contact

See Map - Get Directions

137 Old Country Rd
Carle Place, NY 11514

Phone: (516) 877-7750

Website

Neighborhood: Carle Place

Update Listing

Popular Menu Items

• Coal Oven Roasted Chicken Wings $11.99+
• Create Your Own 16" Pizza $22.19
• Grande mozzarella, hand crushed Italian plum tomato sauce, hand grated Romano cheese, basil and olive oil
• Anthony's Classic Italian Salad $11.99+
• Romaine, celery, red onions, garbanzo beans, kalamata olives, tomato and hard cooked egg tossed in our homemade Italian dressing.
• Create Your Own 12" $18.59
• Grande mozzarella, hand crushed Italian plum tomato sauce, hand grated Romano cheese, basil and olive oil
• Garlic Knots $5.99+
• Garlic Knots made with fresh baked dough, garlic, olive oil, parsley, Romano Cheese.

Hours

Update Hours

View the Menu

Update Details

Restaurant Description

Add a description here.

Restaurant Photos

View Menu

Write a Review for Anthony's Coal Fire Pizza

Share Your
Experience!

Select a Rating Select a Rating!

Reviews for Anthony's Coal Fire Pizza

Write a Review

  3.9 stars - Based on 51 reviews

#4 out of 66 restaurants in Carle Place

#1 of 4 Pizza in Carle Place

5 star				14 reviews	27%
4 star				21 reviews	41%
3 star				13 reviews	25%
2 star				2 reviews	4%
1 star				1 review	2%

Top Reviews of Anthony's Coal Fire Pizza

04/01/2025 - Amy M.
The wings and build-your-own pizza were fantastic, and the service from Jeremy was impressive. We enjoyed the Sweet Caroline wings and the Carnivori pizza, which was loaded with delicious toppings. Overall, the casual atmosphere and attentive staff made for a memorable dining experience that I look forward to repeating soon.

08/05/2024 - Erik G.
I had a wonderful experience at the restaurant with great food and service. The server was attentive and friendly, making sure we had everything we needed for a fantastic evening out.

06/19/2024 - Kadie B.
Awesome place to eat