Amenia Steak House

Add Review

Call

Website

Menu

Location and Contact

See Map - Get Directions

4905 Route 44
Amenia, NY 12501

Phone: (845) 789-1520

Website

Neighborhood: Amenia

Update Listing

Hours

Update Hours

View the Menu

Update Details

Restaurant Description

Add a description here.

Restaurant Photos

View Menu

Write a Review for Amenia Steak House

Share Your
Experience!

Select a Rating Select a Rating!

Reviews for Amenia Steak House

Write a Review

  3.9 stars - Based on 35 reviews

#4 out of 16 restaurants in Amenia

#1 of 1 Steakhouse in Amenia

5 star				9 reviews	26%
4 star				18 reviews	51%
3 star				6 reviews	17%
2 star				0 reviews	0%
1 star				2 reviews	6%

Top Reviews of Amenia Steak House

11/15/2024 - W
Staff is always pleasant and helpful..The food is very fresh and well prepared.
The menu is quite varied. Prices are reasonable. What is not to like? Great place to dine.
Would highly recommend.

04/29/2024 - Briana P.
always good

11/01/2020 - Local Designer Legend (Also I’m Amazing)
It's my second time back after the owner made changes and I don't know where to begin. I think I would just like to say this restaurant is everything you wish for from a Steakhouse! Practically priced and just good food. I had their clam chowder as a side dish and I'm hooked on it like a Starbucks!

Like the entrí©e was great, don't get me wrong. But I'm just wondering how they made that clam chowder? It was like I was back at the Outer Banks in North Carolina.

Have you ever eaten something so good that you forget what you were saying or what was on your mind? Like I think I just had a food-paralysis!

11/01/2020 - Guy under me was right!
That clam chowder was something so....welcoming.

02/16/2020 - Chaotte Voigt
Delicious Fresh Food. Staff is Great The place is very Quaint. Love the California burger and my family Love the Steaks!!!

02/14/2020 - MenuPix User
Worst. Service. Ever.

Such a shame because the food is good!

01/04/2020 - MenuPix User
Tonight my fiance and I decided to go to amenia steakhouse. When we walked in we were brought into the backroom for seating and then they realized the table needed to be cleared off so they sat us at the bar to wait, when we sat at the bar the female bartender was extremely rude to us when we told her we were just sat there to wait and would not be ordering drinks. The table was cleared off in less than 5 minutes but we had to stay at the bar for about 15-20 as our waiter walked past us several times, flirting with customers and ignoring us. When we were finally seated we were left to wait once again this time the wait was so long we debated on leaving. Before even ordering drinks the BUS BOY brought us over rolls and tried talking to us because he realized how long we had been waiting. The waiter came over after 35 minutes went by with no drinks and finally took our order all at once. Food was then rushed out of the kitchen and had little to no flavor to it, I didnt see seasoning on anything my pasta dish just tasted like noodles, milk, and raw onion and my fiance's steak had absolutely no seasoning and some of the pieces were not even able to be chewed. During the whole diner the bus boy continued to bring us drinks and get our waiter when needed which is not his job but he was the best part of the whole dinner for being the only person there that cares about the customers seemingly. Extremely disappointed in this experience and we will not be returning.