Gelotti Ice Cream of Caldwell

• Cups & Pints
• Hard Ice Cream (pint And Quart) $13.20
• Slow churned, high butterfat ice cream. winner of best ice cream in morris & essex county.

• Soft Serve Cups $4.80
• The same base as our ice cream, just in a soft creamy form.

• Gelato (cups) $6.45
• 2019 Winner Best Gelato in North America. #7 Ranked Gelato in the world recognized in Italy by the official Gelato Festival.

• Italian Ice (cups) $5.15

• Italian Ice (pints And Quarts) $12.00

• Gelato (pints And Quarts) $14.60
• 2019 winner best gelato in north america. 7 ranked gelato in the world recognized in italy by the official gelato festival.

• Granita $7.80
• A mix of Soft Serve Ice Cream and our homemade Italian ice.

• Verdi Cups $6.00
• This Gelato is Creamy, Smooth, and just a delicious as our regular ice cream but completely plant based, dairy free, and vegan. We call it "Verdi" which means green in italian! Made with Ripple Plant Milk.

• Toppings $1.20

• Hard Ice Cream (cups) $5.65
• Our classic homemade hard ice cream.

• Breezy Sundae $9.00
• Layer Soft Server with toppings in a shake cup.

• Sandwiches & Novelties
• Mini Chips (dozen) $20.55
• One Dozen Mini Chip sandwiches featuring our nut free house baked chocolate chips.

• Mini Cones (15 Pk) $21.75
• A package of 15 mini Vanilla, Chocolate, and Strawberry Cones dipped in White, Dark, and Ruby Chocolate.

• Mini Oreos (one Dozen) $19.35
• One Dozen Mini Oreo Cookie Sandwiches.

• Mini Monsters (dozen) $21.75
• A package of one dozen mini sandwiches made with cookie monster ice cream.

• Gluten Free Mini Oreos $21.75
• Pack of 12 Gluten Free Mini Oreo Cookie Sandwiches. Made with gluten free oreos and Vanilla Ice Cream

• Big Chips (4 Pack) $20.55
• (4 PACK) Two chocolate chip cookies with vanilla ice cream in the middle, rolled in chocolate chips.

• Small Freezer Bag $4.80
• 15" x 12" x 6" Bag that can fit up to 6 Pints.

• 6 Pack Ic Sandwich $13.80
• 6 pack of ice cream sandwiches made with soft serve ice cream.

• Large Freezer Bag $7.20
• 20" x 20" x 7" Bag that can fit up to a 10" Cake.

• Shakes & Drinks
• (gelato) Milkshake $9.00
• Milkshake made with Gelato.

• (ice Cream) Milkshake $9.00
• Classic Milkshakes made with ice cream.

• Bottle Of Water $1.80
• 16.9oz bottle of water

• Cakes & Pies
• Stock Cakes (same Day) $33.75
• Nut Free - Vanilla & Chocolate with Fudge and Crunchies, decorated the way you would like! (flavors cannot be changed)

• Byo Gelato New Year's (48 Hrs) $38.55
• new years cake

• Byo Gelato Winter/holiday (48 Hrs) $38.55

• Death By Peanut Butter Pie $28.95
• Our new Pies start with a fresh baked brownie bottom, layer of peanut butter, layer of choc. peanut butter ice cream, topped with fresh whip cream, peanut butter cups, peanut butter, and chocolate drizzle.

• Oreo Explosion Brownie Pie $28.95
• Our new Pies start with a fresh baked brownie bottom, layer of fudge, layer of ice cream, topped with fresh whip cream, Oreos, and chocolate drizzle. Available in Vanilla or Mint.

• Baci Cake (same Day) $45.75
• These cakes come in Hazelnut and Chocolate Hazelnut but are just one flavor with no middle filling, decorated to match the flavor. 8" cake serves 12-14.

• Cookie Monster Cake (same Day) $45.75
• These cakes come in Cookie Monster and are just one flavor with no middle filling, decorated to match the flavor. 8" cake serves 12-14.

• Cheesecakes
• Stock Cheesecakes (same Day) $25.35