New Sheffield Cafe
New Sheffield Cafe > Menu View Details
Prices and menu items are subject to change. Contact the restaurant for the most up to date information.
- Salads
- Steak Salad - Large $16.80
- Our house specialty! We start with a bed of fresh lettuce surrounded with hard boiled egg slices, onions, tomato, black olives and pepperoncini. Topped off with golden fries, provolone cheese and our delicious tender sirloin.
- Chicken Salad - Large $15.75
- Two grilled chicken filets served atop fresh lettuce with hard boiled egg slices, onions, tomato, black olives and pepperoncini. Topped off with golden fries, provolone cheese.
- Steak Salad - Small $14.70
- Our house specialty! We start with a bed of fresh lettuce surrounded with hard boiled egg slices, onions, tomato, black olives and pepperoncini. Topped off with golden fries, provolone cheese and our delicious tender sirloin.
- Nugget Salad - Large $14.70
- Tasty fried chicken tenders on a bed of lettuce, provolone cheese, onions, tomatoes, black olives, pepperoncini and golden fries.
- Chicken Salad - Small $14.65
- Two grilled chicken filets served atop fresh lettuce with hard boiled egg slices, onions, tomato, black olives and pepperoncini. Topped off with golden fries, provolone cheese.
- Nugget Salad - Small $13.60
- Tasty fried chicken tenders on a bed of lettuce, provolone cheese, onions, tomatoes, black olives, pepperoncini and golden fries.
- Nug & Stk Salad - Large $16.80
- Tasty fried chicken tenders and steak on a bed of lettuce, provolone cheese, onions, tomatoes, black olives, pepperoncini and golden fries.
- Gyro Salad - Large $14.17
- We start with a bed of fresh lettuce, surrounded with hard boiled egg slices, onions, tomatoes, black olives and pepperoncini. Topped with golden fries and crumbled feta cheese. Served with our house made dill sauce and a pita.
- Chicken & Steak Salad - Large $16.80
- Caesar Salad - Large $10.97
- Crisp romaine lettuce topped with croutons, shaved parmesan and Caesar dressing.
- Fish Salad - Large $16.80
- Our lightly breaded cod deep-fried to a golden brown atop a crisp bed of lettuce with hard boiled egg slices, tomatoes, onions, black olives and pepperoncini. Topped off with golden fries and provolone cheese.
- Nug & Stk Salad - Small $15.75
- Tasty fried chicken tenders and steak on a bed of lettuce, provolone cheese, onions, tomatoes, black olives, pepperoncini and golden fries.
- Chicken & Steak Salad - Small $15.75
- Caesar Salad - Small $8.87
- Crisp romaine lettuce topped with croutons, shaved parmesan and Caesar dressing.
- Grilled Shrimp Salad - Small $14.70
- Our fresh grilled shrimp atop a bed of lettuce with hard boiled egg slices, tomatoes, onions, black olives and pepperoncini. Topped off with golden fries and provolone cheese.
- Taco Salad - Large $14.17
- A crisp bed of lettuce topped with onions, tomatoes, black olives, pepperoncini and cheddar cheese. Topped with our house made tortilla chips, chili and melted cheddar cheese sauce. A Mexican treat! Served with salsa and sour cream.
- Tossed Salad - Large $7.82
- Crisp lettuce topped with tomatoes, onions, black olives and pepperoncini. Served with your choice of dressing.
- Chef Salad - Small $13.07
- Fresh lettuce topped with delicious ham, salami and lean turkey. Garnished with hard boiled egg slices, tomatoes, onions, black olives, pepperoncini and provolone cheese.
- Taco Salad - Small $13.07
- A crisp bed of lettuce topped with onions, tomatoes, black olives, pepperoncini and cheddar cheese. Topped with our house made tortilla chips, chili and melted cheddar cheese sauce. A Mexican treat! Served with salsa and sour cream.
- Tossed Salad - Small $5.72
- Crisp lettuce topped with tomatoes, onions, black olives and pepperoncini. Served with your choice of dressing.
- Chef Salad - Large $14.17
- Fresh lettuce topped with delicious ham, salami and lean turkey. Garnished with hard boiled egg slices, tomatoes, onions, black olives, pepperoncini and provolone cheese.
- Gyro Salad - Small $13.07
- We start with a bed of fresh lettuce, surrounded with hard boiled egg slices, onions, tomatoes, black olives and pepperoncini. Topped with golden fries and crumbled feta cheese. Served with our house made dill sauce and a pita.
- Grilled Shrimp Salad - Large $16.80
- Our fresh grilled shrimp atop a bed of lettuce with hard boiled egg slices, tomatoes, onions, black olives and pepperoncini. Topped off with golden fries and provolone cheese.
- Fish Salad - Small $14.70
- Our lightly breaded cod deep-fried to a golden brown atop a crisp bed of lettuce with hard boiled egg slices, tomatoes, onions, black olives and pepperoncini. Topped off with golden fries and provolone cheese.
- Sandwiches
- Build A Burger $11.50
- Make your own creation.
- Gyro $9.40
- Savory gyro meat, lettuce, tomato, onion and fresh made cucumber dill sauce served on pita bread.
- Turkey Bacon Club Sandwich $13.07
- Turkey, bacon, provolone, lettuce, tomato and mayonnaise, stacked high between three slices of toasted sourdough bread.
- Philly Steak Hoagie $11.50
- Thinly sliced sirloin grilled with sautéed mushrooms, onions and green peppers. Topped with provolone cheese on a fresh grilled hoagie bun.
- Fish Sandwich $13.60
- Generous haddock filet, hand breaded and deep fried golden brown.
- Reuben Sandwich $12.55
- Our tasty corned beef topped with sauerkraut, Swiss cheese and dressing. Served on grilled rye bread.
- Italian Hoagie $11.50
- Generous portions of ham, salami, pepperoni and provolone cheese. Toasted and topped with lettuce, tomato and onion. Served with Italian dressing on the side.
- Meatball Hoagie $10.97
- Lori's delicious meatballs topped with our tangy sauce and melted provolone cheese.
- Chicken Philly Hoagie $11.50
- Thinly sliced chicken breast grilled with sautéed mushrooms, onions and green peppers. Topped with provolone cheese on a fresh grilled hoagie bun.
- Tuna Melt Sandwich $9.40
- Our tuna salad topped with American cheese and grilled to perfection on sourdough bread.
- Triple Decker Sandwich $13.07
- Turkey, baked ham, provolone, lettuce, tomato and mayonnaise, stacked high between three slices of toasted sourdough bread.
- Blt Sandwich $9.40
- Bacon, lettuce, tomato and mayonnaise on toasted sourdough bread.
- Hot Sausage Sandwich $9.40
- Hot sausage patty smothered in peppers and onions, topped with provolone cheese. Served on a fresh grilled hoagie bun with a side of sauce.
- Grilled Cheese Sandwich $7.30
- Your choice of American, provolone, Swiss, cheddar or hot pepper cheese, grilled on your choice of rye or sourdough bread.
- Grilled Chicken Sandwich $9.40
- Tender grilled chicken filet lightly seasoned and grilled to perfection. Topped with lettuce, tomato and mayonnaise.
- Starters
- Munchie Platter $15.75
- Potato skins, fried zucchini, provolone sticks, hot pepper cheese balls and beer battered onion rings. Enough for sharing.
- Bavarian Pretzel Sticks $12.55
- 6 sticks served with your choice of cheddar cheese sauce or beer cheese dip.
- Hot Cheese Balls $8.93
- Deep fried hot pepper cheese served with horsey sauce
- Provolone Sticks $8.35
- Served with marinara sauce
- Homemade Buffalo Chicken Dip $12.55
- Served with house made tortilla chips
- Potato Skins $9.71
- Loaded with cheddar cheese and bacon crumbles. Served with sour cream.
- Spinach Artichoke Dip $12.55
- Fresh spinach and artichokes in a bubbly cheese sauce topped with melted provolone and diced tomatoes. Served with our house made tortilla chips and bite size Italian bread.
- Chicken Quesadilla $12.55
- Made with chicken, shredded cheddar, provolone, grilled peppers and onions. Served with sour cream and salsa.
- Stuffed Hot Banana Peppers $13.07
- 3 banana peppers stuffed with a mixture of hot sausage and cheese. Topped with marinara sauce and mozzarella cheese. Served with a bread stick.
- Nachos Supreme $15.75
- Crispy nachos loaded with your choice of spicy beef or chicken. Topped with cheese, tomatoes, black olives and jalapenos. Served with salsa and sour cream.
- Steak Quesadilla $13.60
- Made with steak, shredded cheddar, provolone, grilled peppers and onions. Served with sour cream and salsa.
- Fried Breaded Mushrooms $9.40
- Zucchini Planks $9.71
- Topped with parmesan cheese and served with marinara sauce.
- Cafe Chips $8.14
- Freshly made thin sliced deep-fried potatoes sprinkled with seasoned salt and served with ranch dressing for dipping.
- Fried Dill Pickle Spears $9.40
- Basket Of Bread Sticks $8.35
- Garlic bread sticks dusted with parmesan, served with marinara for dipping.
- Basket Of Fries $6.56
- Fried Banana Pepper Ring Basket $9.71
- Served with horsey sauce
- Basket Of Onion Rings $9.40
- Shrimp Quesadilla $14.65
- Made with shrimp, shredded cheddar, provolone, grilled peppers and onions. Served with sour cream and salsa.
- Nachos W/cheese $8.87
- Our house made tortilla chips topped with cheese sauce and jalapeno peppers, served with sour cream
- Veggie Quesadilla $11.50
- Basket Of Sweet Potato Fries $8.35
- Cheese Quesadilla $10.45
- Basket Of Waffle Fries $7.61
- Fried Shrimp $10.45
- Coconut Shrimp. $10.45
- 6 crispy coconut battered shrimp served with our pina colada sauce.
- Baskets & Wraps
- Chicken Tenders & Fries $13.60
- Hand breaded fresh white meat chicken deep fried crispy, along side fries, try them buffalo style or with any of our wing sauces.
- Buffalo Chicken Wrap $11.50
- Fried chicken tenders tossed in a buffalo sauce in a warm tortilla wrap with lettuce, shredded provolone, ranch dressing and our red pepper pesto. Served with fries.
- Shrimp Basket $14.65
- Butterfly shrimp served with fries and coleslaw.
- Burger Wrap $11.50
- Our very own house made Angus beef burger wrapped in a warm tortilla with lettuce, tomato, mayonnaise and your choice of cheese. Served with fries.
- Grilled Chicken Wrap $11.50
- Grilled chicken in a warm tortilla wrap with lettuce, shredded provolone, ranch dressing and our red pepper pesto. Served with fries.
- Chicken Tender Wrap $11.50
- Chicken Tenders in a warm tortilla wrap with lettuce, shredded provolone, ranch dressing and our red pepper pesto. Served with fries.
- Fish Basket $13.60
- Cod nuggets served with fries and coleslaw.
- Coconut Shrimp Basket $14.70
- Butterfly coconut shrimp served with fries, coleslaw and our pina colada dipping sauce.
- Café Mixes
- Nugget Mixer $12.55
- A mix of chicken nuggets, golden fries, shredded provolone & cheddar cheese and your choice of dressing. Sure to be a favorite!
- Steak Mixer $15.22
- A mix of steak, golden fries, shredded provolone & cheddar cheese and your choice of dressing. Sure to be a favorite!
- Steak & Nugget Mixer $14.12
- A mix of steak & chicken nugget, golden fries, shredded provolone & cheddar cheese and your choice of dressing. Sure to be a favorite!
- Gyro Mixer $11.50
- A mix of gyro meat, golden fries, shredded provolone & cheddar cheese and your choice of dressing. Sure to be a favorite!
- Steak & Chicken Mixer $15.22
- A mix of chicken & steak, golden fries, shredded provolone & cheddar cheese and your choice of dressing. Sure to be a favorite!
- Chicken Mixer $14.65
- A mix of chicken, golden fries, shredded provolone & cheddar cheese and your choice of dressing. Sure to be a favorite!
- Pasta
- Fettucine Alfredo $13.60
- Served with a tossed salad and breadstick.
- Penne Alla Vodka $13.60
- Served with a tossed salad and breadstick.
- Linguine & Meatball $12.55
- Topped with our marinara sauce.Served with a tossed salad and breadstick.
- Desserts
- Colossal Chocolate Mousse Cake $8.87
- New York Colossal Cheesecake $8.87
- Chocolate Pb Thunder Cake $8.35
- Strawberry Shortcake $9.40
- Salted Carmel Brownie $5.72
- With Pretzel Crust
- Limoncello Cake $6.77
- Chocolate Ganache Cheesecake $8.87
- Carrot Cake $8.87
- Summerberry Stack Cake $7.82
- Lemon Curd Cake $10.45
- Chocolate Marshmallow Cake $9.92
- Cinnamon Roll Cheesecake $8.87
- Red Velvet Cake $9.92
- Butter Pecan Cheesecake $7.30
- Coconut Cream Pie Cheesecake $8.35
- Snickers Pie $8.87
- Peanut Butter Pie $8.87
- Wings
- Wingers $17.11
- 12 Jumbo Cut Wings. Served with celery sticks and choice of ranch or bleu cheese dressing.
- Boneless Wings- 1 Pound $14.70
- Plump, juicy white meat. They're great! No bones about it! Served with celery sticks and choice of ranch or bleu cheese dressing.
- Boneless Wings - 1/2 Pound $10.45
- Plump, juicy white meat. They're great! No bones about it! Served with celery sticks and choice of ranch or bleu cheese dressing.
- Whole Wings - 12 Pc $23.41
- Served with celery sticks and choice of ranch or bleu cheese dressing.
- Whole Wings - 6 Pc $17.11
- Served with celery sticks and choice of ranch or bleu cheese dressing.
- Café Favorites
- Steak 'n' Noodles $15.75
- Generous portion of noodles served with our fresh grilled sirloin tips, fresh sliced mushrooms and smothered in our house made gravy.
- Bret's Special $17.11
- A mix of fresh grilled steak, chicken breast and grilled shrimp. Served with our rice pilaf and fresh green beans.
- Chicken Naturelle $15.22
- Two tender grilled chicken fillets, lightly seasoned. Served with fresh green beans and BBQ sauce.
- Hot Sandwiches
- Hot Hamburger $12.55
- Our fresh grilled burger on white bread. Served with your choice of mashed potatoes or fries, smothered in our rich beef gravy.
- Hot Roast Beef Sandwich $14.65
- Lean thin slices of beef piled high on white bread. Served with your choice of mashed potatoes or fries, smothered in our gravy.
- Hot Turkey Sandwich $13.60
- Lean slices of our fresh baked turkey breast piled high on white bread. Served with your choice of mashed potatoes or fries, smothered in our turkey gravy.
- Kiddie Menu
- Kids- Cheeseburger Sliders $7.30
- Comes with fries.Available for our guests 12yrs old and younger.
- Kids- Chicken Nuggets $7.30
- Comes with fries.Available for our guests 12yrs old and younger.
- Kids- Linguine & Meatball $6.25
- Available for our guests 12yrs old and younger.
- Kids- Grilled Cheese $6.25
- Comes with fries.Available for our guests 12yrs old and younger.
- Kids -fish Nuggets $7.30
- Comes with fries.Available for our guests 12yrs old and younger.
- Rolls
- Pepperoni Rolls $7.34
- Buffalo Chicken Rolls $8.39
- Pizza
- 8" Pizza $9.44
- 14" Pizza $13.64
- Build Your Own Flatbread $8.35
- Soup/Chili
- Homemade Chili - Bowl $5.20
- Meaty and delicious with just the right amount of spices!
- Nacho Chili - Bowl $7.30
- Meaty and delicious with just the right amount of spices!
- Café Kabobs
- Chicken Kabob $14.17
- Chicken, grilled to perfection, served with tossed salad, rice pilaf and a pita.
- Lamb Kabob $15.75
- Lamb, grilled to perfection, served with tossed salad, rice pilaf and a pita.
- Beef Kabob $15.75
- Beef, grilled to perfection, served with tossed salad, rice pilaf and a pita.
- Shrimp Kabob $15.75
- Shrimp, grilled to perfection, served with tossed salad, rice pilaf and a pita.
- Lamb & Beef Kabob $16.80
- Lamb & Beef, grilled to perfection, served with tossed salad, rice pilaf and a pita.
- Extras
- Side Of Meat $2.61
- Side Of Dressing/sauce $0.01
- Side Cheese $1.46
- Side Of Bread/pasta $1.04
- Side Of Veggies $1.88
- Additional Sides
- Side Of Fries $4.15
- Bowl Of Mac & Cheese $5.20
- Side Of Mac & Cheese $4.15
- Mashed Potatoes $3.41
- Side Of Onion Rings $4.15
- Side Of Waffle Fries $4.15
- Side Of Cafe Chips $4.15
- Side Of Fried Banana Pepper Rings $4.15
- Side Of Sweet Potato Fries $4.15
- Coleslaw $1.89
- To Go Drinks
- Pop (can) $2.18
- Water Bottle $1.05
Similiar Restaurants Nearby:
-
J W Halls Steak Inn ($$)
Steak, Steakhouse, American, Seafood -
Harold's Inn Tavern ($$)
Bar Food, American -
Breezy's Pizza ($$)
Pizza, Subs, Sandwiches