Old Town Mexican Cafe

Add Review

Call

Website

Menu

Location and Contact

See Map - Get Directions

609 Duval St
Key West, FL 33040

Phone: (305) 296-7500

Website

Neighborhood: Key West

Update Listing

Popular Menu Items

• Carne Asada Burrito $13.99
• A flour tortilla filled with Asada Steak with Rice and Beans, Cilantro, Onions, and Guacamole, and Jalapeño purée sauce.
• Burrito Especial Shredded Chicken Or Shredded Beef $14.99
• Special Burrito filled with Rice and Beans, your choice of Shredded Chicken or Shredded Beef topped with Red Sauce and Cheeses, then baked and topped with sour cream and guacamole.
• Bean & Cheese Burrito $6.99
• A flour tortilla with beans and cheese.
• 4. Two Cheese Enchiladas $16.99
• Two cheese enchiladas served with rice, beans, chips, and a small salad. Comes with the option to add beef, chicken, asada, or additional cheese.
• Fountain Drinks And Coca-cola $3.99
• Enjoy our fountain offerings including options like Rootbeer, Diet Coke, Dr Pepper, Ice Tea, Hi-C Pink Lemonade, Coke, and Sprite. Choose your preferred refreshing drink.

Hours

Update Hours

View the Menu

Update Details

Restaurant Description

Add a description here.

Restaurant Photos

View Menu

Write a Review for Old Town Mexican Cafe

Share Your
Experience!

Select a Rating Select a Rating!

Reviews for Old Town Mexican Cafe

Write a Review

  3.6 stars - Based on 39 reviews

#61 out of 467 restaurants in Key West

#3 of 10 Mexican in Key West

5 star				6 reviews	15%
4 star				15 reviews	38%
3 star				14 reviews	36%
2 star				3 reviews	8%
1 star				1 review	3%

Top Reviews of Old Town Mexican Cafe

04/05/2025 - Ni Z.
I can never get enough of this Mexican restaurant in Key West! The food is fantastic, but the staff really makes the experience unforgettable; they came through for us during a little crisis like true heroes. The vibe is chill with great outdoor seating, and the cheeseburger quesadilla is something you have to try!

06/01/2021 - Will
My wife and I stumbled upon this place as we were walking up Duval St. and decided to stop in. Our waiter, his name Davis Davis, was an absolute treat and such a great server. The food was outstanding, including their key lime pie to top it all off, and it felt like all of the ingredients were super fresh. The margaritas were all varied and delicious. Like most things in Key West and on Duval, the prices were going to be a little high but I felt like the quality certainly matched it. Thanks for a great meal and an unforgettable service experience with Davis!