Steel City Pizza & Sandwich Co.

Add Review

Call

Website

Menu

Location and Contact

See Map - Get Directions

4801 Peach St
Erie, PA 16509

Phone: (814) 866-0337

Neighborhood: Erie

Update Listing

Popular Menu Items

• Handmade Fresh Dough (large 16" (12 Cuts)) $13.99
• Steel City Pizza and Sandwich Company is proud to serve our award-winning pizza! All of our thin-crust pizzas are made with our fresh, handmade dough, garden fresh tomato sauce, and our special blend of two provolone cheeses.
• Fresh Cut $6.00
• Yes, we have malt vinegar!
• Wings (1 Pound) $11.00
• Approximately 7 wings. Extra sauce for an additional charge.
• Handmade Fresh Dough (small 12" (8 Cuts)) $11.99
• Steel City Pizza and Sandwich Company is proud to serve our award-winning pizza! All of our thin-crust pizzas are made with our fresh, handmade dough, garden fresh tomato sauce, and our special blend of two provolone cheeses.
• Steak & Cheese (whole) $12.49

Hours

Update Hours

View the Menu

Update Details

Restaurant Description

Add a description here.

Restaurant Photos

View Menu

Write a Review for Steel City Pizza & Sandwich Co.

Share Your
Experience!

Select a Rating Select a Rating!

Reviews for Steel City Pizza & Sandwich Co.

Write a Review

  4.4 stars - Based on 32 reviews

#89 out of 557 restaurants in Erie

#4 of 57 Pizza in Erie

5 star				18 reviews	56%
4 star				11 reviews	34%
3 star				2 reviews	6%
2 star				0 reviews	0%
1 star				1 review	3%

Top Reviews of Steel City Pizza & Sandwich Co.

01/18/2025 - Wang K.
The pizza logs at Steel City Sandwich Company were the best I've ever tasted. While there may be fancier options out there, the value and quality here can't be beat. The staff was friendly and the Pepperoni Balls were a delicious local delicacy that I now can't get enough of.

06/05/2024 - Sara L.
great food

04/23/2023 - Karen
I have never had a bad experience with Steel City's food. Everything is delicious.

07/31/2022 - Amber K
I would not recommend this place! Customer service is horrible and the food is not good! The chicken is rubbery and the fries were fried in old grease. The male they took my order is unprofessional and rude and my change was thrown at me basically.

07/06/2021 - mrspjb
Excellent wings & sauces - wings are breaded, which was different for me, but they are delicious. The stromboli is the best around hands down. You won't find a better sub, the quality of ingredients and the bread are amazing!

06/04/2021 - Sandy
By far, the best pizza & hoagies in town. Always fresh. Well worth the prices too.

10/12/2018 - Kathleen Dorich
Yum! Love this place

01/11/2015 - Kathy
We had a large order and it was ready on time when we picked it up. The food was delicious and worth every penny! The subs are 14' and not too many places offer those, and for a good price too. My favorite is the calzone - the dough is so fresh and tastes so good! Thanks again Steel City for providing Erie with a good choice for great food!!