Keystone Pizza

Add Review

Call

Website

Menu

Location and Contact

See Map - Get Directions

17 S Main St
Payette, ID 83661

Phone: (208) 642-9333

Neighborhood: Payette

Update Listing

Popular Menu Items

• Cheese Pizza (small) $11.68
• Cheese Pizza (medium) $18.18
• Cheese Pizza (large) $23.40
• Orange S (20 Oz) $3.25
• 20 oz
• Gingerale (20 Oz) $3.25
• 20 oz

Hours

Update Hours

View the Menu

Update Details

Restaurant Description

clean comfortable environment, friendly staff, great food

Restaurant Photos

View Menu

Write a Review for Keystone Pizza

Share Your
Experience!

Select a Rating Select a Rating!

Reviews for Keystone Pizza

Write a Review

  4.5 stars - Based on 25 reviews

#5 out of 19 restaurants in Payette

#1 of 2 Pizza in Payette

5 star				16 reviews	64%
4 star				8 reviews	32%
3 star				0 reviews	0%
2 star				0 reviews	0%
1 star				1 review	4%

Top Reviews of Keystone Pizza

04/27/2025 - Travis
I placed a phone order for a large taco pizza, and 2 family bread sticks with marinara dipping sauce. I drove 15 minutes to get there, paid over $42 for the meal, and a tip. Drove home. 2 boxes contained the bread sticks. The 3rd box had a large pizza with marinara/salsa sauce, taco hamburger, and cheese. It was advertised to come with lettuce, tomatoes, olives and onions. And sour cream. I called the store and they said that the toppings box was there, if I wanted to drive back and come pick it up. I asked if it could be delivered because they didn't give it to me, and the fault was with them. The girl asked someone and was told they couldn't send somebody "just to deliver toppings". It wasn't "just delivering toppings" it was rectifying a mistake that your employees made. I am NOT driving 15 minutes each way, burning my gas to correct your mistake. Well done Keystone. You lost ALL of my future business because you wanted to save a couple of bucks.

04/08/2025 - Laura G.
With amazing cheesebread and ranch that hit hard when combined, nostalgic old-school pizza reminiscent of the past, quick service, and a welcoming atmosphere filled with games and affordable prices, this local establishment has become a cherished weekend staple for family fun and great food in Payette.

03/17/2025 - Steven B.
The cheesebread and ranch here create a flavor explosion that transports me back to the classic pizzerias of my childhood. The atmosphere exudes nostalgia, with a cozy seating arrangement and a friendly staff that makes it a great hangout after school or a fun family outing. Despite the occasional delay in service, the hearty, delicious pizza and fantastic breadsticks keep me coming back for more, solidifying this establishment as a cherished local favorite.

07/01/2024 - Jhon H.
yummy

01/23/2021 - Brenda Ackerman
Their pizzas are delicious and they're establishment is very clean and very friendly people